Increased cardiac arrest survival and bystander intervention in enclosed pedestrian walkway systems

Minha Lee, Derya Demirtas, Jason E. Buick, Michael J. Feldman, Sheldon Cheskes, Laurie J. Morrison, Timothy C. Y. ChanResuscitation 2017 · DOI

Introduction

Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) remains a critical public health challenge where survival is often determined by the immediate environment. While significant research has focused on OHCA in residential settings, airports, and casinos, "enclosed pedestrian walkway systems"—vast networks of climate-controlled tunnels and bridges—represent a unique and understudied urban micro-environment.

Toronto’s PATH system, a 30km network connecting over 1,200 shops and transit hubs, serves as a primary example. Unlike airports, these systems lack centralized surveillance and dedicated medical first-responder teams. This study investigates whether the architectural and social characteristics of these high-density hubs influence bystander intervention and patient outcomes.

Methodology

Researchers conducted a 10-year retrospective population-based cohort study (2006–2016) using data from the Rescu Epistry, a regional cardiac arrest database compliant with Resuscitation Outcomes Consortium (ROC) standards. The study area was divided into three distinct categories:

  1. Toronto: The broader city area, excluding the downtown core.
  2. Downtown: The high-density urban center, excluding the PATH system.
  3. PATH-accessible: Arrests occurring within the PATH network, specifically between the first basement and the third floor.

Spatial analysis was performed using ArcGIS to map arrest locations against city shapefiles. The study compared patient demographics, bystander interventions (CPR and AED use), and survival to hospital discharge across these three environments.

Results

The findings reveal a significant "PATH effect" on cardiac arrest outcomes. Survival to hospital discharge for OHCAs occurring within the PATH was 33.3%, nearly double the 18.5% survival rate observed in the rest of Toronto.

Bystander Intervention

The most striking difference was in bystander response. In the PATH system, bystanders were significantly more likely to witness the event and take action:

  • Bystander CPR: 73.5% in the PATH vs. 56.6% city-wide.
  • AED Use: 42.6% in the PATH vs. 11.0% city-wide.

Incidence and Response

The PATH system exhibited a high concentration of emergencies, with 5.39 OHCAs per square kilometer per year, compared to 2.21 in the Downtown core and 0.29 city-wide. Paramedic response times were also slightly faster in the PATH (5.34 minutes) than the city average (6.30 minutes), likely due to the central location and accessibility of the downtown core.

Discussion

The high survival rates in the PATH system suggest that high-density pedestrian environments can act as "safe havens" for cardiac emergencies. Several factors contribute to this phenomenon:

Infrastructure as a First Responder

Despite the absence of dedicated medical teams, the PATH achieved survival rates comparable to airports and casinos. This suggests that high visibility and intuitive placement of Automated External Defibrillators (AEDs) can empower the public to act effectively. The high rate of "shockable" rhythms (72.9% in the PATH vs. 45.5% city-wide) indicates that arrests are witnessed almost immediately, allowing for intervention before the heart rhythm deteriorates.

Seasonal Refuge

The study noted a distinct seasonal pattern: over 40% of PATH arrests occurred during winter, compared to approximately 28% city-wide. As a climate-controlled refuge, the PATH concentrates high-risk populations during harsh weather, placing them in an environment where help is more readily available and bystanders are more numerous.

Limitations

The study acknowledges several limitations. A significant portion of PATH arrests (11 of 49) occurred at Union Station, a major transit hub which may skew results due to its unique risk profile. Additionally, the lack of precise "denominator data" (the total number of daily PATH users) makes it difficult to calculate true per-person risk. Finally, the analysis did not fully account for vertical barriers, such as stairs or elevators, which can complicate paramedic access in multi-level structures.

Conclusion

Enclosed pedestrian walkway systems represent a vital frontier for urban emergency planning. The high rates of bystander intervention and survival within Toronto’s PATH demonstrate that high-traffic, well-equipped urban environments can significantly improve outcomes for cardiac arrest. Future urban design should prioritize optimized AED placement and public engagement strategies within these complex 3D environments to further enhance the chain of survival.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{lee2017increased,
  author = {Minha Lee and Derya Demirtas and Jason E. Buick and Michael J. Feldman and Sheldon Cheskes and Laurie J. Morrison and Timothy C. Y. Chan},
  title = {{Increased cardiac arrest survival and bystander intervention in enclosed pedestrian walkway systems}},
  booktitle = {Resuscitation},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1016/j.resuscitation.2017.06.013},
}
Figure