In Situ Growth of COF/PVA-Carrageenan Hydrogel Using the Impregnation Method for the Purpose of Highly Sensitive Ammonia Detection

Xiyu Chen, Min Zeng, Tao Wang, Wangze Ni, Jianhua Yang, Nantao Hu, Tong Zhang, Zhi YangSensors 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel flexible hydrogel sensor by integrating covalent organic frameworks (COFs) with a polyvinyl alcohol-carrageenan (PVA-Carrageenan) matrix. This composite hydrogel demonstrates highly sensitive and rapid detection of ammonia (NH3) at room temperature, while also exhibiting exceptional stability and mechanical flexibility, paving the way for advanced wearable gas sensing applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The detection of ammonia (NH3) is crucial for various applications, including medical diagnostics (as a biomarker for kidney disease), environmental monitoring, and personal safety. While flexible gas sensors offer portability and integration into wearable devices, existing technologies often suffer from issues like COF particle aggregation, poor conductivity, and mechanical rigidity, leading to reduced sensitivity, slow response times, and instability. Specifically, traditional COF-based sensors can be brittle and lack the durability required for real-world applications. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by creating a robust, flexible, and highly sensitive NH3 sensor using a composite hydrogel approach.

Methods

The core innovation lies in the in situ growth of COFs within a flexible PVA-Carrageenan (κPVA) hydrogel template. This method avoids the aggregation issues often seen with pre-synthesized COF particles. The researchers explored several synthesis routes, with the most promising being the impregnation and in situ growth method.

Here's a breakdown:

  • Hydrogel Synthesis: A base κPVA hydrogel was prepared by crosslinking PVA with κ-carrageenan, followed by the addition of monomers and crosslinkers.
  • COF Integration:
    • One-Pot Method: This involved embedding COF precursors (TAPT monomer or pre-synthesized COF particles) directly into the hydrogel matrix during its formation.
  • Impregnation and In Situ Growth Method: This was the key approach. A pre-formed κPVA hydrogel was first swollen in an acidic solution containing a COF precursor (TAPT). This swollen hydrogel was then immersed in an oil phase containing another COF precursor (DHTA). This allowed for the in situ growth of COF film and particles directly onto and within the hydrogel network. This method resulted in the formation of a composite hydrogel (labeled KPVA-5) with COF particles embedded in the conductive network and a COF film coating the surface.
  • Characterization: Standard techniques like Field-Emission Scanning Electron Microscopy (FE-SEM) and Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FT-IR) were used to analyze the morphology and chemical composition of the hydrogels and COFs.
  • Gas Sensing Performance: Electrical conductivity measurements and dynamic response tests were conducted using an Agilent 4156 C system. Sensors were exposed to varying concentrations of NH3 at room temperature.
  • Mechanical Testing: Tensile and compression tests were performed to evaluate the flexibility and durability of the hydrogel sensors.
  • Stability Testing: Water content, swelling ratio, and water retention capacity were measured to assess the hydrogel's stability in atmospheric conditions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the synthesis and characterization of a novel material and its performance evaluation, rather than training on existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Effect of COF and Hydrogel: The combination of COFs and the κPVA hydrogel is crucial. The hydrogel provides a flexible and conductive scaffold, while the COFs offer abundant active sites for NH3 adsorption and act as the primary sensing element.
  • In Situ Growth for Enhanced Properties: Growing COFs directly within the hydrogel matrix (impregnation and in situ growth method) effectively prevents COF particle aggregation, leading to better dispersion, improved conductivity pathways, and enhanced mechanical integrity.
  • Hydrogen Bonding as a Stabilizer: The hydrogen bonds formed between the COF components and the hydrogel matrix play a vital role in stabilizing the structure, preventing COF particle collapse, and improving water retention.
  • Dual Role of COF: The COF not only acts as the sensing material but also contributes to the hydrogel's mechanical strength and water retention by forming a protective film and anchoring water molecules.
  • Flexibility Under Strain: The composite hydrogel maintains its sensing capabilities even under significant bending, making it suitable for wearable applications.

Key Results

  • High Sensitivity: The optimized COF/κPVA hydrogel (KPVA-5) exhibited a remarkable 54.4% response to 1 ppm NH3, with a root mean square error (RMSE) of less than 5%.
  • Rapid Response and Recovery: The sensor showed a rapid response and full recovery to NH3. For 10 ppm NH3, the recovery time was approximately 93 seconds.
  • Exceptional Stability: The KPVA-5 hydrogel remained stable for 70 hours in atmospheric conditions, retaining a significant portion of its weight. In contrast, bare κPVA hydrogel was completely dehydrated within a similar timeframe.
  • Mechanical Robustness: The composite hydrogel demonstrated excellent mechanical properties, with a tensile strength of 0.87 MPa and a deformation capability of up to 120%. It also maintained sensing performance under bending angles up to 60°, showing a response value as high as 222%.
  • Low Detection Limit: The limit of detection (LOD) for NH3 was determined to be 0.81 ppm.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Conductivity Reduction: The incorporation of COFs, which have lower intrinsic conductivity than the bare hydrogel, led to a decrease in the overall conductivity of the composite hydrogels. While the KPVA-5 still showed good performance, further optimization might be needed to balance sensing performance with conductivity.
  • Further Optimization: The paper suggests that the synergistic impact of COF and PVA can improve sensing, water retention, and durability. Future work could focus on exploring different COF structures and compositions, as well as optimizing the hydrogel matrix, to further enhance these properties.
  • Real-World Testing: While the study demonstrates promising results, further validation in more complex and dynamic environments would be beneficial for real-world applications.
  • Selectivity: While selectivity tests for NH3 in different atmospheres were conducted (Figure S4), exploring cross-sensitivity to other common gases would be valuable for practical deployment.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{chen2024situ,
  author = {Xiyu Chen and Min Zeng and Tao Wang and Wangze Ni and Jianhua Yang and Nantao Hu and Tong Zhang and Zhi Yang},
  title = {{In Situ Growth of COF/PVA-Carrageenan Hydrogel Using the Impregnation Method for the Purpose of Highly Sensitive Ammonia Detection}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/s24134324},
}
Figure