Improving the dynamics of northern vegetation in the ORCHIDEE ecosystem model

Dan Zhu, Shushi Peng, Philippe Ciais, Nicolas Viovy, Arsène Druel, Masa Kageyama, Gerhard Krinner, Philippe Peylin, Catherine Ottlé, Shilong Piao, Benjamin Poulter, Dmitry Schepaschenko, А. Shvidenko2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a significant update to the ORCHIDEE ecosystem model's vegetation dynamics, addressing long-standing issues with unrealistic simulations in Northern Hemisphere high-latitude regions. By incorporating new parameterizations for tree mortality, growing season temperature limits, and other processes, the revised model shows substantial improvements in simulating vegetation distribution, particularly the northern tree line and the dominance of different tree types.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dynamic Global Vegetation Models (DGVMs) are crucial for understanding how ecosystems respond to climate change, but they often struggle to accurately represent vegetation distribution and succession, especially in complex environments like the Northern Hemisphere's high latitudes. The ORCHIDEE model's vegetation dynamics module (ORC-VD) had not been updated in years, leading to known unrealistic outputs. This gap hinders our ability to predict how these vital ecosystems will change under future climate scenarios, impacting carbon cycling and biodiversity. The authors aimed to rectify these shortcomings by developing and evaluating a new, improved parameterization for ORC-VD.

Methods

The core of this work lies in a comprehensive re-parameterization and evaluation of the ORC-VD module. Key methodological advancements include:

  • New Parameterizations: The authors introduced updated equations and parameters for:
  • Tree Mortality: Incorporating dynamic background mortality based on growth efficiency and refining mortality from extreme coldness and spring frost.
  • Growing-Season Temperature Limits: Reintroducing and modifying a criterion to constrain tree extension to Arctic regions based on recent soil temperature research.
  • Physiological Traits: Revising maximum photosynthetic rates ($V_{cmax}$, $f_{max}$) and removing leaf-age dependency for evergreen trees.
  • Enhanced Evaluation Framework: A novel, multi-dataset evaluation framework was developed. This framework uses a beta diversity metric to quantify disagreement between model and observational datasets, explicitly accounting for observational uncertainties. This approach is presented as a generic method applicable to other DGVMs.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: Several sensitivity runs were conducted to isolate the impact of specific processes like soil freezing, elevated CO2, and the frequency of extreme cold events during model spin-up.

Datasets

The study utilized a range of datasets for evaluation and comparison:

  • Satellite Land Cover: ESA CCI land cover v1.1, GLC2000, ISLSCP II vegetation continuous field (VCF), and regional Siberian land-cover datasets (OSIB, IIASA). These were converted into Plant Functional Type (PFT) maps.
  • Forest Biomass: Remote sensing-derived forest carbon density maps and national forest inventory data.
  • Gross Primary Productivity (GPP): Data-driven GPP estimates from FLUXNET and a model tree ensemble (MTE).
  • Soil Organic Carbon: Harmonized World Soil Database (HWSD) and Northern Circumpolar Soil Carbon Database (NCSCD).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spin-up Matters: The choice of spin-up forcing (e.g., multi-year climate data vs. average climatology) significantly impacts the resulting vegetation distribution, highlighting the need for realistic spin-up procedures in DGVMs.
  • Process Interactions are Crucial: The study demonstrates how seemingly minor updates to processes like soil freezing or spring frost can have cascading effects on vegetation distribution and competition.
  • Evaluation Metrics Need Nuance: The development of a metric that accounts for observational uncertainty is a critical step towards more robust DGVM evaluation, moving beyond simple comparisons to single datasets.
  • Northern Tree Line is Sensitive: The improved parameterization for growing-season temperature limits dramatically improved the simulation of the northern tree line, a key indicator of climate change impacts.

Key Results

  • The new parameterization (ORC-HL-NVD) significantly improved the modeling of tree functional type distribution north of 40° N, particularly the northern tree limit.
  • The model now better reproduces the observed dominance of needleleaf evergreen trees over broadleaf deciduous trees in northern Europe and North America.
  • The average model skill (Sv) for simulating vegetation distribution in the Northern Hemisphere improved by 18% compared to the old version (OLD).
  • Forest area simulations showed a reduction in systematic overestimation, especially for Asian Russia and Canada, though some overestimation persists.
  • While GPP simulations showed less improvement, likely due to its weak dependence on PFTs at high latitudes, forest biomass simulations saw notable improvements.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Grassland and Tundra Representation: The model still overestimates grass fraction in dry regions and the Arctic tundra, suggesting a need for better representation of shrubland and tundra PFTs.
  • Carbon Cycle Biases: Despite improved vegetation distribution, significant regional biases remain in GPP and forest biomass, indicating that other structural biases in carbon cycle parameterizations need addressing.
  • Future Development: The authors suggest incorporating PFT trait variation into DGVMs to simulate vegetation acclimation and its impact on competition and the carbon cycle. Further work on representing shrub and tundra PFTs is also recommended.

Summary updated

Abstract

Processes that describe the distribution of vegetation and ecosystem succession after disturbance are an important component of dynamic global vegetation models (DGVMs). The vegetation dynamics module (ORC-VD) within the process-based ecosystem model ORCHIDEE (Organizing Carbon and Hydrology in Dynamic Ecosystems) has not been updated and evaluated since many years and does not match the progress in modeling the rest of the physical and biogeochemical processes. Therefore, ORC-VD is known to produce unrealistic results. This study presents a new parameterization of ORC-VD for mid-to-high latitude regions in the Northern Hemisphere, including processes that influence the existence, mortality and competition between tree functional types. A new set of metrics is also proposed to quantify the performance of ORC-VD, using up to five different datasets of satellite land cover, forest biomass from remote sensing and inventories, a data-driven estimate of gross primary productivity (GPP) and two gridded datasets of soil organic carbon content. The scoring of ORC-VD derived from these metrics integrates uncertainties in the observational datasets. This multi-dataset evaluation framework is a generic method that could be applied to the evaluation of other DGVM models. The results of the original ORC-VD published in 2005 for mid-to-high latitudes and of the new parameterization are evaluated against the above-described datasets. Significant improvements were found in the modeling of the distribution of tree functional types north of 40° N. Three additional sensitivity runs were carried out to separate the impact of different processes or drivers on simulated vegetation distribution, including soil freezing which limits net primary production through soil moisture availability in the root zone, elevated CO2 concentration since 1850, and the return frequency of cold climate extremes causing tree mortality during the spin-up phase of the model.
BibTeX
@misc{zhu2015improving,
  author = {Dan Zhu and Shushi Peng and Philippe Ciais and Nicolas Viovy and Arsène Druel and Masa Kageyama and Gerhard Krinner and Philippe Peylin and Catherine Ottlé and Shilong Piao and Benjamin Poulter and Dmitry Schepaschenko and А. Shvidenko},
  title = {{Improving the dynamics of northern vegetation in the ORCHIDEE ecosystem model}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.5194/gmdd-8-2213-2015},
}
Figure