Abstract
This paper proposes that the aims of English teaching should go beyond communicative competence, aligning instead with higher levels of Bloom's taxonomy. It analyzes how Teaching English as a Foreign Language (TEFL) in China can adopt the CSILE/KB (Computer-Supported Intentional Learning Environments / Knowledge Building) program from the University of Toronto. The focus is on goal setting, the active role of thinking scaffolds, and comprehensive English competence. Finally, the paper suggests integrating TEFL with Knowledge Building (KB) and Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs) to advance the field.
Introduction: Moving Beyond Communicative Competence
Despite significant investments in information technology within Chinese classrooms, English language proficiency has not seen a proportional leap. A primary reason is that TEFL pedagogy often remains confined to the lower levels of Bloom’s Taxonomy—knowledge and comprehension—focusing heavily on linguistic drills and narrow "communicative competence."
This focus creates a disconnect: students learn "language for language's sake" rather than using it as a vehicle for inquiry. To address this, the authors propose a shift toward a Knowledge Building (KB) framework, where language acquisition is a natural byproduct of collaborative problem-solving and collective cognitive responsibility.
The Knowledge Building Framework
The core of this proposal is the implementation of the Knowledge Forum (KF), a software platform designed to support collaborative learning. Unlike traditional discussion boards, KF utilizes specific "thinking scaffolds" to guide students toward deeper inquiry.
These scaffolds—such as "My theory," "I need to understand," and "This theory cannot explain"—encourage students to move from "knowledge-telling" (regurgitating facts) to "knowledge-transforming" (actively identifying and solving problems). By focusing on improving ideas, students acquire language naturally as they strive to communicate complex thoughts.
Scaffolding in TEFL
Effective implementation requires a balance between teacher-led guidance and student autonomy. The paper emphasizes "technical scaffolding," where software prompts replace the teacher as the primary guide, allowing students to structure their own learning paths.
By providing assistance through scaffolding activities, educators can help learners bridge the gap between what they can do independently and what they can achieve with support. This model creates a mentally comfortable environment that reduces student anxiety, allowing them to "word alone freely" before sharing and refining their ideas with the community.
Key Insights: Language as a Tool for Inquiry
The transition to a KB model offers several transformative insights for the Chinese TEFL context:
- Language as a Tool, Not a Goal: The best language learning happens when the language is a tool for creating new information.
- Collective Cognitive Responsibility: Students move from individual competition to a shared responsibility for advancing the community's knowledge.
- MOOC Integration: By integrating MOOCs (e.g., Instreamia, LTMOOC), students gain access to "comprehensible input" and global platforms for collaborative knowledge creation.
Conclusion and Future Directions
While Knowledge Building has shown promise in primary and secondary science education in China, its application in higher-education TEFL is still in its early stages. The integration of KB and MOOCs requires a fundamental shift in the teacher's role—from an expert transmitter of knowledge to a facilitator of "idea improvement."
Future work must focus on detailed, course-specific designs and systematic studies to overcome current tool limitations and cultural barriers, ultimately bringing TEFL to a new stage of cognitive and linguistic development.
Summary updated