Implementing BDI-like Systems by Direct Execution

IJCAI 1997

TL;DR

This paper bridges the gap between high-level BDI (Belief-Desire-Intention) agent architectures and their practical implementation. It proposes a hybrid approach by extending the Concurrent METATEM language with BDI's core concepts, enabling direct execution of BDI-like agent behaviors while retaining the advantages of executable specifications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developing rational agent architectures is a significant area of research, with the BDI framework being particularly influential. However, a practical challenge arises from the disconnect between the abstract BDI model and its concrete implementation. Traditional programming languages often lack the flexibility to represent an agent's dynamic control over its own behavior, and existing agent-based programming languages can be either too low-level or not expressive enough to fully capture BDI's key elements. This paper aims to address this by providing a high-level logic-based programming language that supports the principled development of multi-agent systems, directly linking theoretical models to implemented systems.

Methods

The paper introduces a hybrid approach that combines the direct execution capabilities of the Concurrent METATEM language with key rationality elements from the BDI framework.

  • Concurrent METATEM: This language provides a framework for representing agent behavior using temporal specifications and supports asynchronous concurrency and broadcast message-passing. Agent behavior is defined by temporal logic formulas, which are transformed into a normal form (SNF) suitable for execution.
  • BDI Elements: The hybrid approach incorporates two main extensions to Concurrent METATEM:
  • Belief Modality: A new modal operator 'B' is added to the temporal logic to represent beliefs, satisfying KD45 axioms. This allows for the representation of an agent's internal information.
  • Priority Functions: User-definable priority functions (pd for desires-to-intentions and pi for intention execution) are introduced to manage deliberation. These functions allow for flexible control over how agents select and act upon their goals, mimicking the decision-making processes in BDI systems.

The core idea is to represent desires and intentions as temporal eventualities, which are then prioritized and selected for execution using these user-defined functions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Theory-Implementation Gap: The paper demonstrates a practical way to connect abstract BDI models with executable agent systems, a long-standing challenge in the field.
  • Desires and Intentions as Eventualities: A key insight is that, in practice, desires and intentions can be treated similarly as temporal eventualities that the agent aims to satisfy. This simplifies their representation.
  • Flexibility through Priority Functions: The introduction of user-definable priority functions for deliberation offers significant flexibility, allowing for the representation of various decision-making strategies without altering the core execution mechanism.
  • Executable Specifications for Rationality: By extending an already executable temporal logic framework, the paper offers a way to prototype and implement rational agent behaviors that are directly verifiable and understandable.

Key Results

The paper presents a conceptual framework and a methodology for implementing BDI-like systems using an extended Concurrent METATEM. While no specific quantitative results are presented, the authors show that:

  • The hybrid approach can capture a range of agent behaviors.
  • It retains many advantages of executable specifications, such as direct execution and verifiability.
  • The core execution mechanism of Concurrent METATEM remains largely unchanged, making the extension relatively inexpensive.
  • The approach allows for the representation of BDI's key elements (beliefs, desires, intentions) and deliberation processes.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • The authors acknowledge that this approach does not claim to implement all BDI systems, particularly those with complex real-time constraints, intricate plan structures, or advanced intention structures.
  • The efficiency of the hybrid approach is dependent on the complexity of the user-defined priority functions.
  • The paper focuses on propositional temporal logic and does not consider first-order temporal specifications.

Future Work:

  • Extended Languages: Exploring how other elements of Concurrent METATEM, such as multithreading and grouping, can be incorporated.
  • Refined Priority Functions: Defining a range of detailed deliberation strategies through more sophisticated priority functions.
  • Expanded Formal Semantics: Adapting the temporal semantics of Concurrent METATEM to fully incorporate the proposed extensions.
  • Investigating how to implement more complex BDI features, such as explicit links between beliefs and intentions, through program rules.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{1997implementing,
  title = {{Implementing BDI-like Systems by Direct Execution}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1997},
}
Figure