Inactivation of Salmonella enterica in black peppercorn by fluidization with hydrogen peroxide vapor

E.t. Summers, Surabhi Wason, Jeyamkondan Subbiah, Rossana Villa‐RojasFrontiers in Food Science and Technology 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Salmonella remains the most prevalent bacterial pathogen linked to spice-related recalls and outbreaks. As low-moisture foods (LMF), spices present unique challenges for decontamination, as traditional methods like ethylene oxide, irradiation, or steam often face regulatory, consumer, or quality-related hurdles. This study investigates the efficacy of hydrogen peroxide vapor (HPV) combined with fluidization as an alternative pasteurization technology for whole black peppercorns. Treatments were conducted at 45°C and 60°C for 30 and 60 minutes. Results showed a Salmonella reduction of 1.41–2.83 log CFU/g. While chemical quality parameters like piperine content and antioxidant activity remained largely unaffected, significant residual hydrogen peroxide (up to 500 ppm) and minor color changes were observed. These findings suggest that while HPV is a promising "green" technology, further process optimization is required for commercial safety and quality standards.

Introduction

Spices are consistently ranked among the top three food categories for microbiological recalls, primarily due to Salmonella contamination. Because they are classified as low-moisture foods (LMF), pathogens can survive in spices for extended periods without active growth, posing a significant public health risk.

Current validated microbial reduction techniques face substantial limitations. Ethylene oxide (EtO) is associated with health and environmental concerns; irradiation often encounters consumer resistance; and traditional steam treatments can severely degrade the sensory qualities—such as aroma and color—of the spice. Consequently, there is an emerging need for alternative "green" technologies. Hydrogen peroxide vapor (HPV) is a strong candidate because it decomposes into harmless water and oxygen. This study explores the use of HPV in a fluidized bed system to ensure the vapor effectively reaches the complex, wrinkled surfaces of whole peppercorns.

Materials and Methods

The research utilized a custom-built experimental apparatus designed to facilitate fluidization of the spice samples during HPV treatment.

Experimental apparatus showing (A) the treatment chamber and (B) the HPV generator connected in a closed-loop system.

Experimental Design

Whole black peppercorns were inoculated with a five-strain Salmonella enterica cocktail (strains: Agona, Montevideo, Mbandaka, Tennessee, and Reading Moff), selected for their relevance to low-moisture food outbreaks. The samples were treated in a fluidized bed where an upward-moving stream of air and HPV suspended the peppercorns, maximizing surface area exposure.

The study tested two temperatures (45°C and 60°C) and two dwell times (30 and 60 minutes). Microbial reduction and residual hydrogen peroxide were measured immediately (0 h), 24 h, and 48 h post-treatment.

Quality and Residual Analysis

To evaluate the impact on spice quality, the team performed a comprehensive chemical audit using HPLC for piperine content and GC-MS for volatile compounds (aroma profile) across 110 identified compounds. Total phenolics and antioxidant activity were assessed via spectrophotometry, and color changes were measured using a colorimeter. Residual $H_2O_2$ levels were tracked using specialized test strips to ensure food safety compliance.

Results and Discussion

Microbial Efficacy

The treatment achieved Salmonella reductions ranging from 1.41 to 2.83 log CFU/g. The highest reduction was recorded at 60°C with a 60-minute dwell time after 48 hours of storage. Interestingly, the lower temperature (45°C) resulted in higher relative saturation and intermittent "micro-condensation" or fogging. In HPV sterilization, this thin liquid film can be more lethal to bacteria than dry vapor, a phenomenon known as the "condensation paradox."

However, the reduction did not reach the 5-log threshold typically required for FDA-validated kill steps. This is likely due to "surface shielding," where the deep wrinkles of the peppercorn morphology provide micro-niches that protect bacteria from vapor contact.

Quality Preservation and Color Changes

A key finding was the resilience of the peppercorn's chemical profile. Piperine (the source of "heat"), total phenolics, and antioxidant activity remained stable. Of the major volatile compounds, only minor components like Sabinene and $\beta$-Pinene showed negligible changes.

The primary qualitative drawback was a visible color change. Treated peppercorns exhibited a total color difference ($\Delta E$) of approximately 4.0, appearing lighter and grayer than untreated controls, likely due to the bleaching properties of $H_2O_2$.

The Residual Challenge

A significant hurdle for commercial adoption is the persistence of $H_2O_2$. Even 48 hours post-treatment, residual levels remained as high as 200–500 ppm. This far exceeds the 0.5 ppm limit typically allowed for food-contact surfaces in many jurisdictions, indicating that current aeration methods are insufficient.

Conclusion

Fluidized HPV treatment represents a promising, "gentle" pasteurization method that preserves the essential chemical characteristics of black peppercorns. However, the technology is not yet ready for industrial application. Future work must focus on improving microbial kill rates—perhaps through higher concentrations or vacuum assistance—and developing more aggressive aeration techniques to eliminate chemical residuals. Additionally, the bleaching effect needs mitigation to maintain the aesthetic standards of the spice industry.

Summary updated

Abstract

Salmonella is the most common bacterial pathogen associated with product recalls and outbreaks in spices. Spices are in the top three food categories for greatest number of recalls due to microbiological contamination. Current validated microbial reduction techniques for spices are tied to human health and environment concerns or negatively affect the quality characteristics of the spice which has led to the emerging of alternative technologies such as hydrogen peroxide vapor (HPV). hydrogen peroxide vapor treatment was conducted at two different temperatures (45°C and 60°C) and two dwell times (30 and 60 min). Microbial reduction and residual hydrogen peroxide were measured at three storage times: 0 h (immediately after treatment), 24 and 48 h post-treatment. The effect of HPV on the quality of whole black peppercorn was evaluated 48 h post-treatment based on changes in piperine content, total phenolics, antioxidant activity, total volatile compounds, and color. Reduction in Salmonella population ranged from 1.41–2.83 log CFU/g. Residual hydrogen peroxide of up to 500 ppm was still detected on samples after 48 h of storage. All quality parameters except for color remained unaffected between treated and untreated whole black peppercorn. The study highlights the need to explore further process design modifications before conclusions can be made on the efficacy of HPV treatment as a means for low-moisture foods pasteurization.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{summers2023inactivation,
  author = {E.T. Summers and Surabhi Wason and Jeyamkondan Subbiah and Rossana Villa‐Rojas},
  title = {{Inactivation of Salmonella enterica in black peppercorn by fluidization with hydrogen peroxide vapor}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Food Science and Technology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/frfst.2023.1119715},
}
Figure