Improved Orange and Red Ca2+ Indicators and Photophysical Considerations for Optogenetic Applications

Jiahui Wu, Lin Liu, Tomoki Matsuda, Yongxin Zhao, Aleksander Rebane, Mikhail Drobizhev, Yu-Fen Chang, Satoko Araki, Yoshiyuki Arai, Kelsey March, Thomas E. Hughes, Ken Sagou, Takaki Miyata, Takeharu Nagai, Wen-Hong Li, Robert E. CampbellACS 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces new orange and red genetically encoded calcium indicators (GECOs) with significantly improved signal-to-noise ratios for tracking intracellular calcium. Crucially, it identifies and characterizes a photoactivation artifact in red GECOs when used with optogenetic tools like channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2), providing guidelines to avoid it for simultaneous optogenetic control and calcium imaging.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Researchers often need to monitor intracellular calcium (Ca²⁺) dynamics, especially in conjunction with optogenetic tools that control neuronal activity with light. Existing genetically encoded Ca²⁺ indicators, while powerful, have limitations in their spectral range and signal strength. Specifically, there's a need for indicators that emit in the orange and red parts of the spectrum, which offer advantages like reduced autofluorescence and deeper tissue penetration. Furthermore, when combining red fluorescent Ca²⁺ indicators with optogenetic actuators like channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2) – which is activated by blue light – a critical challenge arises: the blue light used to activate ChR2 can inadvertently cause the red indicator to fluoresce, leading to false positives in Ca²⁺ measurements. This paper aims to expand the palette of red/orange Ca²⁺ indicators and address this critical photophysical interference.

Methods

The researchers employed protein engineering techniques to develop new GECO variants. This involved:

  • Directed Evolution and Library Screening: They created genetic libraries by randomizing key amino acid positions in existing red fluorescent protein (FP) scaffolds (inspired by mPlum and mOrange). These libraries were then screened using ratiometric fluorescence to identify variants with improved Ca²⁺ responses and red-shifted emission.
  • In Vitro Characterization: Purified indicator proteins were analyzed for their excitation and emission spectra, Ca²⁺ affinity (K<0xE1><0xB5><0x83>), fluorescence quantum yield, extinction coefficients, and two-photon cross-sections.
  • Cellular and Tissue Imaging: The new indicators were tested in live cells (HeLa, INS-1 beta cells) and ex vivo mouse neocortical slice cultures. This involved co-expression with ChR2 and stimulation with blue light to assess Ca²⁺ transients and the photoactivation artifact.
  • Photophysical Studies: Detailed in vitro experiments were conducted to investigate the mechanism of photoactivation using UV-Vis spectroscopy under varying pH and light intensities.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed in the paper as distinct datasets. The primary "data" consists of:

  • Spectroscopic Data: Excitation and emission spectra, absorbance changes, and fluorescence intensity measurements from purified indicators and cells.
  • Imaging Data: Time-lapse fluorescence microscopy recordings from cell cultures and brain slices showing Ca²⁺ dynamics and ChR2 activation.
  • Quantitative Measurements: Signal changes (fold-increase), K<0xE1><0xB5><0x83> values, two-photon cross-sections, and photoactivation kinetics.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Expanded Spectral Palette: The development of CAR-GECO1 (dark red), R-GECO1.2 (improved red), and O-GECO1 (orange) significantly broadens the available colors for Ca²⁺ imaging, enabling multiplexed experiments.
  • Enhanced Signal-to-Noise: The new indicators show substantially improved intensiometric signal changes (1.7- to 9.7-fold better than R-GECO1) in vitro and in cells, leading to clearer detection of Ca²⁺ transients.
  • Critical Photoactivation Artifact: A major finding is the discovery that red GECOs (especially R-GECO1.2 and CAR-GECO1) undergo photoactivation when exposed to the blue light (around 405 nm) used to activate ChR2. This photoactivation causes a transient increase in fluorescence, mimicking a Ca²⁺ signal and leading to false positives.
  • Mechanism of Photoactivation: The paper proposes a model where violet/blue light shifts the chromophore equilibrium towards a neutral, nonfluorescent anionic form, which then undergoes a slower conversion to a red fluorescent form. This is distinct from simple protonation state changes and may involve a Z to E isomerization of the chromophore.
  • Mitigation Strategies: The research demonstrates that this photoactivation artifact can be managed by carefully controlling the intensity and duration of the blue light used for ChR2 activation, or by introducing a delay after stimulation to allow the indicator fluorescence to recover.

