Increased body mass index is linked to systemic inflammation through altered chromatin co-accessibility in human preadipocytes

Kristina M. Garske, Asha Kar, Caroline Comenho, Brunilda Balliu, David Z. Pan, Yash Bhagat, Gregory M. Rosenberg, Amogha Koka, Sankha Subhra Das, Zong Miao, Janet S. Sinsheimer, Jaakko Kaprio, Kirsi H. Pietiläinen, Päivi PajukantaNature Communications 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that increased Body Mass Index (BMI) alters the way DNA is organized within the nucleus of preadipocytes, leading to changes in gene activity that contribute to systemic inflammation. By analyzing monozygotic twins with differing BMIs, researchers identified specific regions of the genome where this altered organization is linked to inflammation markers and gene-environment interactions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Obesity is a major driver of chronic low-grade inflammation, which in turn fuels numerous comorbidities like type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease. While adipose tissue is known to play a role, the precise mechanisms by which preadipocytes (the precursors to fat cells) contribute to this inflammatory state remain unclear. Specifically, how environmental factors like increased BMI might disrupt the normal function of these cells at a molecular level is a key question. The authors aim to bridge this gap by investigating how BMI influences the epigenetic landscape of preadipocytes, focusing on the higher-order organization of chromatin.

Methods

The study employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Monozygotic (MZ) Twin Design: The core of the study utilized MZ twin pairs discordant for BMI (a difference of at least 3 kg/m²). This powerful design allows researchers to control for genetic background and isolate the effects of environmental factors (like BMI) on epigenetic changes.
  • Epigenetic Profiling (ATAC-seq): Assay for Transposase-Accessible Chromatin sequencing (ATAC-seq) was used to map regions of open chromatin, indicating areas of active gene regulation, in primary human preadipocytes.
  • Transcriptomic Profiling (RNA-seq): RNA sequencing was performed to measure gene expression levels in the same preadipocytes.
  • Chromatin Interaction Analysis (pCHi-C): Promoter Capture Hi-C (pCHi-C) data was used to identify physical interactions between regulatory elements (promoters and enhancers) in the genome.
  • Genomic Compartmentalization Analysis: The researchers adapted methods to infer A/B compartments, which represent large-scale, subnuclear organization of the genome into active (A) and inactive (B) regions, based on ATAC-seq data. They specifically focused on "co-accessibility," a measure of how coordinated the accessibility is across different genomic regions.
  • UK Biobank Data Integration: Data from the UK Biobank was used to investigate the link between identified genomic regions, BMI, and systemic inflammation (measured by C-reactive protein, CRP). This involved partitioned heritability analysis (LDSC) and gene-environment interaction (GxE) scans.
  • Bioinformatic and Statistical Analyses: Various computational tools and statistical methods were used for data processing, alignment, peak calling, differential analysis, clustering (UMAP, Louvain), and enrichment analyses (GO, TF motif).

Datasets

  • Human Primary Preadipocytes: Isolated from BMI-discordant monozygotic twin pairs.
  • UK Biobank (UKB): A large-scale dataset used for genetic association studies, including BMI and CRP measurements.
  • ENCODE and Roadmap Epigenomics Project Data: Used for annotating chromatin states.
  • GTEx Data: Utilized for confirming gene expression in human adipose tissue.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • BMI Alters Nuclear Architecture: The most striking finding is that increased BMI is associated with altered "co-accessibility" of open chromatin in preadipocytes. This suggests that BMI doesn't just affect individual genes but disrupts the higher-order organization of the genome within the nucleus.
  • Preadipocytes as a Link to Inflammation: The study strongly implicates preadipocytes as a key cell type mediating the link between obesity and systemic inflammation, by showing how BMI-induced epigenetic changes in these cells can influence inflammatory markers.
  • Genomic Compartments as Functional Units: The A/B compartment framework proved useful in identifying functionally distinct regions of the genome within preadipocytes, with "A compartments" being enriched for active regulatory elements and gene expression.
  • "Primed" Regions are Key: Interestingly, the genomic regions most affected by BMI and most strongly linked to inflammation heritability were those identified as "developmentally primed" (cluster 1), rather than those with high enhancer activity or promoter interactions (cluster 5). This suggests that pre-existing cellular states might be particularly vulnerable to BMI-induced disruption.
  • Gene-Environment Interactions in Action: The study provides evidence that specific genomic regions identified as having altered co-accessibility in higher BMI individuals are enriched for genetic variants that interact with BMI to influence CRP levels, highlighting a direct mechanism for gene-environment interaction.

