In situ mapping of activity distribution and oxygen evolution reaction in vanadium flow batteries

Kaijie Ma, Yunong Zhang, Le Liu, Jingyu Xi, Xinping Qiu, Tian Guan, Yonghong HeNature Communications 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Understanding spatial distribution difference and reaction kinetics of the electrode is vital for enhancing the electrochemical reaction efficiency. Here, we report a total internal reflection imaging sensor without background current interference to map local current distribution of the electrode in a vanadium redox flow battery during cyclic voltammetry (CV), enabling mapping of the activity and reversibility distribution with the spatial resolution of a single fiber. Three graphite felts with different activity are compared to verify its feasibility. In long-term cyclic voltammetry, the oxygen evolution reaction is proved to enhance activity distribution, and homogeneity of the electrode and its bubble kinetics with periodic fluctuation is consistent with the cyclic voltammetry curve, enabling the onset oxygen evolution/reduction potential determination. Higher activity and irreversibility distribution of the electrode is found in favor of the oxygen evolution reaction. This sensor has potential to detect in situ, among other processes, electrochemical reactions in flow batteries, water splitting, electrocatalysis and electrochemical corrosion.

Introduction

Vanadium redox flow batteries (VFBs) are a leading technology for long-duration grid energy storage, but their efficiency is often limited by the non-uniform performance of their electrodes. Typically, researchers rely on "bulk" measurements—like cyclic voltammetry (CV)—which provide an average performance value for the entire cell. However, these averages hide local "hotspots" or "dead zones" caused by uneven material properties or the formation of gas bubbles during the Oxygen Evolution Reaction (OER). Until now, it has been extremely difficult to visualize these local variations without interfering with the battery's chemistry. Understanding this spatial distribution is the key to designing more efficient, longer-lasting electrodes.

The TIRi Sensor and Experimental Setup

To address this, researchers developed a custom Total Internal Reflection imaging (TIRi) sensor. This setup allows for the mapping of local electrochemical activity without the interference of background currents.

Schematic of the TIRi sensor setup for in situ battery monitoring.

The sensor operates on the principle of total internal reflection at the interface between a prism and the battery electrolyte. When light hits this interface at a specific angle, an "evanescent wave" penetrates approximately 938 nm into the electrolyte. As the battery runs, the concentration of vanadium ions near the electrode changes, altering the electrolyte's refractive index and the intensity of the reflected light. By capturing these intensity changes with a high-resolution camera, the system calculates local current density across the electrode surface. Unlike Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPRi) sensors, which require a gold film that can peel off or interfere with reactions, this TIRi setup is chemically "silent" and stable in the harsh, acidic environment of a flow battery.

Mapping Activity at the Single-Fiber Scale

A major breakthrough of this technique is its spatial resolution. The sensor achieves a resolution of approximately 16 μm, which is significant given that standard graphite fibers are roughly 13 μm in diameter. This allows the system to effectively monitor the activity and reversibility distribution of individual fibers.

High-resolution TIRi mapping of graphite felt electrodes, resolving individual fibers (~16-17 μm).

Using this high-resolution mapping, the researchers compared three types of electrode materials: standard Graphite Felt (GF), Thermal Activated Graphite Felt (TGF), and Porous Graphite Felt (PGF). The results showed that PGF exhibited the highest activity and best reversibility, followed by TGF, with standard GF performing the worst. The sensor successfully mapped four critical parameters: peak oxidation current ($|i_{pa}|$), peak reduction current ($|i_{pc}|$), the reversibility ratio, and peak potential separation ($ΔE$).

The Role of Oxygen Evolution

Traditionally, the Oxygen Evolution Reaction (OER) is viewed as a nuisance because it creates bubbles that block the electrode surface. However, this study revealed a more complex role for OER. Over long-term cycling (35 cycles), the peak oxidation current density distribution shifted from ~1.98 mA/cm² to ~2.31 mA/cm². This suggests that OER actually improves activity distribution over time by introducing oxygen-containing functional groups to the carbon surface, making the electrode more active and homogeneous as it ages.

Furthermore, the study found that bubbles do not form randomly. They are statistically more likely to appear in regions characterized by high activity but also high irreversibility (where the energy barrier for the reverse reaction is high). The TIRi sensor was able to visually determine the exact potential at which oxygen evolution begins, matching the "kinks" observed in traditional electrochemical curves while providing spatial context.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While the TIRi sensor provides unprecedented detail, it is currently limited to a surface-only view, unable to map activity deep within the 3D structure of thick graphite felts. Additionally, large bubbles can temporarily block the optical signal. Despite these limitations, the sensor's ability to provide in situ, high-resolution mapping of electrochemical reactions makes it a powerful tool. Beyond flow batteries, this technology could be adapted for studying water splitting, electrocatalysis, and real-time monitoring of metal corrosion.

Summary updated

Abstract

Understanding spatial distribution difference and reaction kinetics of the electrode is vital for enhancing the electrochemical reaction efficiency. Here, we report a total internal reflection imaging sensor without background current interference to map local current distribution of the electrode in a vanadium redox flow battery during cyclic voltammetry (CV), enabling mapping of the activity and reversibility distribution with the spatial resolution of a single fiber. Three graphite felts with different activity are compared to verify its feasibility. In long-term cyclic voltammetry, the oxygen evolution reaction is proved to enhance activity distribution, and homogeneity of the electrode and its bubble kinetics with periodic fluctuation is consistent with the cyclic voltammetry curve, enabling the onset oxygen evolution/reduction potential determination. Higher activity and irreversibility distribution of the electrode is found in favor of the oxygen evolution reaction. This sensor has potential to detect in situ, among other processes, electrochemical reactions in flow batteries, water splitting, electrocatalysis and electrochemical corrosion.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2019situ,
  author = {Kaijie Ma and Yunong Zhang and Le Liu and Jingyu Xi and Xinping Qiu and Tian Guan and Yonghong He},
  title = {{In situ mapping of activity distribution and oxygen evolution reaction in vanadium flow batteries}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-019-13147-9},
}
Figure