Implementing tin-prefiltration in routine clinical CT scans of the lower extremity: impact on radiation dose

Thomas Marth, Georg Wilhelm Kajdi, Christoph Stern, Reto SutterSkeletal 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that using a tin filter during routine CT scans of the pelvis, knee, and ankle can significantly reduce patient radiation dose by 60-70% without compromising image quality. This is the first study to show this benefit in clinical practice for musculoskeletal imaging, offering a practical way to adhere to radiation safety principles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Computed tomography (CT) scans are invaluable diagnostic tools, but they expose patients to ionizing radiation, which carries a risk of stochastic effects like cancer. The "As Low As Reasonably Achievable" (ALARA) principle guides radiologists to minimize radiation dose while maintaining diagnostic quality. While various dose reduction strategies exist, pre-filtering the X-ray beam with materials like tin has shown promise in research settings. Tin filters selectively absorb low-energy X-rays, which contribute to dose but not significantly to the image quality of high-contrast structures like bone. However, there was a lack of data on the real-world impact of this technique in routine clinical CT scans specifically for musculoskeletal imaging of the lower extremities. This paper aims to fill that gap by evaluating the radiation dose reduction and image quality changes when a tin filter is implemented in clinical practice for these scans.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective study comparing CT scans performed before and after the implementation of a tin filter on a single CT scanner. They included 300 clinically indicated CT scans of the pelvis, knee, and ankle, with 50 scans from each joint group for both the "conventional" (no tin filter) and "tin-prefiltered" groups.

Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Patient Selection: Patients with metal implants or under 18 years old were excluded to ensure comparability.
  • Data Extraction: Radiation dose parameters (CTDIvol, DLP, effective dose) were extracted from the scanner's monitoring system. Acquisition parameters (kV, mAs, collimation, etc.) were also recorded.
  • Quantitative Image Analysis: Standardized regions of interest (ROIs) were drawn on images to measure CT values (Hounsfield Units) and standard deviation (SD) in cortical bone, muscle, and subcutaneous fat. Signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) were calculated.
  • Qualitative Image Analysis: Two experienced musculoskeletal radiologists independently assessed anonymized images using a 4-point Likert scale for depiction of bone anatomy, soft tissue, image noise, image artifacts, and overall diagnostic image quality. They were blinded to the scan group.
  • Statistical Analysis: Mann-Whitney U tests were used to compare continuous variables, and Chi-square tests for gender. Weighted kappa coefficients assessed inter-reader agreement for qualitative measures.

Datasets

The study utilized retrospective clinical CT scans from a single institution. The dataset comprised 300 examinations from 288 patients, equally divided into conventional and tin-prefiltered groups for the pelvis, knee, and ankle. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Significant Dose Reduction is Achievable in Routine Practice: The most striking insight is that tin-prefiltration isn't just a research tool; it demonstrably reduces radiation dose in everyday clinical workflows for musculoskeletal CT.
  • Consistent Benefits Across Joints: The dose reduction was substantial and consistent across all three evaluated anatomical regions (pelvis, knee, ankle), ranging from 60% to 71%.
  • Image Quality Maintained: Crucially, this dose reduction did not come at the cost of diagnostic image quality. Radiologists rated the quality as "good" for all scans, and specific parameters like bone and soft tissue depiction showed no significant differences.
  • Image Noise Trade-off: While overall diagnostic quality was maintained, tin-prefiltration did lead to a statistically significant increase in image noise in the pelvis. However, this was rated as "moderate" and did not impact the radiologists' assessment of diagnostic quality.
  • Dose Reduction Magnitude Varies by Region: The absolute effective dose reduction was much larger for the pelvis compared to the knee and ankle. This is attributed to the higher inherent radiation sensitivity of organs in the pelvic region (bladder, gonads) compared to the less sensitive tissues in the knee and ankle.

Key Results

  • CTDIvol Reduction: Median CTDIvol was reduced by 65% in the pelvis, 73% in the knee, and 54% in the ankle.
  • Effective Dose Reduction: The median effective dose was reduced by 61% for the pelvis (from 3.78 to 1.49 mSv), 71% for the knee (from 0.21 to 0.06 mSv), and 60% for the ankle (from 0.05 to 0.02 mSv).
  • Image Quality: No significant differences were found in the depiction of bone anatomy, soft tissue, or image artifacts between conventional and tin-prefiltered scans for any reader in the knee and ankle. Diagnostic image quality was rated as "good" (4 out of 4) for all scans.
  • Image Noise: Image noise was significantly higher in the pelvis with tin-prefiltration (p<0.001), but no significant difference was observed in the knee and ankle.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Effective Dose Estimation: The authors acknowledge that effective dose is an estimation, calculated using conversion factors or software, and not an exact measurement. However, they believe the impact on the study's conclusions is likely minimal.
  • Scan Length: The tin-prefiltered scans for the pelvis and knee had a slightly longer scan length, which influences the Dose Length Product (DLP). The authors suggest that further dose reduction might be possible if scan length were identical between groups.
  • Modulation Type: Comparing examinations with the same modulation type was not possible for the knee in their retrospective setup.
  • Exclusion of Implants: Excluding patients with orthopedic implants may have affected the average patient age and BMI, potentially influencing X-ray utilization.
  • Future Work: The study suggests that further dose reduction might be feasible, particularly for bone anatomy depiction, potentially even to radiograph-equivalent doses, while still maintaining diagnostic quality. This could involve further protocol optimization.

Summary updated

Abstract

The implementation of tin-prefiltration in clinical routine scan protocols significantly reduced the effective radiation dose for unenhanced CT scans of the lower extremities between 60 and 70%.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{marth2025implementing,
  author = {Thomas Marth and Georg Wilhelm Kajdi and Christoph Stern and Reto Sutter},
  title = {{Implementing tin-prefiltration in routine clinical CT scans of the lower extremity: impact on radiation dose}},
  booktitle = {Skeletal},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1007/s00256-025-04897-3},
}
Figure