Abstract
Non-fungible tokens (NFTs) are increasingly utilized as digital assets for marketing and exhibitions. While lending NFTs offers a path to passive income for owners, the market is currently hampered by risks regarding asset return and the high costs of escrow intermediaries. Furthermore, renters often struggle to predict the marketing impact of an NFT before committing to a rental fee. To address these challenges, we introduce a decentralized NFT rental solution based on a "pay-per-like" pricing model. Implemented via Ethereum smart contracts, our solution automates the rental lifecycle and aligns costs with engagement. However, our evaluation reveals a significant "dark side" to blockchain implementation: high transaction fees create a systemic bias against niche artists, potentially threatening cultural diversity. This paper explores the technical implementation, the trust-cost tradeoff, and the economic implications of value-based NFT rentals.
Introduction
As the market for Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs) matures, the focus is shifting from speculative trading to utility. One emerging use case is the rental of digital art for corporate marketing or online storefronts. Traditionally, these rentals follow a time-based "pay-per-use" model. This model is often inefficient: lenders risk losing their assets if they are not returned, and renters bear the financial risk of the artwork failing to resonate with their audience.
To mitigate these issues, this research proposes a value-based pricing model—specifically "pay-per-like"—leveraging the transparency and automation of blockchain technology. By tying rental costs to actual engagement, the financial risk of underperforming art is shifted from the renter to the lender, mirroring the successful "pay-per-click" models found in traditional online advertising.
System Design and Methodology
Following a Design Science Research (DSR) approach, we developed a Decentralized Application (Dapp) to facilitate the rental process. The system architecture is built on the Ethereum blockchain using the following components:
- Smart Contracts: Written in Solidity, the contracts extend the ERC-721 (NFT) and ERC-20 (Token) standards.
- Non-Wrapped Architecture: To avoid the complexity and security risks of "wrapped" tokens, the smart contract acts as a secure vault. The NFT is held by the contract during the rental period, ensuring it cannot be stolen or lost by the renter.
- The Exhibitor Role: To prevent arbitrary manipulation of engagement metrics, the system introduces an authorized "Exhibitor" (the service provider displaying the art). This party is the only entity permitted to trigger the on-chain "like" function.
- Frontend Integration: The Dapp utilizes TypeScript and Angular, with Web3.js providing the bridge to MetaMask and WalletConnect for secure transaction handling.
The Economic "Dark Side" of Blockchain Fees
While the technical implementation successfully automates the rental lifecycle, our analysis uncovered a critical barrier to adoption: the regressive nature of blockchain transaction fees.
In a decentralized environment, every state change (such as incrementing a "like" counter) requires a gas fee. During our evaluation, a single "like" cost approximately $0.45 in gas. This creates a Trust-Cost Tradeoff. While storing more metadata on-chain increases security and reduces the risk of "click fraud," it simultaneously drives up execution costs.
More importantly, these fees create a systemic injustice. If a niche artist intends to charge a low fee (e.g., $0.10 per like) to gain exposure, the gas fees would exceed the rental income, causing the artist to lose money on every engagement. Consequently, the current Ethereum infrastructure favors high-value "blue-chip" NFTs, potentially excluding emerging creators and reducing cultural diversity within the ecosystem.
Evaluation and Results
The solution was deployed and tested on the Goerli test network, with costs benchmarked against real-world price data from October 2022.
- Functional Integrity: The system achieved 100% unit test coverage across 32 scenarios, including lending, renting, liking, and automated asset reclamation.
- Cost Analysis: Deployment of the rental contract cost roughly $28.08. Standard transactions, such as initiating a rental order, ranged between $2.00 and $3.00.
- Security: The smart contract effectively eliminated the need for collateral, as the code guarantees the return of the NFT to the original owner once the rental period expires or the budget is exhausted.
Conclusion and Future Work
Our implementation demonstrates that smart contracts can successfully automate complex, value-based rental agreements without the need for trusted intermediaries. However, the "dark side" of transaction costs remains a significant hurdle for low-value or high-frequency engagement models.
Future iterations of this work will explore Layer 2 scaling solutions (such as Optimism or Arbitrum) or alternative blockchains (like Avalanche) to reduce fees. Additionally, as standards like ERC-4907 (rentable NFTs) mature, integrating these protocols could further standardize the rental process and improve interoperability across the NFT marketplace.
Summary updated