Improving Order with Queues

Andreas Karrenbauer, Leonie Krull, Kurt Mehlhorn, Pranabendu Misra, Paolo Luigi Rinaldi, Anna TwelsiekarXiv 2022 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper investigates how much "order" can be introduced into a sequence using a limited number of parallel FIFO queues, a problem inspired by car manufacturing logistics. The authors develop optimal algorithms for reducing the "disorder" (measured by longest decreasing subsequences or down-steps) and analyze the limits of what's achievable with a fixed number of queues.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The core problem is: given a sequence of items and a fixed number of parallel FIFO queues, how can we best arrange these items to be closer to a sorted order? This is a generalization of the well-known "Patience Sort" problem, which states that a sequence can be perfectly sorted using $L$ queues, where $L$ is the length of its longest decreasing subsequence (LDS). This paper tackles the scenario where we have fewer than $L$ queues, asking what's the best we can do in terms of reducing the LDS or the number of "down-steps" (where an element is followed by a smaller one). This problem has practical relevance in optimizing production lines where items (cars) must pass through various stages (queues) with specific ordering constraints.

Methods

The authors employ a combination of algorithmic design and theoretical analysis.

  • Refined Patience Sort: They adapt the standard Patience Sort algorithm. Instead of opening a new queue for every decreasing subsequence, they use the first $k-1$ queues as usual and funnel all remaining subsequences into the $k$-th queue. This allows them to reduce the LDS from $L$ to $L-k+1$.
  • Lower Bound Construction: To prove the optimality of their LDS reduction, they construct specific sequences that, even with $k$ queues, cannot have their LDS reduced below $L-k+1$. This involves using direct and skew sums of permutations.
  • Merging Sequences: They analyze the problem of merging two sequences, each with an LDS of at most 2. They characterize when such sequences can be merged into an LDS of 2 and provide a linear-time algorithm to decide this.
  • Down-Step Minimization: An optimal online algorithm, AlgDS, is proposed for minimizing down-steps. This algorithm uses a round-robin approach to distribute elements among queues, maintaining an invariant to ensure optimality.
  • 2-SAT Formulation: For the merging problem, they formulate it as a 2-SAT problem, where satisfiability corresponds to mergeability.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and algorithmic design using constructed sequences rather than empirical evaluation on datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fundamental Trade-off: There's a fundamental trade-off between the number of queues ($k$) and the achievable "sortedness." With fewer queues than the LDS ($L$), perfect sorting is impossible, but significant improvements are still possible.
  • LDS Reduction Limit: The LDS of a sequence can be reduced by at most $k-1$ using $k$ queues, and this bound is tight in the worst case.
  • Merging Complexity: Merging sequences with small LDS (like 2) is non-trivial. While they can always be merged into an LDS of 3, achieving an LDS of 2 requires careful analysis and specific algorithms.
  • Optimal Online Strategy for Down-Steps: The proposed AlgDS algorithm for minimizing down-steps is not only optimal in terms of the final number of down-steps but also online and unique in its strategy.
  • Practical Relevance: The problem, though abstractly formulated, is directly inspired by and applicable to real-world problems like car manufacturing, where optimizing flow and minimizing disruptions is crucial.

Key Results

  • LDS Reduction: An algorithm reduces the LDS of a sequence from $L$ to $\max(L-k+1, 1)$ in $O(n \log k)$ time.
  • LDS Optimality: For any $L$ and $k$, there exists a sequence with LDS $L$ whose LDS cannot be reduced below $L-k+1$ using $k$ queues.
  • Merging LDS 2 Sequences: Two sequences with LDS $\leq 2$ can always be merged into a sequence with LDS 3. An optimal linear-time algorithm is provided to decide if they can be merged into an LDS of 2.
  • Down-Step Minimization: An optimal online algorithm (AlgDS) minimizes down-steps in $O(n \log k)$ time. It is shown to be unique among online algorithms.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Merging General LDS: The merging results are primarily for sequences with LDS $\leq 2$. Generalizing this to arbitrary LDS values or more than two sequences is an open problem.
  • Networked Queues: The current work assumes parallel queues. Investigating more general settings with queues arranged in arbitrary directed acyclic networks is suggested.
  • Alternative Disorder Measures: Exploring other measures of "disorder" beyond LDS and down-steps is proposed as an interesting direction.
  • Stacks vs. Queues: The paper mentions stacks (LIFO) and suggests characterizing their sorting power for $k$ parallel stacks as an open problem.

Summary updated

Abstract

Patience Sort sorts a sequence of numbers with a minimal number of queues that work according to the First-In-First-Out (FIFO) principle. More precisely, if the length of the longest descreasing subsequence of the input sequence is $L$, then Patience Sort uses $L$ queues. We ask how much one can improve order with $k$ queues, where $k < L$? We address this question for two measures of sortedness: number of down-steps and length of the longest descreasing subsequence. For the first measure, we give an optimal algorithm. For the second measure, we give an algorithm that reduces the LDS from $L$ to $L - k + 1$, and we provide a sequence with LDS $L$ that can't be reduced to an LDS lower than $L - k + 1$ with $k$ queues. Moreover, we study the mergeability of two sequences of numbers, providing an optimal linear algorithm for two queues with LDS $\leq 2$. The research was inspired by a problem arising in car manufacturing.
BibTeX
@misc{karrenbauer2022improving,
  author = {Andreas Karrenbauer and Leonie Krull and Kurt Mehlhorn and Pranabendu Misra and Paolo Luigi Rinaldi and Anna Twelsiek},
  title = {{Improving Order with Queues}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2207.02476},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.02476},
}
Figure