Improved estimators of extreme Wang distortion risk measures for very heavy-tailed distributions

Jonathan El Methni, Gilles StupflerEconometrics 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of accurately estimating extreme financial risks (like insurance losses) when the underlying data distribution has a "heavy tail," meaning extreme events are more frequent and impactful than in a normal distribution. The authors introduce improved estimation methods that are more robust to these heavy tails, leading to more reliable risk assessments, especially in challenging scenarios.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Estimating extreme financial risks is crucial for institutions like insurance companies to ensure they can cover potential losses. These risks are often modeled using "Wang distortion risk measures," which are a flexible class of tools that include common measures like Value-at-Risk (VaR) and Tail-Value-at-Risk (TVaR). However, when the probability distribution of these risks has a "heavy tail" (meaning extreme events occur more often than expected), standard estimation methods can become highly unreliable. This is because extreme values in the data can disproportionately influence the estimates, leading to significant over or underestimation of risk. The paper aims to develop more stable and accurate estimators for these extreme risk measures in the presence of heavy-tailed distributions.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in developing "trimmed" and "winsorised" versions of existing estimators.

  • Trimmed Estimators: These methods work by discarding a certain percentage of the most extreme observations in the sample before calculating the risk measure. This helps to reduce the influence of outliers.
  • Winsorised Estimators: Instead of discarding extreme values, winsorising replaces them with less extreme values (e.g., replacing the highest value with the second-highest). This also aims to mitigate the impact of outliers.

The authors then propose a two-stage approach: first, they apply these trimmed or winsorised estimators to reduce variability, and second, they introduce a bias-correction step. This correction factor is designed to bring the estimates closer to the true values, leveraging information about the tail behavior of the data. They also provide theoretical guarantees (asymptotic normality and consistency) for these new estimators under specific conditions.

Datasets

The authors evaluate their proposed methods using:

  • Simulated Data: They generate data from Fréchet and Burr distributions, which are known to exhibit heavy tails, allowing them to control parameters like the tail index ($\gamma$) and second-order parameter ($\rho$).
  • Real Data: They apply their methods to a dataset of French commercial fire losses, which is a practical application for insurance risk assessment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Heavy tails are a major challenge: The paper strongly emphasizes how heavy-tailed distributions can severely impact the reliability of standard risk estimation methods, leading to high variability and bias.
  • Trimming and winsorising offer robustness: By strategically removing or adjusting extreme data points, these techniques can significantly improve the stability and accuracy of risk estimates.
  • A two-stage approach is effective: Combining trimming/winsorising with a bias-correction step appears to be a powerful strategy for achieving both reduced variability and improved accuracy.
  • Bias-correction is key for extreme cases: While trimming/winsorising helps with variability, the bias-correction step is crucial for bringing the estimates closer to the true risk values, especially in challenging scenarios.
  • Practical implications for insurance: The methods developed have direct relevance for insurance companies needing to accurately assess capital requirements and price policies, particularly in the face of extreme events.

Key Results

  • The proposed trimmed (CTrim-PL) and winsorised (CWins-PL) estimators demonstrate reduced finite-sample variability compared to the standard empirical estimator.
  • In challenging cases with very heavy tails, these new estimators significantly reduce bias, sometimes by more than 75%, especially for the Proportional Hazard (PH) risk measure.
  • The bias-correction step is shown to be particularly effective in atypical scenarios where extreme values are highly variable.
  • On a real dataset of commercial fire losses, the CWins-PL estimator provided a lower estimate of extreme risk compared to the standard PL estimator, suggesting that the latter might be overestimating risk.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Bias in moderate cases: The authors acknowledge that their corrected estimators might exhibit slightly worse bias than the standard PL estimator in some moderately heavy-tailed scenarios, as the correction factor is based on approximations that might not perfectly capture all information from extreme data.
  • Dependence on tail index estimation: The performance of the estimators relies on accurate estimation of the tail index ($\gamma$), which itself can be challenging.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest designing a correction factor that incorporates second-order information to potentially close the gap with the full PL estimator in standard cases and further improve performance in difficult cases. They also note the challenge of constructing such a factor due to the volatility of second-order parameter estimators.

Summary updated

Abstract

A general way to study the extremes of a random variable is to consider the family of its Wang distortion risk measures. This class of risk measures encompasses several indicators such as the classical quantile/Value-at-Risk, the Tail-Value-at-Risk and Conditional Tail Moments. Trimmed and winsorised versions of the empirical counterparts of extreme analogues of Wang distortion risk measures are considered. Their asymptotic properties are analysed, and it is shown that it is possible to construct corrected versions of trimmed or winsorised estimators of extreme Wang distortion risk measures who appear to perform overall better than their standard empirical counterparts in difficult finite-sample situations when the underlying distribution has a very heavy right tail. This technique is showcased on a set of real fire insurance data.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{methni2017improved,
  author = {Jonathan El Methni and Gilles Stupfler},
  title = {{Improved estimators of extreme Wang distortion risk measures for very heavy-tailed distributions}},
  booktitle = {Econometrics},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1016/j.ecosta.2017.03.002},
}
Figure