Improving Muon Scattering Tomography Performance With A Muon Momentum Measurement Scheme

Yu Pei, Ziwen Pan, Jiajia Zhai, Yu Xu, Li Deng, Zhengyang He, Zhe Chen, Zechao Kang, Yuhong Yu, Xueheng Zhang, Liangwen Chen, Lei Yang, Z. SunarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Muon imaging, especially muon scattering tomography (MST), has recently garnered significant attention. MST measures the magnitude of muon scattering angles inside an object, which depends not only on the material properties but also on the muon momentum. Due to the difficulty of simultaneous measurement of momentum, it was neglected and taken as a constant in multiple MST reconstruction algorithms. Recently, an experimental measurement scheme has emerged that is feasible in engineering, but it requires many layers of detectors to approach the true momentum. From this, we proposed both an algorithm to incorporating momentum into MST, and a scheme to determine the thresholds of Cherenkov detectors. This novel scheme, termed the "equi-percentage scheme", sets momentum thresholds for Cherenkov detector layers based on cosmic muon momentum distribution. Results showed our approach delivers noticeable enhancement in reconstructed image quality even with only two detector layers, reaching near-saturation performance with four layers. This study proves that momentum measurement significantly enhances short-duration MST, and that substantial improvement can be achieved with relatively coarse momentum measurement using 2-4 layers of Cherenkov detectors.

Introduction

Muon Scattering Tomography (MST) is a non-invasive imaging technique that utilizes naturally occurring cosmic-ray muons to probe dense structures like volcanoes, nuclear casks, or ancient artifacts. When a muon traverses an object, its scattering angle is influenced by both the material's atomic number ($Z$) and the muon's own momentum ($p$). Historically, measuring muon momentum in real-time has been a significant hurdle, leading many MST algorithms to assume a constant momentum (typically 3–4 GeV/c). This simplification results in image blurring and necessitates long exposure times to mitigate errors. This paper presents a novel approach to incorporate coarse momentum measurements into MST to enhance image quality and reduce scan times.

Methods

The proposed solution integrates a momentum-aware reconstruction algorithm with a hardware-efficient measurement scheme.

Momentum-Corrected PoCA Algorithm

The standard Point of Closest Approach (PoCA) algorithm was modified to include a momentum correction factor. By normalizing scattering angles using the relation $\theta' = \theta \cdot p/p_0$, the algorithm accounts for the velocity of individual muons, creating a more consistent representation of the material properties. Additionally, a "bright-spot removal" post-processing step was implemented to eliminate anomalous high-scattering events that can degrade image clarity.

The Equi-Percentage Scheme

To measure momentum efficiently, the researchers propose using a stack of Cherenkov detectors as "speed gates." The "equi-percentage scheme" sets detector thresholds such that each interval between thresholds contains an equal portion of the cosmic-ray muon population. This contrasts with "equi-distance" schemes and is designed to maximize the information gained from a limited number of detector layers.

Illustration of the simulation model and reconstructed images.

Experimental Setup and Datasets

The study utilized Monte Carlo simulations via the Geant4 toolkit. Realistic muon energy and angular distributions were generated using the Cosmic-ray Shower Library (CRY). The primary imaging target was a U-shaped tungsten block. Image quality was quantitatively assessed using the Structural Similarity Index Measure (SSIM), while Kurtosis ($\mathcal{K}$) was used to evaluate the concentration of the scattering distribution.

Results and Discussion

The results demonstrate that high-resolution momentum measurement is not required for significant improvements in MST. Coarse binning of muons into just a few categories provides substantial benefits.

Performance Gains

With only two detector layers using the equi-percentage scheme, the SSIM index for a short-duration scan (10,000 events) improved from 0.22 (without momentum correction) to 0.38. Increasing the number of detector layers to four resulted in an SSIM of 0.46, which is remarkably close to the 0.49 achieved with "perfect" (fully accurate) momentum data. This "near-saturation" performance suggests that 4 layers of Cherenkov detectors are sufficient for high-quality imaging.

Quantitative comparison of SSIM scores across different configurations.

Statistical Convergence

Momentum-aware imaging significantly accelerates statistical convergence. By reducing the noise introduced by momentum variability, high-quality images can be produced with fewer muons, making the technique more viable for time-sensitive applications like cargo security. The combination of momentum correction and bright-spot removal was found to be particularly effective in stabilizing image quality across different random seeds, preventing rare high-scattering events from washing out the reconstruction.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that incorporating even coarse momentum measurements into MST reconstruction significantly enhances image quality. The equi-percentage scheme offers a practical hardware implementation using a small number of Cherenkov detector layers. Future work will focus on testing the scheme with more complex multi-material objects and investigating its impact on material identification capabilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Muon imaging, especially muon scattering tomography (MST), has recently garnered significant attention. MST measures the magnitude of muon scattering angles inside an object, which depends not only on the material properties but also on the muon momentum. Due to the difficulty of simultaneous measurement of momentum, it was neglected and taken as a constant in multiple MST reconstruction algorithms. Recently, an experimental measurement scheme has emerged that is feasible in engineering, but it requires many layers of detectors to approach the true momentum. From this, we proposed both an algorithm to incorporating momentum into MST, and a scheme to determine the thresholds of Cherenkov detectors. This novel scheme, termed the "equi-percentage scheme", sets momentum thresholds for Cherenkov detector layers based on cosmic muon momentum distribution. Results showed our approach delivers noticeable enhancement in reconstructed image quality even with only two detector layers, reaching near-saturation performance with four layers. This study proves that momentum measurement significantly enhances short-duration MST, and that substantial improvement can be achieved with relatively coarse momentum measurement using 2-4 layers of Cherenkov detectors.
BibTeX
@misc{pei2025improving,
  author = {Yu Pei and Ziwen Pan and Jiajia Zhai and Yu Xu and Li Deng and Zhengyang He and Zhe Chen and Zechao Kang and Yuhong Yu and Xueheng Zhang and Liangwen Chen and Lei Yang and Z. Sun},
  title = {{Improving Muon Scattering Tomography Performance With A Muon Momentum Measurement Scheme}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2509.12800},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.12800},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure