Improved phase separation in polymer solar cells by solvent blending

Christian Kästner, Burhan Muhsin, Andreas Wild, Daniel Ayuk Mbi Egbe, Silke Rathgeber, Harald HoppeJournal of Polymer Science Part B Polymer Physics 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how mixing solvents (chlorobenzene and chloroform) during the fabrication of polymer solar cells can significantly improve the performance of the active layer. By carefully controlling the solvent blend, researchers achieved better separation between the donor polymer and the electron acceptor (PCBM), leading to higher short-circuit currents and overall improved solar cell efficiencies, even at lower acceptor concentrations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Organic photovoltaics (OPVs), particularly those based on the bulk heterojunction (BHJ) concept, hold great promise for flexible and low-cost solar energy harvesting. The efficiency of these devices hinges critically on the nanoscale morphology of the active layer, which consists of an intermixed blend of a donor polymer and an electron acceptor (typically a fullerene derivative like PCBM). Achieving optimal phase separation – where the donor and acceptor form distinct, interpenetrating networks – is crucial for efficient charge generation and transport. However, controlling this morphology during film formation is challenging. Factors like solvent choice, polymer concentration, and the ratio of donor to acceptor all play a role, and finding the right combination can be a complex optimization problem. This paper specifically addresses how solvent blending, as a processing parameter, can be leveraged to achieve better phase separation and thus enhance the performance of a particular donor polymer (AnE-PVcc) in BHJ solar cells.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to characterize the thin films and solar cells:

  • Photophysical Investigations: UV-Vis absorption and photoluminescence (PL) spectroscopy were used to probe the electronic properties and intermolecular interactions (like π-π stacking) within the polymer films as a function of PCBM concentration and solvent composition.
  • Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM): Tapping mode AFM was used to visualize the surface topography of the thin films, providing insights into the nanoscale morphology at the film surface.
  • Grazing Incidence Wide-Angle X-ray Scattering (GIWAXS): This technique was crucial for understanding the bulk morphology of the thin films. GIWAXS provides information about the arrangement and orientation of polymer chains and acceptor molecules in the solid state, including the degree of crystallinity and preferred orientations (e.g., face-on vs. edge-on stacking).
  • Solar Cell Device Fabrication and Characterization: Standard procedures were followed to fabricate complete solar cell devices. Current-voltage (IV) measurements under simulated sunlight were performed to evaluate key performance parameters such as short-circuit current (Jsc), open-circuit voltage (Voc), fill factor (FF), and overall power conversion efficiency (PCE).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental characterization of fabricated thin films and devices.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Solvent Blending as a Morphological Control Tool: The core idea is that mixing solvents with different properties (like vapor pressure and solubility parameters) can significantly influence the drying dynamics and thus the phase separation process during film formation.
  • Facilitating Phase Separation: Using a blend of chlorobenzene (CB) and chloroform (CF) was found to promote better phase separation between the AnE-PVcc polymer and PCBM compared to using pure CB alone. This is attributed to the differential evaporation rates and solubilities.
  • Lower PCBM Concentrations for Optimal Performance: A key finding is that solvent blending allows for achieving optimal phase separation and thus high short-circuit currents at lower PCBM concentrations. This is economically and practically advantageous.
  • Morphology-Performance Link: The study successfully links structural information (from GIWAXS and PL) to device performance (Jsc). Improved phase separation, indicated by GIWAXS scattering patterns and PL quenching, directly correlates with enhanced charge transport.
  • PCBM Behavior at High Concentrations: At high PCBM concentrations, the blend morphology becomes less dependent on the solvent, suggesting a saturation point where PCBM forms its own domains regardless of processing.

Key Results

  • Solar cell efficiencies of up to 2.8% were achieved for the AnE-PVcc-based solar cells using optimized solvent blending and PCBM ratios.
  • Deposition from CF:CB solvent mixtures facilitated beneficial phase separation, leading to improved charge transport properties (higher short-circuit currents).
  • Maximum photocurrents were achieved at lower PCBM concentrations when using solvent mixtures compared to pure solvents. For example, a balanced CB:CF ratio (50:50) required a lower PCBM concentration for maximum Jsc compared to pure CB or CF.
  • GIWAXS data indicated that the PCBM phase scattering was generally isotropic, suggesting no preferred orientation of PCBM domains relative to the substrate, but the addition of CF increased the degree of phase separation.
  • PL spectra showed increasing quenching with increasing PCBM concentration, indicating enhanced intercalation and interfacial area between the polymer and PCBM.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited to One Polymer System: The study focuses on a specific anthracene-containing polymer (AnE-PVcc). While the principles are likely generalizable, further studies on other polymer systems would be beneficial.
  • AFM Surface Morphology Limitations: The authors acknowledge that AFM surface topography measurements do not always unambiguously detect domain formation and do not provide insight into the morphology of deeper regions of the thin films.
  • Other Performance Parameters: While Jsc was the primary focus for morphology correlation, other parameters like Voc and FF were also affected by processing but were more difficult to directly link to morphology due to processing difficulties.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the approach of solvent mixing provides a valuable strategy to reduce the PCBM concentration required for favorable morphologies in AnE-PVcc:PCBM blends and potentially in other polymer:fullerene donor-acceptor systems. This implies further exploration of different solvent combinations and polymer systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT The effect of solvent blending on the performance of an anthracene‐containing poly( p ‐phenylene‐ethynylene)‐alt‐poly( p ‐phenylene‐vinylene) backbone‐based donor polymer with asymmetrically substituted branched 2‐ethylhexyloxy and methyloxy side‐chains in bulk heterojunction solar cells is reported. This copolymer yields relatively high open‐circuit voltages with fullerene‐based electron acceptors. We systematically studied the thin‐film blend morphology and solar cell performance as a function of solvent composition (chlorobenzene to chloroform ratio) and polymer to [6,6]‐phenyl C61‐butyric acid methylester (PCBM) ratio. We combined photophysical investigations with atomic force microscopy and grazing incidence wide‐angle X‐ray scattering to elucidate the solid‐state morphology in thin films. In the investigated polymer system, the blend morphology becomes independent of the supporting solvent for high PCBM concentrations. Deposition from solvent blends rather than from pure chlorobenzene facilitates the beneficial phase separation between polymer and PCBM, leading to improved charge transport properties (short‐circuit currents) at lower PCBM concentrations. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part B: Polym Phys, 2013, 51, 868–874
BibTeX
@article{kastner2013improved,
  author = {Christian Kästner and Burhan Muhsin and Andreas Wild and Daniel Ayuk Mbi Egbe and Silke Rathgeber and Harald Hoppe},
  title = {{Improved phase separation in polymer solar cells by solvent blending}},
  journal = {Journal of Polymer Science Part B Polymer Physics},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1002/polb.23286},
}
Figure