Key Results

  • Altered Co-accessibility: Approximately 88.5 Mb of active subnuclear compartments (A compartments) showed altered co-accessibility between higher and lower BMI MZ siblings.
  • Inflammation Heritability: These altered A compartments were significantly enriched for the heritability of C-reactive protein (CRP), a marker of systemic inflammation.
  • GxE Signals: Regions with altered co-accessibility showed a higher accumulation of low p-value genotype-by-BMI interaction signals for CRP in the UK Biobank.
  • Differential Gene Expression: 52 differentially expressed genes were identified in reprogrammed A compartments in higher BMI siblings, with 21 showing correlation between expression and ATAC-seq peak accessibility.
  • Specific Gene Example: The study highlights INPP5K as a potential BMI-responsive gene, with its regulatory elements showing altered co-accessibility and differential expression linked to BMI.

Limitations and Future Work

  • In Vitro Culture: The study acknowledges that preadipocytes were cultured in vitro, which might influence their epigenetic characteristics. Future work could involve more direct analysis of in vivo preadipocytes.
  • Sample Size: While the MZ twin design is powerful, the number of twin pairs for some analyses was limited, potentially impacting the power to detect subtle effects, especially for individual open chromatin peaks.
  • Heterogeneity of BMI: The complex etiology of increased BMI means that environmental factors are highly heterogeneous. Future studies with larger cohorts and more detailed environmental data would be beneficial.
  • Functional Validation: The study identifies candidate genes and regions. Further functional validation using techniques like CRISPR-based gene editing in preadipocytes is needed to confirm the causal roles of these identified elements in obesity-related inflammation.
  • Broader Genomic Mechanisms: While focusing on higher-order chromatin organization, the authors suggest investigating other genomic regulatory mechanisms beyond co-accessibility to fully understand BMI's impact on preadipocytes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Obesity-induced adipose tissue dysfunction can cause low-grade inflammation and downstream obesity comorbidities. Although preadipocytes may contribute to this pro-inflammatory environment, the underlying mechanisms are unclear. We used human primary preadipocytes from body mass index (BMI) -discordant monozygotic (MZ) twin pairs to generate epigenetic (ATAC-sequence) and transcriptomic (RNA-sequence) data for testing whether increased BMI alters the subnuclear compartmentalization of open chromatin in the twins' preadipocytes, causing downstream inflammation. Here we show that the co-accessibility of open chromatin, i.e. compartmentalization of chromatin activity, is altered in the higher vs lower BMI MZ siblings for a large subset ( ~ 88.5 Mb) of the active subnuclear compartments. Using the UK Biobank we show that variants within these regions contribute to systemic inflammation through interactions with BMI on C-reactive protein. In summary, open chromatin co-accessibility in human preadipocytes is disrupted among the higher BMI siblings, suggesting a mechanism how obesity may lead to inflammation via gene-environment interactions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{garske2023increased,
  author = {Kristina M. Garske and Asha Kar and Caroline Comenho and Brunilda Balliu and David Z. Pan and Yash Bhagat and Gregory M. Rosenberg and Amogha Koka and Sankha Subhra Das and Zong Miao and Janet S. Sinsheimer and Jaakko Kaprio and Kirsi H. Pietiläinen and Päivi Pajukanta},
  title = {{Increased body mass index is linked to systemic inflammation through altered chromatin co-accessibility in human preadipocytes}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-023-39919-y},
}
Figure