Incorporation of parental phenotypic data into multi‐omic models improves prediction of yield‐related traits in hybrid rice

Yang Xu, Yue Zhao, Xin Wang, Ying Ma, Pengcheng Li, Zefeng Yang, Xuecai Zhang, Chenwu Xu, Shizhong XuPlant 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces a novel approach to hybrid breeding by integrating parental phenotypic data (phenome) into multi-omic prediction models. By doing so, they significantly improve the prediction accuracy of yield-related traits in rice, demonstrating that even seemingly "poor" predictors can substantially boost performance when combined with others. This work paves the way for more efficient and accurate hybrid breeding strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Hybrid breeding is a cornerstone of modern agriculture, significantly boosting crop yields through heterosis. However, identifying the most promising hybrid combinations from a vast pool of possibilities is a major bottleneck. Traditional methods rely on extensive field trials, which are time-consuming and resource-intensive. Genomic selection (GS) offers a solution by predicting hybrid performance using genetic information, but its predictive power can be limited for complex traits. While multi-omic data (genomics, transcriptomics, metabolomics) have shown promise in enhancing GS, a crucial piece of information has been overlooked: the phenotypic performance of the parent lines themselves. Experienced breeders often use parental phenotypes as a guide, yet this valuable data has been largely absent from sophisticated predictive models. This paper aims to bridge this gap by incorporating parental phenotypic data into multi-omic prediction frameworks to improve hybrid prediction accuracy.

Methods

The researchers employed a Best Linear Unbiased Prediction (BLUP) framework, a standard statistical method in quantitative genetics, to build their prediction models. A key methodological innovation was the adaptation and application of a fast HAT (Hybridization Accuracy Test) method for multi-omic prediction. This method, originally developed for genomic prediction, offers a computationally efficient alternative to traditional cross-validation (CV) for evaluating predictive accuracy, especially crucial when dealing with multiple omic datasets.

They explored various combinations of four predictor sets:

  • Genome (G): SNP markers.
  • Transcriptome (T): Gene expression data.
  • Metabolome (M): Metabolite profiles.
  • Phenome (P): Parental phenotypic data for the target traits.

Predictors were coded to account for both additive and dominance effects. They evaluated 15 combinations of these predictors and compared different models for incorporating parental phenotypic data, including treating it as random or fixed effects, and using data from the target trait only or all traits.

Datasets

The study utilized a rice dataset comprising:

  • Genomic data: 1619 recombinant bins inferred from 270,820 high-quality SNPs from 210 recombinant inbred lines (RILs).
  • Transcriptomic data: 24,994 gene expression traits quantified from flag leaves of the 210 RILs.
  • Metabolomic data: 317 metabolites from germinated seeds and 683 from flag leaves of the 210 RILs.
  • Phenotypic data: Grain yield (YIELD), number of tillers per plant (TILLER), number of grains per panicle (GRAIN), and 1000 grain weight (KGW) for 278 hybrids and their parents, collected over two years.

The authors also used publicly available wheat and maize datasets to validate the HAT method's performance against traditional CV methods.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Parental Phenotypes Matter (Even if "Weak"): The study strongly demonstrates that parental phenotypic data, even if individually not the strongest predictor, significantly boosts the predictive power of multi-omic models when combined with other data sources. This validates the intuition of experienced breeders.
  • Synergy in Multi-Omics: Combining different omic datasets consistently outperforms using any single omic source. This highlights the complementary nature of genomic, transcriptomic, and metabolomic information in capturing complex biological processes.
  • The Power of Combined Predictors: The best predictive performance was achieved with the most comprehensive predictor set (GTMP), suggesting that integrating all available information is key for maximizing accuracy.
  • Computational Efficiency is Crucial: The modified HAT method proved to be a significant improvement over traditional cross-validation, drastically reducing computation time (from hours to minutes) for multi-omic predictions, making it more practical for breeding applications.
  • Trait-Specific Interactions: The effectiveness of different predictors varies across traits, underscoring the need for tailored model selection based on the target trait's genetic architecture.

Key Results

  • Improved Predictability: Incorporating parental phenotypic data (P) into various omic predictors increased predictability by an average of 13.6% for grain yield, 54.5% for tillers per plant, 19.9% for grains per panicle, and 8.3% for 1000 grain weight.
  • Best Model: The AD-All model (integrating additive and dominance effects of all predictors, with parental phenotypes treated as fixed effects across all traits) was found to be the most effective for incorporating parental phenotypic data.
  • HAT vs. CV: The modified HAT method produced predictabilities very similar to traditional CV methods but was orders of magnitude faster, making it a practical alternative.
  • Comprehensive Predictor Performance: The GTMP predictor combination (Genome, Transcriptome, Metabolome, Phenome) generally yielded the highest predictabilities across traits.
  • Significant Gains: For YIELD, combining P with G improved predictability by up to 41%. For TILLER, the gain was even more substantial at 65.5%.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Environmental Sensitivity of Omics: The authors acknowledge that transcriptomic and metabolomic data can be dynamic and sensitive to environmental variations, requiring careful consideration of tissue selection and sampling times. This can also increase costs due to the need for multiple replicates.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: While multi-omic data improves prediction, the cost of generating such data needs to be balanced against the gains in predictability. The study suggests that combining genomic data with parental phenotypic data might be a cost-effective strategy.
  • Phenomic Prediction Potential: The study highlights that using parental phenotypic data from multiple traits (phenomic prediction) is more effective than using data from a single trait, suggesting that incorporating a wider array of phenotypic data could further enhance prediction accuracy.
  • Model Extension: The authors plan to extend the HAT method to other prediction models beyond BLUP, such as LASSO and Bayesian methods, to further enhance its applicability.

This research represents a significant step forward in leveraging multi-omic data and parental information for more efficient and accurate hybrid breeding, with broad implications for crop improvement.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hybrid breeding has been shown to effectively increase rice productivity. However, identifying desirable hybrids out of numerous potential combinations is a daunting challenge. Genomic selection holds great promise for accelerating hybrid breeding by enabling early selection before phenotypes are measured. With the recent advances in multi-omic technologies, hybrid prediction based on transcriptomic and metabolomic data has received increasing attention. However, the current omic-based hybrid prediction has ignored parental phenotypic information, which is of fundamental importance in plant breeding. In this study, we integrated parental phenotypic information into various multi-omic prediction models applied in hybrid breeding of rice and compared the predictabilities of 15 combinations from four sets of predictors from the parents, that is genome, transcriptome, metabolome and phenome. The predictability for each combination was evaluated using the best linear unbiased prediction and a modified fast HAT method. We found significant interactions between predictors and traits in predictability, but joint prediction with various combinations of the predictors significantly improved predictability relative to prediction of any single source omic data for each trait investigated. Incorporation of parental phenotypic data into various omic predictors increased the predictability, averagely by 13.6%, 54.5%, 19.9% and 8.3%, for grain yield, number of tillers per plant, number of grains per panicle and 1000 grain weight, respectively. Among nine models of incorporating parental traits, the AD-All model was the most effective one. This novel strategy of incorporating parental phenotypic data into multi-omic prediction is expected to improve hybrid breeding progress, especially with the development of high-throughput phenotyping technologies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2020incorporation,
  author = {Yang Xu and Yue Zhao and Xin Wang and Ying Ma and Pengcheng Li and Zefeng Yang and Xuecai Zhang and Chenwu Xu and Shizhong Xu},
  title = {{Incorporation of parental phenotypic data into multi‐omic models improves prediction of yield‐related traits in hybrid rice}},
  booktitle = {Plant},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1111/pbi.13458},
}
Figure