Increased hippocampal shape asymmetry and volumetric ventricular asymmetry in autism spectrum disorder

Rose Richards, Ellen Greimel, Dorit Kliemann, Inga K. Koerte, Gerd Schulte‐Körne, Martin Reuter, Christian WachingerNeuroImage 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages a large, multi-site dataset to investigate brain asymmetry in individuals with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). They introduce a novel shape asymmetry measure and find increased hippocampal shape asymmetry and ventricular volumetric asymmetry in ASD, suggesting these could be potential biomarkers for the disorder.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is a complex neurodevelopmental condition with a growing prevalence, yet its exact causes and underlying anatomical differences remain debated. While many studies have explored structural brain abnormalities in ASD, research on asymmetry (differences between the left and right hemispheres) in subcortical regions has been limited, often due to small sample sizes and a focus solely on volume. This paper aims to address this gap by investigating both volumetric and shape asymmetries in key subcortical structures (amygdala, hippocampus, and lateral ventricles) within a large cohort, seeking to identify more robust biomarkers for ASD.

Methods

The researchers employed a novel approach to measure brain asymmetry. Instead of just looking at the volume of brain regions, they also analyzed their shape. This was achieved using a method called "shapeDNA," which converts the geometric representation of a brain structure into a vector of spectral shape descriptors. These descriptors are derived from the eigenvalues of the Laplace-Beltrami operator, making them invariant to rigid transformations and reflections.

The core innovation lies in using these shape descriptors to calculate shape asymmetry. This is done by computing the Mahalanobis distance between the shape descriptors of the left and right hemispheres for each individual. This measure captures both directional (consistent difference in one direction) and undirectional (inconsistent difference) asymmetry, offering a more comprehensive view than traditional methods.

For statistical analysis, they used linear regression models, with diagnosis (ASD vs. controls) and sex as independent variables, while controlling for age, scanning site, intracranial volume, and full-scale IQ.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Autism Brain Imaging Data Exchange (ABIDE) database. This is a large, multi-site collection of T1-weighted MRI scans from individuals with ASD and typically developing controls. The authors selected a final sample of 437 individuals with ASD and 511 healthy controls from this dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shape Matters: The study highlights that focusing solely on volume might miss crucial information. Shape asymmetry, captured by novel spectral descriptors, reveals differences not apparent in volumetric analyses.
  • Hippocampal Shape is Different in ASD: The hippocampus, crucial for memory and learning, showed significantly increased shape asymmetry in individuals with ASD compared to controls. This suggests that the subtle geometric distortions, rather than just overall size, are important.
  • Ventricular Asymmetry is Volumetric: While hippocampal asymmetry was primarily a shape phenomenon, ventricular asymmetry in ASD was predominantly volumetric. This implies different underlying mechanisms or manifestations of asymmetry in these distinct brain structures.
  • Sex Differences in Asymmetry: The study found significant sex differences in asymmetry across regions, with males generally exhibiting greater asymmetry than females, irrespective of diagnosis. This underscores the importance of considering sex as a biological variable in neurodevelopmental research.
  • Potential for Biomarkers: The consistent findings in a large cohort suggest that these asymmetries, particularly hippocampal shape asymmetry and ventricular volumetric asymmetry, could be valuable candidates for developing neurodiagnostic classification tools for ASD.

Key Results

  • Hippocampus: Significantly increased shape asymmetry was observed in individuals with ASD compared to controls (p < 0.0001). Volumetric hippocampal asymmetry was not significantly predicted by diagnosis.
  • Lateral Ventricles: Significantly increased volumetric asymmetry was observed in individuals with ASD compared to controls (p = 0.002). Ventricular shape asymmetry was not significantly predicted by diagnosis.
  • Amygdala: Diagnosis did not significantly predict either shape or volumetric asymmetry of the amygdala.
  • Sex Effects: Males showed significantly greater amygdalar shape asymmetry than females. For the hippocampus, sex was a significant predictor for both shape and volumetric asymmetry, with males exhibiting greater asymmetry. For ventricles, sex did not significantly predict either measure.
  • Age: Age was a significant predictor for volumetric ventricular asymmetry, with asymmetry increasing with age.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Heterogeneity: While the ABIDE dataset is large, the ASD sample included individuals with various formerly used DSM-IV-TR subtypes, and the FSIQ scores differed significantly between ASD and control groups, potentially influencing results. The study focused on relatively high-functioning individuals, limiting generalizability to the entire ASD spectrum.
  • Dataset Limitations: The authors acknowledge criticisms of the ABIDE dataset regarding confounding effects of scanner variations across sites. While they argue their methods are robust, future work could benefit from analyzing additional datasets and employing cross-validation.
  • Causality: The study, like most cross-sectional research, cannot establish causality. It's unclear whether ASD causes the observed asymmetries or if these asymmetries contribute to ASD.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest longitudinal studies to track the developmental trajectory of these asymmetries and their relationship with symptom severity. They also emphasize the need for further research using large cohorts and classification experiments to explore the potential of these asymmetries as neurodiagnostic tools.

Summary updated

Abstract

Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a prevalent and fast-growing pervasive neurodevelopmental disorder worldwide. Despite the increasing prevalence of ASD and the breadth of research conducted on the disorder, a conclusive etiology has yet to be established and controversy still exists surrounding the anatomical abnormalities in ASD. In particular, structural asymmetries have seldom been investigated in ASD, especially in subcortical regions. Additionally, the majority of studies for identifying structural biomarkers associated with ASD have focused on small sample sizes. Therefore, the present study utilizes a large-scale, multi-site database to investigate asymmetries in the amygdala, hippocampus, and lateral ventricles, given the potential involvement of these regions in ASD. Contrary to prior work, we are not only computing volumetric asymmetries, but also shape asymmetries, using a new measure of asymmetry based on spectral shape descriptors. This measure represents the magnitude of the asymmetry and therefore captures both directional and undirectional asymmetry. The asymmetry analysis is conducted on 437 individuals with ASD and 511 healthy controls using T1-weighted MRI scans from the Autism Brain Imaging Data Exchange (ABIDE) database. Results reveal significant asymmetries in the hippocampus and the ventricles, but not in the amygdala, in individuals with ASD. We observe a significant increase in shape asymmetry in the hippocampus, as well as increased volumetric asymmetry in the lateral ventricles in individuals with ASD. Asymmetries in these regions have not previously been reported, likely due to the different characterization of neuroanatomical asymmetry and smaller sample sizes used in previous studies. Given that these results were demonstrated in a large cohort, such asymmetries may be worthy of consideration in the development of neurodiagnostic classification tools for ASD.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{richards2020increased,
  author = {Rose Richards and Ellen Greimel and Dorit Kliemann and Inga K. Koerte and Gerd Schulte‐Körne and Martin Reuter and Christian Wachinger},
  title = {{Increased hippocampal shape asymmetry and volumetric ventricular asymmetry in autism spectrum disorder}},
  booktitle = {NeuroImage},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1016/j.nicl.2020.102207},
}
Figure