TL;DR
This paper tackles the challenge of inferring implicit discourse relations (like cause-and-effect or contrast) in text, which are difficult to detect due to the absence of explicit connecting words. They propose a novel method to identify "freely omissible" discourse connectives that can be safely removed without changing meaning, allowing for the creation of more effective training data to significantly improve implicit relation detection.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Automatic discourse parsing aims to understand the structure of text by identifying relationships between sentences or clauses. A major bottleneck in this field is the detection and classification of implicit discourse relations, where the connective (like "because," "however," or "therefore") is not explicitly stated. Inferring these relations relies solely on the surrounding text, making it a much harder task than identifying explicit ones. Current methods struggle with data sparsity, meaning there isn't enough labeled data to train robust models. This paper proposes a way to leverage explicit discourse relations to generate more training data for implicit relations, but with a crucial caveat: not all explicit connectives can be freely removed without altering the intended meaning.
Methods
The core of this paper's contribution lies in its method for selecting which explicit discourse connectives are suitable for generating weakly labeled data for implicit relation detection. They introduce two key criteria:
- Omission Rate (OR): This measures how frequently a discourse connective appears in implicit relations compared to its total occurrences. A high OR suggests the connective is often omitted.
- Context Differential (JSD): This quantifies how similar the semantic context (word distributions in the arguments) is between explicit and implicit uses of a connective. A low JSD indicates that removing the connective doesn't drastically change the surrounding meaning.
By combining these metrics, they classify discourse connectives into categories like "Freely Omissible" (high OR, low JSD), "Omissible" (low OR, low JSD), "Alternating" (high context differential), and "Non-omissible" (zero OR). The "Freely Omissible" connectives are identified as the most promising for generating useful weakly labeled data. They then use these selected connectives to extract instances from a large corpus, which are then used to train classifiers for implicit discourse relations.
Datasets
- Penn Discourse Treebank (PDTB) 2.0: This is the primary dataset used for annotation and analysis. It provides manually annotated discourse relations, their senses (e.g., CONTINGENCY, COMPARISON), and the text spans (ARG1, ARG2) involved. It's used for classifying connectives and for training/testing implicit relation classifiers.
- English Gigaword Corpus version 3: A large, unannotated newswire corpus used to extract weakly labeled instances of explicit discourse relations. This corpus supplements the PDTB by providing a much larger pool of text from which to draw data.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Not all connectives are equal: The paper strongly refutes the idea that all discourse connectives are interchangeable or that their omission is always context-independent. This is a crucial insight for improving distant supervision.
- "Freely Omissible" connectives are gold: Identifying connectives that are both frequently omitted and whose omission doesn't significantly alter meaning is key to generating high-quality weakly labeled data.
- Context matters for omission: The semantic context surrounding a connective is critical in determining whether its omission is permissible without changing the discourse relation's interpretation.
- Weakly labeled data can significantly boost performance: By carefully selecting connectives, the generated weakly labeled data can substantially improve the accuracy of implicit discourse relation classifiers, even without adding new features.
Key Results
- The proposed method, using "freely omissible" discourse connectives for distant supervision, significantly improves the accuracy of implicit discourse relation classifiers.
- The 4-way classification system achieved an accuracy of 0.571, a notable increase from the baseline of 0.550 (p < 0.05).
- The macro-average F₁ score also improved from 0.384 to 0.405.
- The performance boost was particularly significant for minority classes like "Comparison vs. Others" and "Temporal vs. Others" when compared to previous state-of-the-art methods.
- The study found that the performance gain plateaus or even decreases when using connectives from other classes (e.g., "Alternating" or "Non-omissible"), highlighting the importance of their selection criteria.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited scope of connectives: The analysis focused on 54 connectives that appeared in both explicit and implicit relations in the PDTB. Connectives that are exclusively explicit or implicit were not considered for this specific classification.
- Data sparsity for minority classes: While the approach helps, some minority classes still benefit less from the added data, suggesting further improvements are needed.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that the increased training data size enabled by their method opens doors for more sophisticated models and extensive feature engineering. They also note that their classification of discourse connectives can be used for other downstream NLP tasks.
Summary updated