Improving the representation of hydrologic processes in Earth System Models

Martyn Clark, Ying Fan, David M. Lawrence, J. C. Adam, Diogo Bolster, David Gochis, Richard Hooper, Mukesh Kumar, L. Ruby Leung, D. S. Mackay, R. M. Maxwell, Chaopeng Shen, Sean Swenson, Xubin ZengWater 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

Earth System Models (ESMs) are crucial for predicting global environmental change, but their land components (land models) lag behind current hydrological understanding. This paper argues for integrating advanced hydrological process representations and establishing rigorous benchmarking to improve ESMs' ability to simulate water cycle changes and their impacts on energy, carbon, and nutrient cycles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The central problem is that current land models within Earth System Models (ESMs) do not adequately represent the complexity of terrestrial hydrological processes. While ESMs are designed to capture Earth system interactions, their land components often rely on simplified or outdated hydrological understanding. This limits their ability to accurately predict how the water cycle will change under global environmental change scenarios, which in turn affects predictions of weather, climate, ecosystem productivity, and freshwater availability. The paper highlights that the vast knowledge gained in the field of hydrology over the past 50 years, particularly regarding processes like groundwater dynamics, spatial heterogeneity, and human impacts, is not fully incorporated into these large-scale models.

Methods

The paper doesn't introduce new computational methods but rather advocates for the adoption of existing, more sophisticated hydrological modeling approaches within ESM land models. Key areas for improvement include:

  • Soil Water Dynamics: Moving beyond simplified Richards' equation implementations to include mixed-form solutions and macropore flow for better representation of variably saturated flow.
  • Root Water Uptake: Incorporating representations that account for hydraulic gradients between soil and roots, and potentially dynamic root growth models.
  • Groundwater Dynamics: Explicitly representing groundwater flow, including lateral flow between grid cells and within-grid variability, and two-way stream-aquifer interactions.
  • Heterogeneity and Scaling: Developing approaches to better represent how subgrid-scale heterogeneities in soil moisture and water table depth influence grid-average fluxes, moving beyond simple mosaic or single-vegetation-type approaches.
  • Human Impacts: Integrating more detailed representations of human activities like dam construction, irrigation, and groundwater extraction.

The paper also strongly emphasizes the need for comprehensive hydrologic benchmarking. This involves:

  • Synthetic Test Problems: Using standardized tests to verify the correct implementation of model equations.
  • Process-Based Model Evaluation: Systematically evaluating models against multivariate and multiscale data from research basins to diagnose specific model weaknesses and guide development.
  • Interplay Analysis: Understanding the trade-offs between predictive accuracy, computational efficiency, and data availability.
  • Information Content: Defining "good" models and meaningful benchmarks to assess how well models utilize available data.

Datasets

The paper does not present results from specific datasets or introduce new benchmarks. Instead, it refers to the need for and use of:

  • Hydrologic Observations: A large amount of hydrological observations are mentioned as being underutilized for model testing.
  • Research Basins and Critical Zone Observatories: These are highlighted as crucial sites for rigorous process-based model evaluation.
  • Geophysical Attributes: Datasets on topography, vegetation, soils, geology, and meteorological data are noted as important for parameterizing models.
  • Remote Sensing Data: Data from sources like GRACE (for groundwater) and future missions like SWOT (for river geometry) are mentioned as valuable for improving model representations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hydrology's Untapped Potential: The field of hydrology has developed sophisticated tools and understanding that could significantly enhance ESM land models, but this knowledge is not being fully integrated.
  • Beyond Simple Soil Moisture: Current land models often oversimplify soil water dynamics, neglecting crucial processes like macropore flow and hydraulic gradients, which are vital for accurate evapotranspiration and groundwater recharge estimates.
  • Groundwater is Key: The underrepresentation of groundwater dynamics (both lateral and vertical) is a major limitation, as groundwater plays a critical role in buffering water stress and influencing land-atmosphere interactions.
  • Heterogeneity Matters: Simply averaging processes across a grid cell misses the critical influence of spatial variability in topography, soil, and water table depth on hydrological fluxes and ecosystem responses.
  • Benchmarking is Essential: Without systematic and rigorous benchmarking, it's difficult to identify the best modeling approaches, understand model weaknesses, and prioritize development efforts. This is crucial for accelerating progress.
  • Collaboration is Crucial: Bridging the gap between hydrologists and ESM modelers is paramount for advancing the field.

Key Results

The paper is a review and a call to action, rather than a presentation of new empirical results. Therefore, there are no quantitative results in terms of accuracy improvements or speedups. The "results" are conceptual:

  • Identification of Gaps: The paper clearly outlines the deficiencies in current ESM land models regarding the representation of key hydrological processes (e.g., groundwater dynamics, lateral flow, macropore flow, root water uptake).
  • Opportunities for Improvement: It provides a detailed roadmap of specific hydrological modeling techniques and concepts that can be incorporated into ESMs.
  • Emphasis on Benchmarking: It strongly advocates for a shift towards more systematic and comprehensive benchmarking as a critical step for model development.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Complexity vs. Fidelity: The authors acknowledge the ongoing challenge of balancing model complexity with the availability of data and computational resources. They suggest careful analysis of trade-offs.
  • Global Applicability: A key challenge is ensuring that improved modeling approaches are applicable globally, not just in specific research catchments. This requires extensive data and careful parameterization.
  • Software Engineering: Implementing advanced hydrological models within ESM frameworks introduces significant software engineering challenges, including hierarchical data structures and unstructured grids.
  • Future Work: The paper explicitly calls for:
  • Increased engagement of hydrologists in ESM land model development.
  • Rigorous evaluation of ESM hydrology performance in research watersheds.
  • Detailed synthesis activities to create a comprehensive roadmap for improving hydrologic process representation in land models.
  • Continued development of benchmarking activities, including synthetic tests and process-based evaluations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Many of the scientific and societal challenges in understanding and preparing for global environmental change rest upon our ability to understand and predict the water cycle change at large river basin, continent, and global scales. However, current large‐scale land models (as a component of Earth System Models, or ESMs) do not yet reflect the best hydrologic process understanding or utilize the large amount of hydrologic observations for model testing. This paper discusses the opportunities and key challenges to improve hydrologic process representations and benchmarking in ESM land models, suggesting that (1) land model development can benefit from recent advances in hydrology, both through incorporating key processes (e.g., groundwater‐surface water interactions) and new approaches to describe multiscale spatial variability and hydrologic connectivity; (2) accelerating model advances requires comprehensive hydrologic benchmarking in order to systematically evaluate competing alternatives, understand model weaknesses, and prioritize model development needs, and (3) stronger collaboration is needed between the hydrology and ESM modeling communities, both through greater engagement of hydrologists in ESM land model development, and through rigorous evaluation of ESM hydrology performance in research watersheds or Critical Zone Observatories. Such coordinated efforts in advancing hydrology in ESMs have the potential to substantially impact energy, carbon, and nutrient cycle prediction capabilities through the fundamental role hydrologic processes play in regulating these cycles.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{clark2015improving,
  author = {Martyn Clark and Ying Fan and David M. Lawrence and J. C. Adam and Diogo Bolster and David Gochis and Richard Hooper and Mukesh Kumar and L. Ruby Leung and D. S. Mackay and R. M. Maxwell and Chaopeng Shen and Sean Swenson and Xubin Zeng},
  title = {{Improving the representation of hydrologic processes in Earth System Models}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1002/2015wr017096},
}
Figure