TL;DR
This study presents a cost-effectiveness analysis of a digital comprehensive myopia prevention and control strategy for children and adolescents in China. The findings suggest that this digital approach is a cost-effective solution compared to traditional methods, offering a scalable and accessible way to combat the growing public health issue of myopia.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Myopia, or nearsightedness, is a significant global public health concern, particularly among children and adolescents. Its prevalence is rapidly increasing, with projections indicating that half the world's population could be myopic by 2050. High myopia can lead to severe vision impairment and irreversible blindness, imposing substantial economic burdens through healthcare costs and lost productivity. While various interventions for myopia exist, there's a lack of comprehensive, national-level assessments that integrate economics and effectiveness. China, facing a high prevalence of myopia, has been implementing a multi-faceted strategy including school-based screening, health education, and digital management. This paper aims to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of a digital comprehensive myopia prevention and control strategy compared to traditional approaches and simple school-based screening.
Methods
The researchers employed a Markov model to simulate the progression of myopia in a hypothetical cohort of 100,000 schoolchildren aged 6 to 18, both in rural and urban settings in China. The model categorized myopia into four stages: non-myopia, low myopia, moderate myopia, and high myopia, based on spherical equivalent (SE) diopters.
They compared three main strategies:
- School-based myopia screening: Routine vision tests with referrals for further examination and treatment.
- Traditional myopia prevention and control strategy: This includes health education delivered through posters, videos, and brochures, alongside encouraging outdoor activities.
- Digital comprehensive myopia prevention and control strategy: This strategy leverages digital channels like WeChat and SMS for health education, alongside the components of the traditional strategy.
The analysis focused on cost-utility (measured by Quality-Adjusted Life-Years, QALYs) and cost-effectiveness (measured by Disability-Adjusted Life-Years, DALYs averted). Parameters for the model were drawn from published literature, pilot projects, and official data. Extensive sensitivity analyses were conducted to ensure the robustness of the findings.
Datasets
The study utilized data from:
- Published sources, meta-analyses, and pilot projects related to myopia interventions.
- Official data from the National Health Commission of the People's Republic of China.
- Recommendations from the National Expert Advisory Committee on Vision Health Management for Children and Adolescents.
- Reasonable assumptions where direct data was unavailable.
No new datasets were introduced; rather, existing data was synthesized and modeled.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Digital is the way forward: The digital comprehensive strategy emerged as the most cost-effective option, outperforming traditional methods and basic screening. This highlights the potential of technology to scale up public health interventions.
- Holistic approach is crucial: The study emphasizes that integrating screening, prevention, and treatment into a comprehensive strategy is more effective than single interventions.
- Outdoor activity is king (and cheap): Promoting full coverage of outdoor activities was identified as a highly cost-effective measure, even producing the lowest cost in some scenarios. This reinforces existing evidence on the protective effects of sunlight exposure.
- Health education matters, but digital delivery is key: While health education is vital, digital platforms offer a more accessible, sustainable, and potentially impactful way to disseminate information and change behaviors compared to traditional methods.
- Context matters: The cost-effectiveness varied between rural and urban settings, underscoring the need for tailored approaches within a national strategy.
Key Results
- Prevalence Reduction: The digital strategy reduced myopia prevalence by 3.79% in rural and 3.48% in urban areas compared to school-based screening alone. It also showed a decrease in high myopia by 1.81% (rural) and 1.35% (urban).
- Cost-Utility: The incremental cost-utility ratio (ICUR) for the digital strategy was $11,301 per QALY gained in rural settings and $10,707 in urban settings. These figures were below 3 times the per capita GDP in rural areas and less than 1 time the per capita GDP in urban areas, indicating cost-effectiveness.
- Cost-Effectiveness: The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) for the digital strategy was $37,446 (rural) and $41,814 (urban) per DALY averted. While slightly exceeding the cost-effectiveness threshold in base-case analysis, subgroup analyses showed that perfect compliance with outdoor activities and spectacles wearing made the strategy highly cost-effective.
- Optimal Scenario: Full coverage of outdoor activities yielded the lowest cost ($321 rural, $808 urban) and met the cost-effectiveness threshold.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Data on Digital Health Education: A lack of specific data for digital health education led to the use of parameters similar to traditional methods, potentially inflating ICERs.
- Environmental Factors: The model did not fully account for the effects of natural environments (e.g., green spaces, light exposure) on myopia progression.
- Broader Eye Health: The study focused solely on myopia and did not include the costs and benefits of screening for other common eye diseases.
- Advanced Myopia: Complications of pathological myopia were not included in the analysis.
Future work should focus on:
- Developing more comprehensive models that incorporate environmental factors and a wider range of eye conditions.
- Further research into the specific impact and cost-effectiveness of digital health education interventions.
- Exploring strategies to address the "distal drivers" of myopia, such as educational system reforms.
- Evaluating the cost-effectiveness of myopia management across different age groups and life stages.
Summary updated