Improper Acupuncture Causing Severe Multiple Soft Tissue Damage: A Case Report

yulong xie, yan peng, wengzong zhou, qiantong qin, Hui Wang, bing ni, Wenjie Wang, tianyu li, yanqing liu, donghong jiang, yunxia dong, rui miaoResearch 2020 · DOI

Introduction

Acupuncture is a widely recognized "Category A" recommendation for stroke rehabilitation, often used to improve motor function and facilitate recovery. However, many stroke patients require long-term anticoagulant therapy, such as warfarin, to prevent secondary infarctions. This creates a clinical challenge: while acupuncture is generally safe, coagulation dysfunction significantly narrows the margin for error. This case report details a severe complication arising from improper acupuncture technique in an anticoagulated patient and outlines the successful multi-modal rehabilitation strategy used to resolve it.

Case Presentation

A 63-year-old female patient with a history of stroke was readmitted to the hospital two years after her initial discharge. She presented with a massive 20x20 cm subcutaneous hematoma on her lateral thigh following an acupuncture session.

Upon clinical evaluation, her International Standardized Ratio (INR) was 2.48, indicating therapeutic anticoagulation. The severity of the injury was exacerbated by a "double hit": following the initial improper needle placement—likely involving incorrect depth and angle in a highly vascularized muscular area—the patient’s family attempted to "massage and pull" the bruised area. This mechanical stress caused the localized bleeding to spread extensively across the soft tissue.

Management and Treatment

The clinical team implemented a comprehensive physical factor therapy regimen to dissipate the hematoma and restore mobility:

  • Ultrasound Therapy: Initially applied at 1.0 W/cm² (8 minutes, twice daily) to reduce acute swelling. As the hematoma "organized" (hardened into deep tissue masses), the intensity was increased to 1.8 W/cm² to break down the semi-solid blocks.
  • Thermal and Magnetic Therapies: Infrared and wax therapies were used to promote local blood circulation, while magnetic therapy was employed to modulate the inflammatory response.
  • Traditional Chinese Massage: Specific techniques were used to dredge meridians and remove local blood stasis once the acute phase had passed.
  • Kinesiotherapy: A graduated exercise program focusing on muscle strength and balance was introduced as the hematoma subsided.

Results

The patient’s recovery followed a clear timeline, demonstrating the efficacy of the targeted physical therapy.

Progression of the 20x20 cm subcutaneous hematoma over 22 days of treatment.

At the 10-day mark, the hematoma had reduced by 75% in area (to approximately 10x10 cm), though limb stiffness remained a concern. By day 22, the visible subcutaneous hematoma had completely disappeared, and the patient regained full range-of-motion under gravity. She was discharged on day 28 with a Barthel Index score significantly improved from her admission state, returning to a strictly monitored anticoagulant plan with a target INR of 2.0–3.0.

Discussion and Clinical Implications

This case highlights several critical insights for practitioners:

  1. Contraindication vs. Caution: Coagulation dysfunction is not a contraindication for acupuncture. However, it requires heightened vigilance. While healthy patients might only experience minor bruising (≤3x3 cm) from improper technique, the same error in an anticoagulated patient can lead to a medical emergency.
  2. Anatomical Precision: There is a noted gap where some practitioners may rely on traditional meridian theory without sufficient grounding in Western medical anatomy. Precise knowledge of needle depth and angle is essential to avoid deep-seated vascular injury.
  3. Post-Injury Care: Education for patients and families is vital. Mechanical manipulation (like aggressive massage) of a fresh bruise in a patient on blood thinners can drastically worsen the injury.
  4. Deep Tissue Organization: Even after surface bruising clears, deep "hard blocks" may persist, requiring higher-intensity ultrasound to fully resolve.

Conclusion

While acupuncture remains a valuable tool in stroke recovery, this case serves as a validation of the potential adverse reactions caused by improper technique in high-risk populations. Standardized training in Western anatomy for TCM practitioners and the development of specific guidelines for treating patients on anticoagulants are necessary to eliminate such preventable injuries.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Acupuncture therapy is well known. But there is no report that acupuncture in patients with coagulation dysfunction in stroke may lead to severe soft tissue injury. we report a case of acupuncture leading to severe soft tissue injury. Methods A 63-year-old female patient was hospitalized for stroke rehabilitation. After 2 years of discharge, severe subcutaneous hematoma caused by acupuncture was readmitted to hospital. She received medication and physical rehabilitation. we monitored the international standardized ratio (INR) in plasma and observed the degree of dissipation of subcutaneous hematoma. the changes of patients during treatment were explored by data analysis. Findings Subcutaneous hematoma (area 20×20 cm) disappeared completely after 3 weeks of physical factor therapy. Small range (area ≤3×3 cm) subcutaneous hematoma can heal itself within 2 weeks. Improper acupuncture is only one of the causes of soft tissue injury. Stroke with coagulation dysfunction is not a contraindication of acupuncture treatment. Interpretation Our report suggests that previously unanticipated acupuncture treatment for stroke patients with coagulation dysfunction may lead to severe multiple soft tissue injuries. Although coagulation dysfunction is not a contraindication of acupuncture treatment, acupuncture treatment for stroke patients with coagulation dysfunction should be vigilant, strengthen the level of acupuncture operation, and fundamentally eliminate the problem. These cases are validation and supplement of adverse clinical reactions caused by improper acupuncture.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xie2020improper,
  author = {yulong xie and yan peng and wengzong zhou and qiantong qin and Hui Wang and bing ni and Wenjie Wang and tianyu li and yanqing liu and donghong jiang and yunxia dong and rui miao},
  title = {{Improper Acupuncture Causing Severe Multiple Soft Tissue Damage: A Case Report}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-118203/v1},
}
Figure