Abstract
Obesity is strongly associated with musculoskeletal disorders of the lower limb, including ankle instability and resulting gait problems. In the present study, we aimed to examine, using paired comparisons of subjects, whether moderate duration of obesity in patients with mild to moderate elevations of body mass index (BMI), changes the fibrous contents of muscles that support the ankle mortices, namely calf and plantar muscles. MRI image segmentation and pixel correlations by grey level co-occurrence matrix (GLCM) and entropy were used to analyse the changes. The differences in the means between groups (both GLCM and entropy) were significant from control lean populations (P<0.0001, ANOVA) for the parameters examined for both the calf and the plantar muscles. Reduction in weight should thus be a first-line approach in preventing these changes that may significantly affect quality of life due to gait disturbances.
Introduction
While the link between obesity and musculoskeletal disorders like ankle instability is well-established, the underlying cause is often simplified as "excessive mechanical loading." However, recent research suggests that obesity might trigger fundamental changes in the internal composition of the muscles themselves. This study investigates whether obesity triggers fibrosis—the development of excess fibrous connective tissue—within the calf and plantar muscles that support the ankle mortise. If functional muscle tissue is replaced by stiff, non-contractile fibrous tissue, the muscle's ability to stabilize the joint during movement is significantly diminished.
Methodology
The researchers employed non-invasive high-resolution imaging and advanced statistical texture analysis to quantify tissue changes:
- MRI Imaging: Subjects underwent 3T MRI scans (T1-weighted sagittal and T2-weighted axial) of the calf and foot.
- Image Segmentation: Specific muscle compartments (anterolateral calf, posterior calf, and plantar muscles) were isolated using Metamorph software and a Sobel edge detector.
- Texture Analysis: To quantify fibrosis without invasive biopsies, the authors utilized the Grey Level Co-occurrence Matrix (GLCM) and Pixel Entropy. GLCM identifies patterns of tissue heterogeneity, while Entropy measures the "chaos" or randomness in pixel distribution.
- Angular Second Moment (ASM): This was used as an additional measure of image homogeneity.
The study categorized subjects into four groups to control for age and BMI: Lean Youth (25–35 years), Obese Youth (25–35 years), Lean Aged (55–65 years), and Obese Aged (55–65 years). Subjects over 65 and those with confounding conditions like diabetes or tobacco use were excluded to ensure findings were specifically related to obesity.
Results
The quantitative differences between lean and obese subjects were statistically profound ($P < 0.0001$ across most parameters). The data indicates that obesity significantly increases the fibrous-to-skeletal muscle volumetric ratio across all examined compartments.
Key findings include:
- Fibrous-to-Muscle Ratio: In the anterolateral calf, the ratio increased from 0.03 ± 0.004 in lean youth to 0.23 ± 0.0071 in obese youth. Similarly, in plantar muscles, the ratio rose from 0.02 ± 0.002 in lean youth to 0.244 ± 0.006 in obese youth.
- Entropy Scores: In the posterior calf, entropy (a proxy for tissue fibrosis) rose from 2.34 ± 0.41 in lean youth to 5.67 ± 0.86 in obese youth.
- Age-Independent Fibrosis: Notably, young obese individuals exhibited fibrotic levels similar to or exceeding those of lean elderly individuals, suggesting that obesity accelerates the "aging" of muscle tissue.
Discussion
The study highlights a mechanical-biological feedback loop: obesity causes unequal joint loading, which triggers pro-fibrotic reactions. These reactions, potentially mediated by the TGFβ1 pathway, weaken joint support, leading to further instability. The posterior calf and plantar muscles showed more pronounced changes than the anterolateral group, suggesting that muscles primarily responsible for postural stabilization are most susceptible to obesity-induced remodeling.
Limitations and Future Directions
While the correlation is strong, the study's small cohort and static MRI measurements mean that a definitive causal link between fibrosis and functional instability remains to be established through dynamic studies. Furthermore, the duration of obesity's impact requires more granular investigation.
Conclusion
Obesity induces significant structural remodeling of the lower limb muscles, characterized by increased fibrosis. These changes likely compromise the mechanical support of the ankle joint, contributing to chronic instability and gait issues. Weight loss remains the primary clinical recommendation to prevent irreversible myogenic damage and maintain quality of life.
Summary updated