In vitro neutrophil migration is associated with inhaled corticosteroid treatment and serum cytokines in pediatric asthma

Solveig Lemmel, Markus Weckmann, Anna Wohlers, Adan Chari Jirmo, Ruth Grychtol, Isabell Ricklefs, Gyde Nissen, Anna Bachmann, Shantanu Singh, Juan Carlos Caicedo, Thomas Bahmer, Gesine Hansen, Erika von Mutius, Klaus F. Rabe, Oliver Fuchs, Anna‐Maria Dittrich, Bianca Schaub, Christine Happle, Anne E. Carpenter, Matthias Kopp, Tim BeckerFrontiers in Pharmacology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that neutrophils from children with asthma exhibit impaired migration towards the chemoattractant LTB4, a defect that is partially reversed by inhaled corticosteroid (ICS) treatment. Interestingly, a specific "Th1-high" asthma endotype shows particularly reduced and randomized neutrophil migration, suggesting this cellular behavior could serve as a biomarker for asthma severity and treatment response.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Asthma is a complex disease with diverse presentations, often categorized by phenotypes and endotypes. While Th2-driven inflammation is common, a "Th1-high" endotype is linked to severe, therapy-refractory asthma and neutrophil involvement. Previous work indicated that neutrophils from asthmatics have reduced chemotaxis (directed movement) towards leukotriene B4 (LTB4), a key molecule in inflammatory responses. This study aimed to clarify whether this reduced chemotaxis is a general feature of asthma, how it's affected by inhaled corticosteroid (ICS) treatment, and if it's specifically exacerbated in the Th1-high endotype. Understanding these cellular mechanisms could lead to better diagnostic tools and treatment monitoring for pediatric asthma.

Methods

The core of this study utilizes a sophisticated Simplified Migration Assay (SiMA), a microfluidic technique developed by the authors. This assay allows for high-content, single-cell tracking of neutrophil migration in response to chemoattractants like LTB4 and fMLP.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Neutrophil Isolation: Neutrophils were isolated from blood samples using density centrifugation and erythrocyte lysis.
  • SiMA Workflow: Neutrophils were loaded onto microfluidic chips and exposed to chemoattractant gradients. Time-lapse microscopy captured their movement.
  • Deep Learning for Tracking: A U-Net model was employed for image segmentation and cell tracking, enabling the extraction of detailed morphological and dynamic parameters for each neutrophil.
  • Feature Extraction: Over 25 features were extracted per cell, including speed, directionality (gradient precision), and chemotactic response (percentage of cells migrating towards the chemoattractant).
  • Unsupervised Clustering (UMAP): High-dimensional migration data was projected into a 2D "SiMA landscape" using Uniform Manifold Approximation and Projection (UMAP) to identify distinct patient clusters based on their migratory profiles.
  • Chip Cytometry: Neutrophil surface receptor expression (e.g., BLT1, FPR1, CD62L, CD184) was analyzed using chip cytometry to investigate potential molecular underpinnings of altered migration.
  • Serum Cytokine Measurement: Serum cytokine levels were measured using a multiplex assay to identify Th1-high endotypes.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the ALLIANCE cohort, a longitudinal study of children with asthma and healthy controls.

  • Participants: 75 asthmatic children and 13 healthy controls.
  • Data Collected: Demographic information, clinical data (including ICS treatment status and dosage), serum cytokine levels, and in vitro neutrophil migration data.
  • Subgroup Analysis: Patients were stratified based on ICS treatment (naive vs. treated) and Th1 cytokine levels (Th1-high vs. Th1-low).

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study leverages existing patient cohorts and established analytical techniques.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Asthma Impairs Neutrophil Migration: The fundamental finding is that neutrophils from asthmatic children, in general, show a reduced ability to migrate towards LTB4 compared to healthy controls. This suggests a systemic issue with neutrophil function in asthma.
  • ICS Treatment Partially Rescues Migration: Inhaled corticosteroid (ICS) treatment appears to partially restore neutrophil migration towards LTB4, bringing it closer to control levels. This highlights a direct impact of therapy on innate immune cell function.
  • Th1-High Endotype is Distinct: The "Th1-high" asthma phenotype, characterized by elevated IL-2 and IFN-γ, exhibits a particularly pronounced defect in neutrophil migration. Their neutrophils are not only less likely to move towards LTB4 but also move in a more randomized fashion.
  • Receptor Expression Correlates with Migration: Differences in surface receptor expression, specifically lower BLT1 on ICS-treated neutrophils and altered CD62L/CD184 levels in Th1-high patients, offer potential molecular explanations for the observed migratory defects.
  • SiMA Landscape as a Diagnostic Tool: The unsupervised clustering analysis using the SiMA landscape effectively separates patient groups (controls, naive asthmatics, treated asthmatics), suggesting this multidimensional analysis of migration could be a valuable tool for phenotyping and monitoring asthma.

