Incorporating Water Molecules into Highly Accurate Binding Affinity Prediction for Proteins and Ligands

Diya Zhang, Qiaozhen Meng, Fei GuoInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces GraphWater-Net, a novel deep learning model that significantly improves protein-ligand binding affinity prediction by explicitly incorporating the crucial role of water molecules. By representing protein-ligand-water complexes as graphs and leveraging a Graphormer architecture, the model achieves state-of-the-art performance, outperforming existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Predicting how strongly a small molecule (ligand) will bind to a protein is a cornerstone of computer-aided drug design. This binding affinity dictates a drug's efficacy. While many computational methods exist, they often overlook the dynamic and influential role of water molecules. Water molecules are not passive bystanders; they actively participate in the binding process by forming hydrogen bonds, mediating interactions, and influencing both the enthalpy and entropy of the system. Ignoring these water molecules can lead to inaccurate binding affinity predictions. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a model that explicitly accounts for the presence and interactions of water molecules within the protein-ligand binding site.

Methods

The core of this work is the GraphWater-Net model. It employs a graph-based approach to represent the complex system.

  • Graph Representation: Proteins, ligands, and importantly, predicted water molecules are converted into a graph structure. Atoms become nodes, and interactions (covalent bonds, hydrogen bonds, etc.) become edges.
  • Water Molecule Prediction: Two established methods, HydraMap and 3D-RISM, are used to identify and predict the locations of water molecules within the protein's binding pocket. These predicted water sites are then integrated into the graph representation.
  • Graphormer Architecture: The model leverages the Graphormer network, a powerful graph neural network architecture. Graphormer excels at capturing complex relationships within graph structures by using multi-head attention mechanisms to learn node and edge features, considering both local and global interactions.
  • Feature Extraction and Prediction: The Graphormer network extracts rich features from the protein-ligand-water graph. These features are then fed into a Softmax regression function to predict the binding affinity.

The novelty lies in the explicit integration of predicted water molecules into the graph representation and the subsequent application of the Graphormer architecture to learn from this enriched structural information.

Datasets

  • PDBbind refined set (version 2016): This dataset was used for training the model. It contains a large collection of experimentally determined protein-ligand complex structures and their binding affinity data.
  • CASF-2016 test set: This is a standard benchmark dataset used for evaluating the performance of binding affinity prediction methods. The paper uses the core set of 285 complexes from CASF-2016 for testing.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Water is not just solvent; it's a participant: The study strongly reinforces that water molecules are integral to the binding process, not just passive solvent. Their inclusion significantly boosts prediction accuracy.
  • Graph representation is powerful for complex systems: Representing the intricate interplay of protein, ligand, and water as a graph allows Graphormer to effectively learn complex interaction patterns.
  • Combining water prediction methods is beneficial: Using both HydraMap and 3D-RISM for water site prediction leads to more robust results than relying on a single method, suggesting complementary strengths.
  • Graphormer's attention mechanism captures crucial interactions: The model's ability to weigh different parts of the graph and their interactions is key to its success.

Key Results

  • Improved Accuracy: GraphWater-Net achieved a Pearson correlation coefficient ($R_p$) of 0.868 on the CASF-2016 test set. This is a significant improvement, outperforming state-of-the-art methods by 0.022 to 0.129.
  • Impact of Water: Including water molecules in the model input increased the $R_p$ by 0.154 compared to a model without water.
  • Parameter Optimization: The optimal model configuration involved an edge threshold of 6 Å, 12 attention heads, and 4 Graphormer layers.
  • Case Study Success: For the 1E66 complex (acetylcholinesterase with huprine X), which relies heavily on water-mediated interactions, GraphWater-Net achieved a prediction deviation of only -0.01, significantly outperforming other methods.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Structural Changes: The study acknowledges that it hasn't yet explored how the inclusion of water molecules might affect the predicted positions of the original receptor and ligand molecules within the complex.
  • Dynamic Behavior: Future work could investigate the dynamic behavior of binding pockets through molecular dynamics simulations or flexibility analysis to gain deeper insights into their conformational changes.
  • Hydrophilic/Hydrophobic Interactions: A more detailed analysis of these specific types of interactions is suggested for further model enhancement.
  • Generalizability: While the model shows promise, further validation on a wider range of protein-ligand systems and different types of interactions would be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the binding process between proteins and ligand molecules, water molecules play a pivotal role by forming hydrogen bonds that enable proteins and ligand molecules to bind more strongly. However, current methodologies for predicting binding affinity overlook the importance of water molecules. Therefore, we developed a model called GraphWater-Net, specifically designed for predicting protein-ligand binding affinity, by incorporating water molecules. GraphWater-Net employs topological structures to represent protein atoms, ligand atoms and water molecules, and their interactions. Leveraging the Graphormer network, the model extracts interaction features between nodes within the topology, alongside the interaction features of edges and nodes. Subsequently, it generates embeddings with attention weights, inputs them into a Softmax function for regression prediction, and ultimately outputs the predicted binding affinity value. Experimental results on the Comparative Assessment of Scoring Functions (CASF) 2016 test set show that the introduction of water molecules into the complex significantly improves the prediction performance of the proposed model for protein and ligand binding affinity. Specifically, the Pearson correlation coefficient (<i>R<sub>p</sub></i>) exceeds that of current state-of-the-art methods by a margin of 0.022 to 0.129. By integrating water molecules, GraphWater-Net has the potential to facilitate the rational design of protein-ligand interactions and aid in drug discovery.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2024incorporating,
  author = {Diya Zhang and Qiaozhen Meng and Fei Guo},
  title = {{Incorporating Water Molecules into Highly Accurate Binding Affinity Prediction for Proteins and Ligands}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms252312676},
}
Figure