Increased Evoked Potentials to Arousing Auditory Stimuli during Sleep: Implication for the Understanding of Dream Recall

Raphaël Vallat, Tarek Lajnef, Jean‐Baptiste Eichenlaub, Christian Berthomier, Karim Jerbi, Dominique Morlet, Perrine RubyFrontiers in Human Neuroscience 2017 · DOI

Abstract

High dream recallers (HR) show a larger brain reactivity to auditory stimuli during wakefulness and sleep as compared to low dream recallers (LR) and also more intra-sleep wakefulness (ISW). This study investigated the sleep microstructure of HR and LR to test whether the amplitude of auditory evoked potentials (AEPs) was predictive of arousing reactions. Results suggest that the amplitude of the brain response to stimuli during sleep determines subsequent awakening and that awakening duration—specifically a threshold of approximately 2 minutes—is the critical parameter for successful dream encoding into long-term memory.

Introduction

While dreaming is a near-universal human experience, the frequency with which individuals recall their dreams varies significantly. The "arousal-retrieval model" posits that for a dream to be moved from short-term to long-term memory, the sleeper must wake up during or immediately after the dream. Previous research has identified that "High Recallers" (HR) experience more intra-sleep wakefulness (ISW) than "Low Recallers" (LR), but the physiological mechanisms driving these awakenings and their specific role in memory encoding remained unclear. This study examines whether a more reactive brain causes these awakenings and if the duration of wakefulness is the deciding factor for dream recall.

Methods

The study involved 36 participants, divided into 18 High Recallers (recalling dreams >3 mornings/week) and 18 Low Recallers (recalling dreams <2 mornings/month). Participants underwent a full night of polysomnography (PSG) in a laboratory setting. During sleep, they were presented with auditory stimuli (their own name and an unfamiliar name) at 50 dB. The researchers analyzed:

  • Sleep Microstructure: Manual and automated detection of spindles, K-complexes, rapid eye movements (REMs), and muscle twitches.
  • Event-Related Potentials (ERPs): Auditory Evoked Potentials (AEPs) were calculated to compare brain responses to sounds that caused an "arousing reaction" versus those that did not.

Key Insights

Reactivity and Awakening

The study found that the amplitude of the brain's electrical response to sound—specifically late parieto-occipital positivity and frontal negativity in N2 sleep—is a reliable predictor of whether a sound will trigger an awakening. HR individuals naturally exhibit larger responses, making them nearly twice as likely to have an arousing reaction to environmental stimuli compared to LR individuals.

The Distinction Between Arousal and Awakening

A critical finding was the distinction between brief "arousals" (3–15 seconds) and full "awakenings" (>15 seconds). Interestingly, both HR and LR groups showed similar frequencies of short arousals. The divergence appeared only in full awakenings, suggesting that brief shifts in EEG frequency are insufficient for dream recall.

The 2-Minute Memory Threshold

By correlating physiological data with behavioral studies, the authors propose a "2-minute threshold." The brain appears to require approximately 2 minutes of wakefulness to re-engage the hardware necessary for encoding dreams into long-term memory. Short awakenings (e.g., 30 seconds) are likely too brief for this "reboot," causing the dream to be lost.

Key Results

The data revealed that HR individuals had significantly more "long" awakenings (>1 minute) and fewer "short" awakenings (<1 minute) than LR individuals. Despite these differences in wakefulness, the overall "macrostructure" of sleep (time spent in various stages like REM or N3) remained consistent between the two groups.

Figure 1: Comparison of sleep parameters (awakening/arousal indices and durations) between High (HR) and Low (LR) dream recallers.

Discussion and Limitations

These results suggest that the duration of awakening, rather than the frequency of brief arousals, is the vital parameter for dream recall. However, the study has limitations, including a sample size for AEP analysis that was primarily restricted to N2 sleep due to the need for clean EEG data. Additionally, while external auditory stimuli were used to trigger awakenings, further research is needed to determine if these findings translate perfectly to spontaneous, "natural" awakenings. Future work may focus on the temporo-parietal junction (TPJ) as a potential generator for the increased brain reactivity observed in High Recallers.

Summary updated

Abstract

High dream recallers (HR) show a larger brain reactivity to auditory stimuli during wakefulness and sleep as compared to low dream recallers (LR) and also more intra-sleep wakefulness (ISW), but no other modification of the sleep macrostructure. To further understand the possible causal link between brain responses, ISW and dream recall, we investigated the sleep microstructure of HR and LR, and tested whether the amplitude of auditory evoked potentials (AEPs) was predictive of arousing reactions during sleep. Participants (18 HR, 18 LR) were presented with sounds during a whole night of sleep in the lab and polysomnographic data were recorded. Sleep microstructure (arousals, rapid eye movements (REMs), muscle twitches (MTs), spindles, KCs) was assessed using visual, semi-automatic and automatic validated methods. AEPs to arousing (awakenings or arousals) and non-arousing stimuli were subsequently computed. No between-group difference in the microstructure of sleep was found. In N2 sleep, auditory arousing stimuli elicited a larger parieto-occipital positivity and an increased late frontal negativity as compared to non-arousing stimuli. As compared to LR, HR showed more arousing stimuli and more long awakenings, regardless of the sleep stage but did not show more numerous or longer arousals. These results suggest that the amplitude of the brain response to stimuli during sleep determine subsequent awakening and that awakening duration (and not arousal) is the critical parameter for dream recall. Notably, our results led us to propose that the minimum necessary duration of an awakening during sleep for a successful encoding of dreams into long-term memory is approximately 2 min.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{vallat2017increased,
  author = {Raphaël Vallat and Tarek Lajnef and Jean‐Baptiste Eichenlaub and Christian Berthomier and Karim Jerbi and Dominique Morlet and Perrine Ruby},
  title = {{Increased Evoked Potentials to Arousing Auditory Stimuli during Sleep: Implication for the Understanding of Dream Recall}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Human Neuroscience},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3389/fnhum.2017.00132},
}
Figure