Improved Latency-communication Trade-off for Map-shuffle-reduce Systems with Stragglers

Jingjing Zhang, Osvaldo SimeoneICASSP 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel coding scheme for distributed computing systems that significantly improves the trade-off between computation latency and communication overhead, especially in the presence of "straggler" servers that complete tasks slower than others. By cleverly leveraging repetition codes, the authors show it's possible to reduce the need for complex MDS codes, leading to faster shuffling and overall system performance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Distributed computing systems, like those used for large-scale data processing (e.g., machine learning training), often employ a "map-shuffle-reduce" paradigm. In this setup, multiple servers work on parts of a task. The "map" phase involves initial computations, followed by a "shuffle" phase where intermediate results are exchanged, and finally a "reduce" phase to combine everything. A major challenge is the presence of "stragglers" – servers that are slower and can bottleneck the entire process. To mitigate this, researchers have explored coding techniques. One approach uses Maximum Distance Separable (MDS) codes to recover from lost or delayed data (erasures) and repetition codes to reduce the amount of data that needs to be communicated during the shuffle. However, existing methods still face limitations in optimizing both latency and communication load simultaneously. This paper aims to find a better balance by rethinking how these codes are used.

Methods

The core of this paper's contribution lies in a refined approach to concatenated coding for map-shuffle-reduce systems. The authors build upon a prior scheme that uses an outer MDS code for erasure correction and an inner repetition code for coded multicasting during the shuffle.

The key innovation is to repurpose the redundancy introduced by the repetition code. Instead of solely relying on the MDS code for straggler tolerance, the paper demonstrates how the repetition code's redundancy can be leveraged to:

  • Increase the effective rate of the outer MDS code: This allows for more efficient use of the MDS code's error-correcting capabilities.
  • Reduce the reliance on the MDS code: In certain scenarios (e.g., when the number of non-stragglers is sufficiently high), the MDS code can even be entirely omitted, simplifying the scheme.
  • Enhance multicasting opportunities: The repetition code's structure is used to facilitate more efficient coded multicasting during the shuffle phase, reducing the total amount of data exchanged.

The paper introduces a general framework and then provides specific propositions and proofs to characterize the achievable communication load under various conditions, identifying sufficient conditions for the rates of the MDS and repetition codes to ensure a feasible and efficient policy.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a theoretical framework and simulation-based evaluation rather than training or testing on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Repetition codes are more versatile than previously thought: The paper shows that repetition codes can contribute not only to bandwidth reduction but also to latency reduction by aiding in straggler tolerance.
  • Synergy between MDS and repetition codes: By carefully choosing the rates of both codes, a more optimal trade-off can be achieved than by treating them as independent components.
  • Eliminating the MDS code is possible: For a sufficient number of non-straggling servers, the system can operate effectively using only repetition codes, simplifying the architecture and potentially improving performance.
  • Improved latency-communication trade-off: The proposed scheme demonstrably outperforms existing methods in achieving a better balance between how quickly results are obtained and how much data is transferred.

Key Results

The paper presents a new achievable communication load formula, $L(q)$, which is shown to be no larger than the load achieved by the prior scheme in [5]. Numerical examples and plots (Figure 4) illustrate that the proposed scheme offers a positive reduction in communication load for intermediate values of computation latency, especially as the total number of servers ($K$) increases. For instance, with $K=100$ and a specific latency, the proposed scheme reduces communication load by a factor of 2 to 2.5 compared to the scheme in [5]. The paper also provides conditions under which the MDS code can be avoided, leading to a simpler and potentially more efficient system.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Theoretical framework: While the paper provides a strong theoretical foundation and demonstrates performance improvements through analysis and numerical examples, direct experimental validation on real-world distributed systems would be valuable.
  • Specific task: The analysis is focused on matrix multiplication. Extending the framework to other map-shuffle-reduce tasks could reveal further insights.
  • Parameter selection: The paper identifies conditions for feasible rate pairs $(r_1, r_2)$, but the optimal selection of these rates for specific system configurations and workload characteristics might require further investigation.
  • Dynamic straggler behavior: The current model assumes a certain distribution of straggler behavior. Adapting the scheme to more dynamic or adversarial straggler patterns could be a future direction.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2019improved,
  author = {Jingjing Zhang and Osvaldo Simeone},
  title = {{Improved Latency-communication Trade-off for Map-shuffle-reduce Systems with Stragglers}},
  booktitle = {IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech and Signal Processing},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/icassp.2019.8682404},
}
Figure