Improved Gravity Wave Drag to Enhance Precipitation Simulation: A Case Study of Typhoon In-Fa

Kun Liu, F. Richard Yu, Yong Su, Hongliang Zhang, Qiying Chen, Jian SunAtmosphere 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "scale-aware" gravity wave drag (GWD) parameterization for numerical weather prediction models. By moving beyond idealized assumptions and incorporating subgrid-scale orography variability, the improved GWD scheme significantly enhances the simulation of precipitation, particularly during extreme events like Typhoon In-Fa, and improves forecasts of near-surface atmospheric conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Numerical weather prediction (NWP) models struggle to accurately simulate precipitation, especially during intense events like typhoons. A significant source of this uncertainty lies in how these models represent gravity wave drag (GWD), a process where atmospheric waves generated by mountains influence wind patterns and, consequently, weather. Traditional GWD parameterizations often use simplified assumptions about mountain shapes (like idealized ellipses) that make them insensitive to changes in model resolution. This "scale insensitivity" leads to systematic biases in simulated wind stress and can propagate into inaccurate precipitation forecasts. The challenge is to develop a GWD scheme that can better capture the complex interaction between subgrid-scale orography and atmospheric flows across different model resolutions.

Methods

The core of this research is the development and implementation of a modified "scale-aware" orography GWD parameterization within the China Meteorological Administration Global Forecast System (CMA-GFS). Key methodological advancements include:

  • Fourier Transform for Subgrid-Scale Orography: Instead of relying on idealized elliptical assumptions for subgrid-scale orography (SSO), the new scheme uses Fourier transforms to derive GWD coefficients directly from high-resolution terrain data. This allows for a more accurate representation of the variability and complexity of subgrid orography.
  • Revised Flow-Blocking Drag (FBD) Calculation: The calculation of the dividing streamline height (ha), a crucial parameter for FBD, was modified to better account for subgrid orography characteristics. This refinement aims to improve the representation of drag effects caused by blocked flow over mountains.
  • Scale-Awareness: The modifications are designed to make the GWD parameterization more sensitive to changes in horizontal resolution, addressing the scale insensitivity issue of traditional schemes.

Datasets

  • Terrain Data: Global 30 Arc-Second Elevation data set (GTOP30) from the United States Geological Survey was used for terrain information.
  • Reanalysis Data: ERA5 reanalysis data (0.25° resolution) was used for initial conditions and for comparing model outputs.
  • Sea Surface Temperature (SST): Operational Sea Surface Temperature and Sea Ice Analysis (OSTIA) data was used for initial SST forcing.
  • Observational Precipitation Data: China Meteorological Administration Multisource Precipitation Analysis System (CMPAS) data (0.05° resolution, hourly) was used for evaluating precipitation forecasts.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Idealized Mountains: The study demonstrates that moving away from simplified elliptical assumptions for subgrid orography is crucial for improving GWD simulations. Capturing the variability of subgrid orography is key.
  • Resolution Matters (Now): The modified GWD scheme makes the model's wind field tendencies more sensitive to horizontal resolution changes, a significant improvement over previous scale-insensitive schemes.
  • Cascading Impacts: Improvements in GWD directly affect low-level wind fields, which in turn influence integrated water vapor transport, ascending motions, and ultimately, precipitation patterns.
  • FBD is Key: The enhanced Flow-Blocking Drag (FBD) effect, due to the modified parameterization, contributes significantly (over 80%) to the total changes in GWD.

Key Results

  • Precipitation Improvement: The GWD-25d experiment significantly reduced accumulated precipitation biases compared to the control (CTL-25d), particularly in the southern regions of Typhoon In-Fa's landfall. It also improved the simulation of intense precipitation centers and hourly precipitation intensity. Relative bias was reduced by up to 10% in key areas.
  • Wind Field Enhancement: The improved scheme reduced overestimated wind speeds at 850 hPa and aided in simulating the typhoon's center location more accurately. It also showed improvements in middle and upper tropospheric geopotential height.
  • Medium-Range Forecasts: Statistical analysis of 8-day forecasts showed that the GWD-25d experiment improved Equitable Threat Scores (ETS) for precipitation, especially for light rain and intense events. It also reduced Root Mean Square Errors (RMSE) for 2m temperature and 10m winds, bringing them closer to or comparable with EC forecasts.
  • Scale Sensitivity: The modified scheme showed a more sensitive response of parameterized horizontal wind tendencies to resolution changes (0.125° vs. 0.25°) compared to the standard CMA-GFS, which is considered more realistic.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Fourier Transform Complexity: While the study uses Fourier transforms to derive GWD coefficients, it notes that the full implementation of a scale-aware Fourier transform scheme, especially for complex terrains like East Asia's Tibetan Plateau, is a complex task that warrants further investigation.
  • Downstream Impacts: The paper suggests that the potential influence of this improved GWD on downstream circulation patterns and precipitation simulations, particularly in regions with unique terrain, needs further study.
  • Turbulent Orographic Form Drag: The authors indicate that future work will investigate the effects of turbulent orographic form drag processes in conjunction with horizontal resolution enhancement.
  • Comparison with EC Forecast: While the GWD-25d shows improvements, there's still a gap in scores above 1 mm precipitation compared to EC's forecast, suggesting room for further refinement.

Summary updated

Abstract

Traditional gravity wave drag parameterizations produce wind stresses that are insensitive to changing horizontal resolution in numerical weather prediction (NWP), partly due to the idealized elliptical assumption. This study employs the modified subgrid-scale orography scheme based on the Fourier transform into gravity wave drag scheme of the China Meteorological Administration Global Forecast System (CMA-GFS) to assess its impacts on simulating precipitation during the slow-moving period of Typhoon In-Fa after its landfall in Zhejiang Province, China. The simulation with the updated scheme can effectively reduce the accumulated precipitation bias of the control one and improve the simulation of precipitation distribution and intensity, especially in the hourly precipitation simulation. The improved scheme primarily influences the wind field of the low-level troposphere and also changes the convergence of the integrated water vapor transport and ascending motions related to the reduced precipitation biases. The modified scheme enhances the tendencies of the horizontal winds caused by the varying horizontal resolutions in the model, strengthening the sensitivity of the gravity wave drag across the horizontal scales. Results from medium-range forecasts indicate the modified scheme benefits the statistics scores of precipitation over China and also reduces root-mean-square errors of 2 m temperature and 10 m winds.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023improved,
  author = {Kun Liu and F. Richard Yu and Yong Su and Hongliang Zhang and Qiying Chen and Jian Sun},
  title = {{Improved Gravity Wave Drag to Enhance Precipitation Simulation: A Case Study of Typhoon In-Fa}},
  booktitle = {Atmosphere},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/atmos14121801},
}

Loading related content...

Figure