In situ-generated palladium nanoparticles promoted co-reduction of bromate and nitrate in hydrogenotrophic biofilms

Chengyang Wu, Guirong Liang, Siqing Xia, Jingzhou Zhou, Éric Lichtfouse, Xiang Cai, Suyun Xu, Hongbo LiuWater 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of simultaneously removing bromate and nitrate from water, which is difficult due to competition for microbial electron donors. The researchers developed a novel approach using palladium nanoparticles (PdNPs) embedded within hydrogenotrophic biofilms. This "Pd-biofilm" system effectively diverts electron flow, significantly enhancing the co-reduction of both contaminants and offering a more sustainable water treatment solution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bromate is a harmful disinfection byproduct that poses significant health risks, and its removal is crucial for safe drinking water. While microbial reduction is a promising remediation strategy, it's often hindered by the common co-occurrence of nitrate. Both bromate and nitrate are electron acceptors that rely on similar microbial pathways, particularly the use of NADH generated from hydrogen oxidation. This creates a competition where nitrate, being more abundant and often preferred by microbes, can suppress bromate reduction. Existing technologies for removing these contaminants are often energy-intensive or costly. This study aims to overcome this competitive inhibition by introducing a catalytic element that can reroute electron flow, thereby improving the efficiency of simultaneous bromate and nitrate removal.

Methods

The core innovation in this study is the in situ generation of palladium nanoparticles (PdNPs) within the biofilm matrix of a membrane biofilm reactor (MBfR). This creates a "Pd-MBfR" system. The researchers compared this to a conventional MBfR without PdNPs.

Key techniques and approaches include:

  • Membrane Biofilm Reactors (MBfRs): These reactors utilize hollow fiber membranes to support biofilm growth, with hydrogen gas supplied internally as an electron donor.
  • In situ PdNP Synthesis: Palladium nanoparticles were generated directly within the biofilm by introducing a palladium precursor (Pd(II)) and hydrogen gas. This method ensures the PdNPs are intimately associated with the microbial community.
  • Comparative Reactor Setup: Two parallel MBfRs were used: one with in situ generated PdNPs (Pd-MBfR) and a control MBfR without PdNPs. An additional abiotic Pd-film reactor (MPfR) was also used to differentiate between catalytic and biological contributions.
  • Continuous Operation and Kinetic Testing: Reactors were operated continuously for extended periods (125 days) under varying concentrations of bromate, nitrate, and nitrite to assess performance. Short-term kinetic tests were conducted to quantify reaction rates.
  • Microbial Community and Functional Gene Analysis: Metagenomic sequencing (16S rRNA gene sequencing) was employed to analyze the bacterial community composition and identify shifts in response to the different conditions. Functional gene profiling (metagenomics) was used to understand the metabolic pathways involved.
  • Solid-State Characterization: Techniques like Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM), X-ray Diffraction (XRD), and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) were used to characterize the PdNPs and their association with the biofilm.

Datasets

The study utilized microbial sludge from the Wusong wastewater treatment plant (Shanghai, China) as inoculum. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the focus was on experimental data generated from the MBfR systems.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Electron Flow Rerouting: The most significant insight is how the PdNPs act as a catalyst to divert electron flow. Instead of solely relying on intracellular NADH for both bromate and nitrate reduction, the PdNPs facilitate extracellular hydrogenation of hydrogen, which can then be used to reduce bromate and nitrite.
  • Mitigating Competition: This rerouting effectively bypasses the competition for NADH between bromate and nitrate, a major bottleneck in conventional biological systems.
  • Synergistic Interactions: The Pd-MBfR system fostered beneficial microbial community structures. Specifically, it maintained syntrophic interactions between bromate-reducing bacteria (like Dechloromonas) and homoacetogens (Acetobacterium), which are crucial for producing electron donors (VFAs) that are otherwise outcompeted under nitrate stress.
  • Dual-Pathway Remediation: The Pd-biofilm system leverages both biological (enzymatic) and catalytic (PdNP) pathways for contaminant removal, offering a more robust and efficient solution.
  • Nitrite Scavenging: PdNPs efficiently catalyze the reduction of nitrite to nitrogen, preventing its accumulation and further freeing up electron flow for bromate reduction.

Key Results

  • Enhanced Bromate Removal: The Pd-MBfR achieved up to 70% bromate removal under competitive nitrate conditions, significantly outperforming the conventional MBfR (30% removal).
  • Improved Resilience: The Pd-MBfR showed greater resilience to high nitrate concentrations, maintaining stable bromate removal while the conventional MBfR experienced a sharp decline.
  • Kinetic Contributions: Kinetic modeling indicated that Pd-catalyzed reduction accounted for approximately 18% of bromate flux and about 65% of nitrite reduction flux in the Pd-MBfR.
  • Microbial Community Stability: The Pd-MBfR maintained a more stable microbial community structure under nitrate stress, favoring mixotrophic denitrifiers and homoacetogens, whereas the conventional MBfR shifted towards autotrophic denitrifiers.
  • Functional Gene Shifts: Gene profiling revealed increased abundance of homoacetogenesis-related genes and decreased abundance of dissimilatory nitrate reduction genes in the Pd-MBfR, consistent with the proposed electron flow diversion.

Limitations and Future Work

  • PdNP Dispersion: The study notes that due to the dispersive nature of PdNPs within the biofilms, directly quantifying the exact contributions of catalytic and enzymatic bromate reduction was challenging.
  • Long-term Stability and Cost: While the study demonstrates effectiveness over 125 days, further research would be needed to assess the long-term stability of the PdNPs and the overall economic feasibility of this approach for large-scale applications.
  • Other Contaminants: The study focused on bromate and nitrate. Future work could explore the application of this Pd-biofilm system for the co-removal of other co-contaminants.
  • Optimization of PdNP Synthesis: Further optimization of in situ PdNP synthesis could potentially lead to even greater efficiency and stability.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2025situ,
  author = {Chengyang Wu and Guirong Liang and Siqing Xia and Jingzhou Zhou and Éric Lichtfouse and Xiang Cai and Suyun Xu and Hongbo Liu},
  title = {{In situ-generated palladium nanoparticles promoted co-reduction of bromate and nitrate in hydrogenotrophic biofilms}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1016/j.watres.2025.124303},
}
Figure