Inclusive photoproduction of neutral strange particles at 20 GeV

K. Abe, T. C. Bacon, J. Ballam, A. V. Bevan, H. H. Bingham, J. E. Brau, K. Braune, D. Brick, W. Bugg, J. Butler, W. Cameron, J. T. Carroll, C. V. Cautis, J. S. Chima, H.o. Cohn, D.c. Colley, G. T. Condo, S. Dado, R. N. Diamond, R. Erickson, T. Fieguth, R. C. Field, B. Franek, N. Fujiwara, K. Furuno, R. Gearhart, D. Gershoni, Jacques Goldberg, G. P. Gopal, A. T. Goshaw, E. Hafen, G. Hall, Edwin R. Hancock, T. Handler, H. J. Hargis, P. Haridas, E. L. Hart, K. Hasegawa, T. Hayashino, I. Hideta, R. I. Hulsizer, M. Jobes, G. Kalmus, D. P. Kelsey, J. Kent, T. Kitagaki, A. Levy, Peter W. Lucas, W. A. Mann, R. Merenyi, R. H. Milburn, C. Milsténe, K. C. Moffeit, Joseph J. Murray, A. Napier, S. Noguchi, F. Ochiai, S.w. OʼNeale, Y. Ohtani, A. P. T. Palounek, I. A. Pless, P. Rankin, A. H. Rogers, E. Ronat, H. Rudnicka, H. Sagawa, Takahiro Sato, J. Schneps, J. T. Shank, A. Shapiro, R. Sugahara, Y. Suzuki, K. Takahashi, K. Tamai, S. Tanaka, S. Tether, W. D. Walker, M. Widgoff, Christina Wilkins, S. Wolbers, C. A. Woods, Akihiro Yamaguchi, R. K. Yamamoto, S. Yamashita, Y. Yoshimura, G.p. Yost, H. YutaPhysical 1984 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive study of neutral strange particle production (K⁰s, Λ, and Λ̄) in 20 GeV photon-proton (γp) interactions. The findings reveal striking similarities to particle production in hadronic and leptonic collisions, suggesting a common underlying mechanism. This work provides crucial data for understanding the fundamental processes of particle creation in high-energy physics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

High-energy particle physics aims to understand the fundamental constituents of matter and the forces that govern them. A key aspect of this is studying how particles are produced in collisions. While significant data existed for particle production using hadron and lepton beams, inclusive photoproduction of neutral strange particles was relatively under-explored, with limited data available from lower-energy experiments. This paper addresses this gap by providing detailed measurements of K⁰s, Λ, and Λ̄ production in γp interactions at 20 GeV, allowing for a more direct comparison with other interaction types and a deeper understanding of the underlying production mechanisms.

Methods

The experiment utilized the SLAC Hybrid Facility, a 1-meter bubble chamber exposed to a monoenergetic photon beam. This setup offered nearly full acceptance for detecting the decay products of neutral strange particles, which are identified by their decay kinematics. The analysis involved:

  • Event Reconstruction: Identifying and reconstructing particle tracks within the bubble chamber.
  • Particle Identification: Using invariant mass distributions and kinematic fitting to uniquely identify K⁰s, Λ, and Λ̄ decays from various hypotheses (e.g., K⁰ → π⁺π⁻, Λ → pπ⁻, Λ̄ → p̄π⁺).
  • Ambiguity Resolution: Developing criteria to resolve cases where a decay could be attributed to multiple particle types.
  • Cross Section Measurement: Calculating production cross sections by counting observed particles and applying corrections for detection efficiencies, decay probabilities, and escape probabilities.
  • Distribution Analysis: Studying the distributions of kinematic variables like Feynman scaling variable ($x$) and transverse momentum ($p_T$) to probe production mechanisms.
  • Polarization Measurement: Analyzing the decay products to determine the polarization of Λ and Λ̄ particles.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of approximately 2.4 million pictures from the SLAC 1m bubble chamber exposed to a 20 GeV photon beam. The analysis presented here is based on about 20% of the processed film, corresponding to 97,100 hadronic interactions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Universal Production Mechanisms: The observed features of neutral strange particle production in γp interactions are remarkably similar to those seen in hadronic (πp, pp) and leptonic (e⁺e⁻) collisions. This strongly suggests that a common, fundamental mechanism underlies particle production across different beam types and energies.
  • Photon as a Meson-like Probe: The higher production fractions of strange particles in γp interactions compared to some hadronic interactions suggest that the photon can act like a meson, with an enhanced propensity for producing strange quarks.
  • Fragmentation vs. Target Excitation: The energy dependence of K⁰s production, rising with energy similarly to charged multiplicity, points towards a fragmentation process. In contrast, Λ production, less energy-dependent beyond a threshold, is associated more with target excitations.
  • Polarization Similarities: The measured polarization of Λ particles shows a striking resemblance in both shape and normalization to results from π⁻p interactions, further supporting the idea of common underlying dynamics.

