In Situ Measurement of NO, NO2, and H2O in Combustion Gases Based on Near/Mid-Infrared Laser Absorption Spectroscopy

Jing Li, Renjie Li, Yan Liu, Fei Li, Xin Lin, Xilong Yu, Weiwei Shao, Xiang Xu2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel laser absorption spectroscopy technique for simultaneously measuring trace amounts of NO and NO2 in hot, humid combustion exhaust gases. By combining linear calibration-free wavelength modulation spectroscopy (LCF-WMS) with a temperature profile-fitting strategy, the method effectively overcomes significant interference from water vapor, a major challenge in existing techniques.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern gas turbines operate at higher temperatures to improve efficiency, but this also leads to increased emissions of nitrogen oxides (NOx), which are harmful air pollutants. Accurately monitoring these ultra-low NOx emissions in real-time within the harsh, high-temperature, and humid environment of combustion exhaust is crucial for optimizing combustion processes and meeting environmental regulations. Existing methods often struggle with interference from water vapor (H2O), which is abundant in combustion gases, and the non-uniform temperature and gas composition along the line of sight. This paper aims to provide a reliable, in-situ, and quantitative method for measuring NO and NO2 under these challenging conditions.

Methods

The core of the proposed method is the Linear Calibration-Free Wavelength Modulation Spectroscopy (LCF-WMS) technique. This approach is advantageous because it can decouple the laser characteristics from the gas absorption signal, making it suitable for non-uniform gas fields. To further enhance accuracy and address the strong interference from H2O, the researchers employed a temperature profile-fitting strategy. This involves using near-infrared TDLAS to independently measure the H2O concentration and then incorporating this information into the spectral fitting process for NO and NO2.

Specifically, the study utilized:

  • Near-infrared DFB laser (~1.31 µm): For H2O detection.
  • Mid-infrared Quantum Cascade Lasers (QCLs): One near 5.2 µm for NO and another near 6.25 µm for NO2.

The LCF-WMS technique was applied at different harmonic levels:

  • Second harmonic (2f): Used for NO and H2O detection.
  • Fourth harmonic (4f): Employed for NO2 detection. The 4f harmonic was chosen for NO2 because it exhibits reduced sensitivity to water vapor interference compared to lower harmonics.

The experimental setup involved a combustion exhaust tube with a controlled temperature gradient, and the data processing involved iterative fitting of simulated harmonic signals to the measured ones, taking into account both target species and interfering gases.

Datasets

The paper relies on the HITRAN database for spectroscopic parameters (line strengths, broadening coefficients, etc.) of various gases, including H2O, NO, NO2, CO, CO2, and CH4. These parameters are essential for simulating the absorption spectra and developing the fitting algorithms.

The experimental data was collected from a premixed CH4/air flat flame generated in a McKenna burner, with varying equivalence ratios (Φ) from 0.73 to 0.99. This experimental setup provided the combustion exhaust gases with controlled composition and temperature profiles.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LCF-WMS with Temperature Profile Fitting is Key: The combination of LCF-WMS and an independent H2O measurement with temperature profile fitting is crucial for overcoming the significant H2O interference in combustion exhaust.
  • 4f Harmonic for NO2 is Effective: Using the fourth harmonic of the WMS signal for NO2 detection significantly reduces the impact of water vapor, a critical improvement for accurate NO2 measurements in humid environments.
  • Non-Uniformity is Manageable: The method demonstrates robustness in non-uniform temperature and gas composition fields, which are typical in combustion environments, by incorporating temperature profile data.
  • Ultra-Low NOx Detection is Achieved: The technique successfully detected ultra-low NOx emissions, which are challenging for many existing sensors.
  • H2O Interference is Quantified: The study highlights that while H2O interference is a major challenge, it can be effectively quantified and accounted for by using a separate H2O measurement.

Key Results

  • H2O Measurement Agreement: The measured mole fractions of H2O showed good agreement (within 1.5%) with theoretical values calculated using Chemkin, validating the near-infrared H2O sensing.
  • NOx Detection Limits: The study demonstrated the capability of detecting ppm-level NO and NO2. For example, at Φ = 0.89, the measured NO concentration was around 7.6 ppm with a relative precision of ~30%, and NO2 was around 1.5 ppm with a relative precision of ~70%.
  • Noise Levels: The 2s noise levels for NO, NO2, and H2O were reported to be in the range of 0.4–1.0 ppm, 0.5–0.9 ppm, and 1.9–2.4 ppm, respectively, with corresponding relative precisions.
  • Validation Against Gas Analyzer: The normalized NO emission trends from the optical measurement closely matched those from a Testo 350 gas analyzer, providing confidence in the method's performance.
  • Temperature Gradient Impact: The study confirmed that temperature gradients along the line of sight can affect absorbance measurements, but the proposed method effectively accounts for this.

Limitations and Future Work

  • NO2 Measurement Accuracy: While the 4f harmonic reduces H2O interference, the accuracy of NO2 measurements can still be affected by the spectral features of water vapor, especially at high internal energy levels. Further work is needed for more precise characterization of these water transitions.
  • CH4 Interference: The presence of methane (CH4) was noted to negatively influence NO2 detection, particularly at higher temperatures.
  • Random Noise: For ultra-low NOx concentrations (e.g., at lower equivalence ratios), the random noise can exceed the predicted concentration, limiting measurement efficiency.
  • Fuel-Lean Conditions Recommended: The authors suggest performing experiments under fuel-lean conditions to minimize potential interference from unburned hydrocarbons (UHC) and improve NO2 measurement accuracy.
  • Future Improvements: The authors suggest that the developed technique can be further improved in terms of spatial and temporal resolution, making it suitable for real-time monitoring of combustion exhaust from gas turbines. Future work could also focus on better understanding and mitigating CH4 interference.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{li2022situ,
  author = {Jing Li and Renjie Li and Yan Liu and Fei Li and Xin Lin and Xilong Yu and Weiwei Shao and Xiang Xu},
  title = {{In Situ Measurement of NO, NO2, and H2O in Combustion Gases Based on Near/Mid-Infrared Laser Absorption Spectroscopy}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22155729},
}

Loading related content...

Figure