TL;DR
This study reveals how inclusive leadership can curb employees' "creative territory behavior" (hoarding ideas and resources) by fostering harmonious work passion. Crucially, this effect is amplified when employees have high work autonomy and strong status-seeking motivation, offering practical insights for managers to optimize team dynamics and innovation.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In today's competitive landscape, organizations thrive on innovation, which starts with individual ideas. However, a significant hurdle is "creative territory behavior," where employees protect their ideas and intellectual property, hindering collaboration and knowledge sharing. This behavior stems from a fear of losing competitive advantage or not receiving due credit. While negative leadership styles are known to exacerbate this, the impact of inclusive leadership—which emphasizes openness and sharing—on this protective behavior has been less explored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating the mechanisms through which inclusive leadership can mitigate creative territory behavior and identifying the contextual factors that influence this relationship.
Methods
The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:
- Situational Experiment (Study 1): MBA students were randomly assigned to one of four experimental conditions, simulating scenarios with varying levels of inclusive leadership and work autonomy. Participants imagined themselves as employees and responded to questionnaires measuring their perceptions of these leadership styles and their own harmonious work passion and creative territory behavior. This method helps establish causal relationships and internal validity.
- Multi-time Questionnaire Survey (Study 2): A larger sample of employees from various industries in China completed surveys at two different time points. This longitudinal design allowed for the measurement of inclusive leadership, work autonomy, status competition motivation, harmonious work passion, and creative territory behavior, enabling the testing of the full proposed model and enhancing external validity.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Inclusive Leadership as a Double-Edged Sword: While inclusive leadership is generally positive, its impact on creative territory behavior isn't straightforward. It can reduce this behavior, but only under specific conditions.
- Harmonious Work Passion is Key: The study identifies "harmonious work passion" as the crucial mediator. Inclusive leaders foster this passion by meeting employees' psychological needs (autonomy, competence, belonging), which in turn makes employees less likely to engage in territorial behavior.
- The Power of Autonomy: When employees have high work autonomy, they are more receptive to inclusive leadership. This autonomy allows them to exercise their own choices and feel more internally motivated, amplifying the positive effects of inclusive leadership on their work passion.
- Status Matters: Employees driven by a desire for status and recognition (status competition motivation) are more likely to benefit from inclusive leadership, especially when combined with high work autonomy. This combination creates an environment where they can showcase their abilities and gain status through collaboration rather than protection.
- A Triple Interaction: The most significant finding is the three-way interaction between inclusive leadership, work autonomy, and status competition motivation. Inclusive leadership's positive impact on harmonious work passion (and thus its reduction of creative territory behavior) is strongest when both work autonomy and status competition motivation are high.
Key Results
- Study 1 (Experiment): Confirmed that inclusive leadership negatively impacts creative territory behavior and positively influences harmonious work passion. It also showed that work autonomy moderates the relationship between inclusive leadership and harmonious work passion, with higher autonomy leading to stronger positive effects.
- Study 2 (Survey):
- Inclusive leadership negatively correlated with creative territory behavior (r = -0.494).
- Inclusive leadership positively correlated with harmonious work passion (r = 0.382).
- Harmonious work passion negatively correlated with creative territory behavior (r = -0.451).
- Harmonious work passion significantly mediated the negative relationship between inclusive leadership and creative territory behavior (indirect effect = -1.311).
- Work autonomy significantly moderated the mediating effect, with the indirect effect being stronger under high work autonomy.
- A significant three-way interaction was found, indicating that inclusive leadership's positive effect on harmonious work passion is maximized when both work autonomy and status competition motivation are high.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Self-Report Bias: Reliance on employee self-evaluation reports may introduce social desirability bias. Future research could incorporate multi-source evaluations (e.g., peer and leader ratings) and longitudinal designs to better establish causality.
- Cultural Specificity: The study was conducted in a Chinese cultural context, which may influence findings related to "face" and status. Future research should expand to cross-cultural contexts (e.g., comparing Chinese and Western enterprises) to assess the universality of the model.
- Individual-Level Focus: The study primarily examined individual-level effects. Future work could explore aggregation effects at team or organizational levels, such as the impact of inclusive team climates on creative territory behavior.
- Limited Interaction Significance: The triple interaction effect of work autonomy and status competition motivation was not significant in all situations, suggesting potential influences from industry or task characteristics that warrant further investigation.
- Theoretical Expansion: While grounded in self-determination theory, future studies could incorporate other theoretical frameworks (e.g., resource conservation theory, social identity theory) for cross-validation.
Summary updated