Key Results

  • New Indicators:
    • O-GECO1: 146× intensity change in vitro, K<0xE1><0xB5><0x83> of 1500 nM, 85 GM two-photon cross-section.
  • R-GECO1.2: 33× intensity change in vitro, K<0xE1><0xB5><0x83> of 1200 nM.
  • CAR-GECO1: 27× intensity change in vitro, K<0xE1><0xB5><0x83> of 490 nM.
  • Cellular Performance: O-GECO1 showed the best performance in HeLa cells with ~41-fold intensity changes. R-GECO1.2 and CAR-GECO1 showed ~11-fold changes.
  • ChR2 Integration: INS-1 cells co-expressing ChR2 and R-GECO1.2 or Lyn-R-GECO1.2 showed robust Ca²⁺ transients upon brief blue light pulses.
  • Photoactivation Magnitude: In cells, blue light illumination (even when ChR2 was off) caused up to a 12% increase in R-GECO1 fluorescence. In vitro, photoactivation led to absorbance increases of up to ~631% for CAR-GECO1.
  • pH Dependence: Photoactivation was most significant around pH 7 and diminished at higher and lower pH values.
  • Ca²⁺ State Effect: Photoactivation was greatly diminished in the Ca²⁺-bound state of the indicators.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Photoactivation Artifact: While manageable, the photoactivation artifact remains a significant consideration when using red GECOs with blue light activators. The paper suggests that Lyn-targeted GECOs (tethered to the plasma membrane) can mitigate this, but this approach may be limited to specific cellular compartments.
  • Alternative Indicators: The authors mention RCaMP red fluorescent Ca²⁺ indicators as an alternative that exhibits smaller Ca²⁺-dependent changes but does not undergo photoactivation, suggesting they might be preferred in certain scenarios.
  • Mechanism Nuances: While a model is proposed, the exact structural changes during photoactivation require further investigation.
  • Future Directions: The authors anticipate that these new tools will stimulate further efforts to combine genetically encoded Ca²⁺ indicators and optogenetic tools for simultaneous activation and imaging in various cell types, including neurons in brain tissue. They also suggest exploring indicators with faster recovery times (like R-GECO1.2) for situations requiring rapid Ca²⁺ signal resolution after optogenetic stimulation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We have used protein engineering to expand the palette of genetically encoded calcium ion (Ca(2+)) indicators to include orange and improved red fluorescent variants, and validated the latter for combined use with optogenetic activation by channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2). These indicators feature intensiometric signal changes that are 1.7- to 9.7-fold improved relatively to the progenitor Ca(2+) indicator, R-GECO1. In the course of this work, we discovered a photoactivation phenomenon in red fluorescent Ca(2+) indicators that, if not appreciated and accounted for, can cause false-positive artifacts in Ca(2+) imaging traces during optogenetic activation with ChR2. We demonstrate, in both a beta cell line and slice culture of developing mouse neocortex, that these artifacts can be avoided by using an appropriately low intensity of blue light for ChR2 activation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2013improved,
  author = {Jiahui Wu and Lin Liu and Tomoki Matsuda and Yongxin Zhao and Aleksander Rebane and Mikhail Drobizhev and Yu-Fen Chang and Satoko Araki and Yoshiyuki Arai and Kelsey March and Thomas E. Hughes and Ken Sagou and Takaki Miyata and Takeharu Nagai and Wen-Hong Li and Robert E. Campbell},
  title = {{Improved Orange and Red Ca<sup>2+</sup> Indicators and Photophysical Considerations for Optogenetic Applications}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1021/cn400012b},
}
Figure