Improvements in protective measures in factories with acetylene hydrochlorination and ethylene oxychlorination techniques declined risk assessment levels and affected liver health status

Yiwen Dong, Xingang Wang, Weijiang Hu, Hongying Bian, Ning Kang, Feng Han, Siyu Zhang, Meng YeFrontiers in Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that targeted engineering improvements—specifically enhanced mechanical ventilation and airtight sealing—significantly reduce occupational risk levels and improve liver health indicators in PVC production workers. By comparing two different chemical synthesis techniques over a one-year period, the researchers show that these workplace interventions effectively lower ambient hazard concentrations and correlate with a measurable decrease in abnormal liver enzyme levels.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Vinyl chloride monomer (VCM), the primary building block of PVC, is a potent carcinogen known to cause liver impairment, hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), and the rare angiosarcoma of the liver (ASL). In industrial settings, workers are often exposed to VCM and PVC dust through leaks in unsealed valves or inadequate ventilation.

While the health risks are well-documented, there is a gap in understanding how specific "root cause" improvements in a factory's protective infrastructure translate to clinical health outcomes. This paper evaluates whether upgrading engineering controls can move the needle on both environmental risk assessments and the actual physiological health of the workforce.

Methods

The researchers conducted a comparative study of two factories using different production methods:

  • Factory Y: Uses the acetylene hydrochlorination technique (common in regions with abundant coal).
  • Factory Z: Uses the ethylene oxychlorination technique (requires more high-tech equipment).

The study compared data from 2020 (pre-improvement) and 2021 (post-improvement). Improvements included installing anti-dust fences, bag dust collectors, sprinkler facilities, and local exhaust fans, alongside upgrading to high-efficiency sealing and anti-corrosion materials for pipelines.

To assess risk, the authors compared three different modeling approaches:

  1. Semi-quantitative comprehensive index model: Factors in vapor pressure, usage amounts, and contact time.
  2. ICMM (International Council on Mining and Metals) model: A more subjective, consequence-based model.
  3. Chinese National Classification (GBZ/T 229): A standard regulatory model.

Clinical health was monitored via annual physical exams, including liver ultrasounds and function tests for enzymes like Alanine Aminotransferase (ALT), Aspartate Transaminase (AST), and Glutamyl Transpeptidase (GGT).

Datasets

The study utilized a cohort of 757 workers (408 from Factory Y and 349 from Factory Z). The researchers collected:

  • Environmental Data: Ambient concentrations of VCM, PVC dust, HCl, and other hazards across various work positions (e.g., crushing, polymerization, maintenance).
  • Engineering Data: Wind speed, fresh air requirements, and ventilation air changing rates.
  • Clinical Data: Results from liver ultrasounds and blood chemistry panels from 2020 and 2021.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Model Sensitivity Matters: The researchers found that the semi-quantitative comprehensive index model was the most effective at capturing the nuances of risk reduction post-improvement. In contrast, the ICMM model tended to overestimate risk, while the national classification model often underestimated it.
  • Ventilation as a Primary Driver: There was a strong negative correlation between ventilation rates and ambient hazard concentrations. In Factory Y, doubling the ventilation air changing rate (from ~5.76 to ~12.93 t/h) was a key factor in bringing previously "disqualified" work positions into compliance with Occupational Exposure Limits (OEL).
  • Biochemical vs. Structural Changes: Interestingly, while liver enzyme levels (ALT, AST, GGT) showed significant improvement within one year, the rates of fatty liver (detected via ultrasound) did not decrease significantly. This suggests that biochemical stress responds quickly to reduced exposure, but structural liver changes require longer-term recovery or different interventions.
  • Technique-Specific Impact: Improvements were more pronounced in Factory Y (acetylene-based). This factory initially relied more on general ventilation and had more "room for improvement" compared to the more modern, outdoor-oriented Factory Z.

Key Results

  • Risk Level Decline: In Factory Y, risk levels for positions like ore breaking and welding dropped from "High" or "Medium" to "Low" under the comprehensive index model.
  • Environmental Compliance: Several work areas that failed to meet OEL requirements in 2020 were successfully brought into compliance by 2021.
  • Clinical Improvement: In Factory Y, the rate of abnormal hepatic symptoms (excluding fatty liver) dropped from 16.3% to 8.1%. Significant reductions in the mean levels of ALT, AST, and GGT were observed, particularly in the acetylene-based production line.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Short Duration: A one-year follow-up is insufficient to observe changes in chronic conditions like fatty liver or the incidence of liver cancer.
  • Measurement Gaps: The study could not quantify the mercury catalyst (HgCl2) used in Factory Y because it exists in a solid state during production, though it remains a significant occupational concern.
  • Natural Ventilation: The impact of natural ventilation at Factory Z (where many facilities are outdoors) was difficult to isolate from the engineering improvements.

Future Work: The researchers suggest long-term longitudinal studies to determine if these engineering controls lead to a sustained decrease in chronic liver disease and long-term cancer risk among PVC workers.

Summary updated

Abstract

Acetylene hydrochlorination and ethylene oxychlorination are the two most common methods of producing vinyl chloride monomer (VCM), which has been linked to liver impairment, hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), and angiosarcoma of the liver (ASL) in occupational settings. However, whether and how these impairments could be effectively improved from workplace root causes has yet to be discovered. This study aimed to evaluate whether improvements in protective measures in groups Y (408 subjects) and Z (349 subjects) could have an influential impact on the alleviation of liver impairment by comparing risk assessment levels under several semi-quantitative models and results from liver ultrasound detection and liver function tests before and after the improvement. Importantly, significant differences in constituent ratio involved in parameters among age, length of employment, weekly exposure time, smoking status, alcohol consumption, and sleeping quality were found between Y and Z before improvement took place in 2020 (<i>P</i> < 0.05 or <i>P</i> < 0.001), and population distribution by gender between Y and Z was in a large homogeneity with differences in age and length of employment. C<sub>STE</sub> involves ore breaking, acetylene generation, steam stripping, outward processing, and welding maintenance, was disqualified in 2020 compared to OEL, and was said to have declined to meet OEL requirements by 2021. Further, a negative correction of fresh air requirement and ventilation air changing rate with ambient concentration toward hazards in Y was stronger in 2021 than in 2020. Significant differences in risk levels in Y between 2020 and 2021 were found as ore breaking, acetylene generation, steam stripping, outward processing, VCM polymerization, welding, and repairing, decreasing to relatively lower risk levels in 2021 from the original ones in 2020 only under the semi-quantitative comprehensive index model. Abnormal rates toward other hepatic symptoms decreased in the majority of positions after the improvement, as referred to by alterations such as ALT, AST, and GGT. Overall, the effect of improvements on protective measures effectively reduced positions' risk assessment levels through ventilation enhancement and airtight strengthening, which further affected abnormal rates toward other hepatic symptoms, and alterations such as ALT, AST, and GGT were much more significant in Y than effect in Z.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dong2022improvements,
  author = {Yiwen Dong and Xingang Wang and Weijiang Hu and Hongying Bian and Xin Wang and Ning Kang and Feng Han and Siyu Zhang and Meng Ye},
  title = {{Improvements in protective measures in factories with acetylene hydrochlorination and ethylene oxychlorination techniques declined risk assessment levels and affected liver health status}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2022.1053300},
}
Figure