Key Results

  • Reduced LTB4 Chemotaxis in Asthma: Asthmatic children showed a significantly reduced chemotactic response towards LTB4 (51% of trajectories) compared to healthy controls (73% of trajectories). This effect was not observed for fMLP or IL8.
  • ICS Treatment Improves Migration: While ICS treatment didn't fully normalize migration, it significantly improved the speed of neutrophil migration towards LTB4 in asthmatics, bringing it closer to control levels.
  • Th1-High Phenotype Migration Deficit: Th1-high asthmatics showed significantly reduced chemotactic response and gradient precision towards LTB4 and fMLP compared to Th1-low asthmatics.
  • Receptor Expression Differences:
    • ICS-treated asthmatics had significantly less BLT1 expression on their neutrophils compared to untreated asthmatics.
  • Th1-high asthmatics showed significantly more CD62L and less CD184 (CXCR4) expression.
  • SiMA Landscape Clustering: Unsupervised clustering revealed distinct migratory profiles for control, ICS-naive, and ICS-treated asthmatics, with a subset of ICS-treated patients showing a unique profile. Th1-high patients formed a distinct cluster separate from Th1-low patients.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Small Sample Size: The overall cohort size, particularly for specific subgroups (e.g., Th1-high patients, different ICS dosages), limits statistical power for definitive conclusions on dose-response relationships.
  • Methodological Differences: The study notes potential differences in migration assay setups compared to previous work, which might explain discrepancies (e.g., with Sackmann et al.).
  • Severity of Asthma: The study focused on children with relatively normal lung function, and the findings might not directly extrapolate to severe childhood asthma, which is often characterized by higher neutrophil counts and different inflammatory profiles.
  • Cytokine Specificity: While Th1 cytokines were investigated, other endotypes (Th2, Th9, Th17) did not show significant differences in migration in this study.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Clinical Trials: Conducting double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled cross-over studies to better disentangle the dose-dependent effects of ICS on neutrophil migration.
  • Investigating the Th1-High Cluster: Further research is needed to understand the clinical significance and underlying mechanisms of the distinct migratory cluster observed in some ICS-treated patients.
  • CXCR4/LTB4 Interaction: Exploring the role of CXCR4 expression levels in neutrophils and their interaction with LTB4-induced chemotaxis.
  • Monitoring Tool: Developing the SiMA protocol and neutrophil receptor analysis as a potential tool for monitoring asthma treatment efficacy and disease severity.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> Different asthma phenotypes are driven by molecular endotypes. A Th1-high phenotype is linked to severe, therapy-refractory asthma, subclinical infections and neutrophil inflammation. Previously, we found neutrophil granulocytes (NGs) from asthmatics exhibit decreased chemotaxis towards leukotriene B4 (LTB<sub>4</sub>), a chemoattractant involved in inflammation response. We hypothesized that this pattern is driven by asthma in general and aggravated in a Th1-high phenotype. <b>Methods:</b> NGs from asthmatic nd healthy children were stimulated with 10 nM LTB<sub>4</sub>/100 nM N-formylmethionine-leucyl-phenylalanine and neutrophil migration was documented following our prior SiMA (simplified migration assay) workflow, capturing morphologic and dynamic parameters from single-cell tracking in the images. Demographic, clinical and serum cytokine data were determined in the ALLIANCE cohort. <b>Results:</b> A reduced chemotactic response towards LTB<sub>4</sub> was confirmed in asthmatic donors regardless of inhaled corticosteroid (ICS) treatment. By contrast, only NGs from ICS-treated asthmatic children migrate similarly to controls with the exception of Th1-high donors, whose NGs presented a reduced and less directed migration towards the chemokines. ICS-treated and Th1-high asthmatic donors present an altered surface receptor profile, which partly correlates with migration. <b>Conclusions:</b> Neutrophil migration <i>in vitro</i> may be affected by ICS-therapy or a Th1-high phenotype. This may be explained by alteration of receptor expression and could be used as a tool to monitor asthma treatment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lemmel2022vitro,
  author = {Solveig Lemmel and Markus Weckmann and Anna Wohlers and Adan Chari Jirmo and Ruth Grychtol and Isabell Ricklefs and Gyde Nissen and Anna Bachmann and Shantanu Singh and Juan Carlos Caicedo and Thomas Bahmer and Gesine Hansen and Erika von Mutius and Klaus F. Rabe and Oliver Fuchs and Anna‐Maria Dittrich and Bianca Schaub and Christine Happle and Anne E. Carpenter and Matthias Kopp and Tim Becker and Tim Becker},
  title = {{In vitro neutrophil migration is associated with inhaled corticosteroid treatment and serum cytokines in pediatric asthma}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Pharmacology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fphar.2022.1021317},
}
Figure