TL;DR
This study introduces a "Social Presence-Based Teaching Strategy" (SP-BTS) to enhance online learning by focusing on peer interaction, not just instructor presence. The SP-BTS significantly improved students' perceived social presence, online interaction, and academic performance compared to traditional lecture-based online learning.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Online learning, particularly lecture-based formats, often leads to student isolation and a lack of meaningful interaction. While much research has focused on enhancing instructor presence through video design, the crucial element of peer presence and its impact on learning has been underexplored. This gap can hinder students' engagement, emotional experience, and ultimately, their academic success. The paper aims to address this by developing and testing a strategy that actively fosters social presence, specifically by emphasizing peer-to-peer connections within online lecture environments.
Methods
The researchers developed a Social Presence-Based Teaching Strategy (SP-BTS) grounded in Biocca et al.'s (2003) social presence theory, which encompasses co-presence, psychological involvement, and behavioral engagement. This strategy was implemented through six specific online learning activities designed to foster these dimensions.
A quasi-experimental design was employed with 81 Chinese university students enrolled in a ten-week online course. Participants were randomly assigned to either an experimental group (EG) receiving the SP-BTS intervention or a control group (CG) receiving conventional lecture-based instruction.
Key methods included:
- Pre- and Post-Intervention Surveys: Measuring perceived social presence using a validated scale.
- Academic Performance Assessment: Evaluating students' final design work (PowerPoint slides and micro-lectures) based on grading criteria.
- Social Network Analysis: Analyzing online discussion forum data to map interaction patterns, density, cohesion, and subgroup formation.
- Content Analysis: Coding discussion postings using a social presence coding schema to assess participation in affective, interactive, and cohesive responses.
Datasets
The study utilized data collected from 81 junior undergraduates participating in an online course on "digital learning resource design and development" at a Chinese university. This included:
- Online discussion forum contributions.
- Responses to pre- and post-intervention questionnaires on social presence.
- Final design work (PowerPoint slides and micro-lectures) for academic performance assessment.
- Foreknowledge test results.
No new benchmarks were introduced; the study focused on evaluating the effectiveness of the SP-BTS within an existing online course structure.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Peer Presence is Key: The study strongly suggests that focusing on fostering peer presence and interaction is as vital, if not more so, than solely enhancing instructor presence in online learning.
- SP-BTS is Effective: The developed strategy demonstrably improved students' social presence, online interaction, and academic outcomes. This highlights the potential for structured pedagogical interventions to overcome the isolation often associated with online lectures.
- Beyond Technology: The effectiveness of the SP-BTS suggests that significant improvements in online learning can be achieved through thoughtful instructional design and pedagogical strategies, rather than solely relying on advanced technological tools.
- Interconnectedness of SP Dimensions: The study implies that fostering co-presence, psychological involvement, and behavioral engagement through specific activities leads to a holistic improvement in social presence.
- Social Presence Fuels Academic Success: A significant correlation was found between higher social presence and better academic performance in the experimental group, underscoring the practical impact of social connection on learning.
Key Results
- Social Presence: The experimental group (EG) showed a significantly greater perceived social presence at the posttest compared to the control group (CG).
- Online Interaction:
- During the treatment phase, the EG posted more affective and cohesive responses in discussion forums than the CG.
- Social network analysis revealed a more concentrated network structure for the EG, with increased connections, stronger links, higher density, and greater cohesion, indicating more robust online interaction.
- The EG formed significantly more cohesive subgroups (11 subgroups with 68.4% of students participating) compared to the CG (1 subgroup with 9.3% of students).
- Academic Performance: The EG members achieved significantly better academic performance (mean score of 89.86) than the CG members (mean score of 88.29). There was no significant difference in foreknowledge between the groups.
- Correlation: A significant positive correlation was found between perceived social presence and academic performance for the EG (r = 0.41), but not for the CG.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited Demographics: The study's participants were primarily from social and human science disciplines at a single Chinese university. This limits the generalizability of the findings to broader student populations and different subject areas.
- Interplay of SP Dimensions: The researchers did not further investigate how the individual dimensions of social presence (co-presence, psychological involvement, behavioral engagement) interact with each other to influence participants' social presence and academic performance.
Future research should:
- Examine the SP-BTS across diverse demographic backgrounds, ages, cultural contexts, and disciplines.
- Delve deeper into the specific interactions between the three dimensions of social presence and their combined impact on online learning experiences and outcomes.
Summary updated