Key Results

  • Production Cross Sections: Measured cross sections for K⁰s, Λ, and Λ̄ production, as well as for K(890) and Σ(1385) resonances. For example, the K⁰s photoproduction cross section is approximately 1.7 times larger than that of Λ production.
  • Kinematic Distributions: Inclusive distributions of the Feynman scaling variable ($x$) and transverse momentum ($p_T$) for K⁰s, Λ, and Λ̄ were presented and compared with theoretical models, showing good agreement with quark fragmentation models.
  • Λ Polarization: An overall Λ polarization of 0.09 ± 0.07 was measured, with a clear dependence on $x$ (positive in the backward hemisphere, negative in the forward) and $p_T$.
  • Multiplicities: Average multiplicities of charged particles in events with K⁰s, Λ, and Λ̄ were found to be similar and slightly lower than the average for all hadronic events.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Ambiguity Resolution: The procedure for resolving ambiguous V⁰ identifications was noted as "admittedly somewhat arbitrary," though various complex procedures were tried without significant changes to the results.
  • Normalization Uncertainties: The authors acknowledge a potential normalization uncertainty of 30-40% in their data and in some comparison data.
  • Low Statistics for Λ̄ Polarization: The statistical precision for Λ̄ polarization measurements was limited, making detailed $z$ and $p_T$ dependent studies difficult.
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests further theoretical work to explain the observed similarities across different interaction types and to refine models of particle production, particularly concerning the role of quark fragmentation and target excitation. The comparison with lepton scattering experiments also opens avenues for further investigation into the photon's role as a probe.

Summary updated

Abstract

We have studied inclusive production of ${K}_{S}^{0}$, $\ensuremath{\Lambda}$, and $\overline{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ particles in 20-GeV $\ensuremath{\gamma}p$ interactions and have found features similar to those observed in both hadronic and leptonic interactions. The production cross sections, charged-particle multiplicities, and average $\ensuremath{\Lambda}$ polarization are reported. Inclusive distributions of $x$ and ${p}_{T}$ are shown and discussed in terms of quark fragmentation models. Production cross sections for ${K}^{*}(890)$ and ${\ensuremath{\Sigma}}^{*}(1385)$ are also reported.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{abe1984inclusive,
  author = {K. Abe and T. C. Bacon and J. Ballam and A. V. Bevan and H. H. Bingham and J. E. Brau and K. Braune and D. Brick and W. Bugg and J. Butler and W. Cameron and J. T. Carroll and C. V. Cautis and J. S. Chima and H.O. Cohn and D.C. Colley and G. T. Condo and S. Dado and R. N. Diamond and R. Erickson and T. Fieguth and R. C. Field and B. Franek and N. Fujiwara and K. Furuno and R. Gearhart and D. Gershoni and Jacques Goldberg and G. P. Gopal and A. T. Goshaw and E. Hafen and G. Hall and Edwin R. Hancock and T. Handler and H. J. Hargis and P. Haridas and E. L. Hart and K. Hasegawa and T. Hayashino and I. Hideta and R. I. Hulsizer and M. Jobes and G. Kalmus and D. P. Kelsey and J. Kent and T. Kitagaki and A. Levy and Peter W. Lucas and W. A. Mann and R. Merenyi and R. H. Milburn and C. Milsténe and K. C. Moffeit and Joseph J. Murray and A. Napier and S. Noguchi and F. Ochiai and S.W. OʼNeale and Y. Ohtani and A. P. T. Palounek and I. A. Pless and P. Rankin and A. H. Rogers and E. Ronat and H. Rudnicka and H. Sagawa and Takahiro Sato and J. Schneps and J. T. Shank and A. Shapiro and R. Sugahara and Y. Suzuki and K. Takahashi and K. Tamai and S. Tanaka and S. Tether and W. D. Walker and M. Widgoff and Christina Wilkins and S. Wolbers and C. A. Woods and Akihiro Yamaguchi and R. K. Yamamoto and S. Yamashita and Y. Yoshimura and G.P. Yost and H. Yuta},
  title = {{Inclusive photoproduction of neutral strange particles at 20 GeV}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1984},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.29.1877},
}
Figure