Improving Heart disease risk through quality-focused diet logging: pre-post study of a diet quality tracking app

Courtland VanDam, Bum Chul Kwon, Stephanie E. Chiuve, Hyung Wook Choi, Paul Entler, Pang‐Ning Tan, Jina HuhbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces a mobile app designed to improve heart disease risk by focusing on diet quality rather than calorie counting. The app, which simplifies diet logging and provides real-time feedback on cardiovascular risk, showed significant improvements in users' diet scores and overall heart disease risk, even though users weren't particularly interested in monitoring their risk scores directly.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional diet-tracking apps often focus on calorie counting, which can be time-consuming, tedious, and lead to users abandoning the app. This approach doesn't always translate to better health outcomes. The paper addresses the need for a more sustainable and effective method for diet tracking that can positively impact heart disease risk. They propose focusing on "diet quality" – emphasizing healthy food categories rather than precise quantities – as a more manageable and impactful approach. The challenge is to design a mobile health (mHealth) app that effectively implements this quality-focused approach and demonstrates its efficacy in improving health outcomes.

Methods

The researchers developed a mobile app based on Behavior Change Techniques (BCTs). The app design was iteratively refined through focus groups with individuals at risk for heart disease. The core of the app involves users logging simplified diet quality by selecting food categories (e.g., fruits, vegetables, whole grains, red meat, sugary drinks). The app then uses the Healthy Heart Score (HHS) to provide real-time feedback on the user's 20-year cardiovascular risk. The study employed a 5-week pre-post design, measuring various health metrics before and after the intervention period.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study involved 38 participants who were recruited from a weight management clinic.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Quality over Quantity: Focusing on diet quality (what you eat) rather than quantity (how much you eat) can be a more effective and sustainable approach for behavior change, especially for heart disease risk reduction.
  • Simplified Logging is Key: A simplified diet logging system, focusing on broad food categories, significantly improved dietary behavior, suggesting that reducing user burden is crucial for app adoption and sustained use.
  • Risk Score Visibility vs. Impact: While users weren't highly engaged with actively monitoring their risk scores, the app's focus on improving diet quality still led to significant reductions in their overall risk. This suggests that the impact of behavior change on risk is more important than the user's direct engagement with the risk score itself.
  • Balancing Simplicity and User Needs: There's a tension between simplifying the app for efficiency and accommodating users' broader dietary goals (e.g., reducing dairy intake, which wasn't directly related to heart disease risk in this app's framework).

Key Results

  • App Use: 84% of participants used the app weekly during the 5-week intervention.
  • Diet Score Improvement: Participants significantly improved their Diet Score (DS) by the fifth week (p<0.05).
  • Heart Disease Risk Reduction: Participants also significantly improved their Healthy Heart Score (HHS) (p<0.05).
  • Risk Score Monitoring: Only 31% of participants checked their risk scores more than once, indicating low engagement with this specific feature.
  • Other Outcomes: Weight, blood sugar, and blood pressure did not show significant changes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • No Control Group: The study lacked a control group, making it difficult to definitively attribute the observed changes solely to the app.
  • Short Duration: The 5-week intervention period might not be long enough to observe true, long-term behavior change.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest testing the app's efficacy with a larger, more diverse population, particularly those who are disinterested in existing quantity-focused diet apps. They also propose improving the visualization of risk scores to make improvements more apparent and potentially augmenting risk scores with forecasting trajectories to further motivate users. Further research could explore how to better integrate users' concurrent personal goals with the app's clinical objectives.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Diet-tracking mobile apps have been effective in behavior change. At the same time, quantity-focused diet tracking (e.g., calorie counting) can be time-consuming and tedious, leading to unsustained adoption. Diet Quality—focusing on high-quality dietary patterns rather than quantifying diet into calories—has shown effectiveness in improving heart disease risk. Healthy Heart Score (HHS) predicts 20-year cardiovascular risks based on quality-focused food category consumptions, rather than detailed serving sizes. No studies have examined how mobile health apps focusing on diet quality can bring promising results on health outcomes and ease of adoption. We designed a mobile app to support the HHS informed quality-focused dietary approach by enabling users to log simplified diet quality and view its real-time impact on future heart disease risks. Users were asked to log food categories that are the main predictors of HHS. We measured the app’s feasibility and efficacy on improving individuals’ clinical and behavioral factors affecting future heart disease risks and app use. We recruited 38 overweight or obese participants at high heart disease risk, who used the app for 5 weeks and measured weight, blood sugar, and blood pressure, HHS, and Diet Score (DS) measuring diet quality at baseline and the fifth week of the intervention. The majority used the application every week (84%) and significantly improved DS and HHS at the fifth week (p&lt;0.05), although only 10 participants (31%) checked their risk scores more than once. Other outcomes did not show significant changes. Our study showed logging simplified diet quality significantly improved dietary behavior. The participants were not interested in seeing HHS, and the participants perceived logging diet categories irrelevant to improving HHS as important. We discuss the complexities of addressing health risks, quantity vs. quality-based health monitoring, and incorporating secondary behavior change goals that matter to users when designing mobile health.
BibTeX
@misc{vandam2020improving,
  author = {Courtland VanDam and Bum Chul Kwon and Stephanie E. Chiuve and Hyung Wook Choi and Paul Entler and Pang‐Ning Tan and Jina Huh},
  title = {{Improving Heart disease risk through quality-focused diet logging: pre-post study of a diet quality tracking app}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.01.30.926634},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure