Impacts of Phase Noise on the Anti-Jamming Performance of Power Inversion Algorithm

Minglei Zhou, Qing Wang, Fangmin He, Jin MengSensors 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the often-overlooked impact of phase noise, introduced during the down-conversion process in wireless communication systems, on the performance of the Power Inversion (PI) anti-jamming algorithm. The authors develop a new mathematical model and derive a closed-form formula for the Interference Cancellation Ratio (ICR), revealing that phase noise significantly degrades anti-jamming performance, a finding validated through simulations and real-world measurements.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Adaptive beamforming techniques, like the Power Inversion (PI) algorithm, are crucial for suppressing interference in wireless communication systems. These algorithms typically operate on base-band signals, which are obtained by down-converting the received radio-frequency (RF) signals. A common implementation uses a common reference clock to synchronize multiple down-conversion circuits. However, imperfections in these circuits, specifically phase noise introduced by the local oscillator (LO) signals, can degrade the performance of the PI algorithm. While other hardware impairments have been studied, the specific impact of phase noise on the PI algorithm's anti-jamming capabilities, particularly in the context of common reference clock architectures, remained largely unaddressed in the existing literature. This gap is critical for practical system design, as it dictates hardware requirements and performance limitations.

Methods

The core of this research lies in developing a new mathematical model for the PI algorithm that explicitly incorporates the phase noise introduced by the down-conversion circuits. The authors first model the received signals, including the effects of phase shifts and phase noise from independent LO signals. They then derive the optimal beamforming weights for the PI algorithm and, crucially, obtain a closed-form formula for the Interference Cancellation Ratio (ICR). This formula quantifies the relationship between the anti-jamming performance (ICR), the level of phase noise (variance), and the number of auxiliary antennas. To validate their theoretical findings, the researchers employed two approaches:

  1. Simulations: They built a simulation model using MATLAB, incorporating phase noise blocks that mimic the behavior of real-world down-conversion circuits. This allowed them to test the PI algorithm's performance under various simulated phase noise conditions and with different numbers of auxiliary antennas.
  2. Measured Data: They utilized measured phase noise data from three different types of down-conversion modules to evaluate the ICR performance. This real-world data was fed into their simulation model to assess the accuracy of their theoretical predictions.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets. Instead, it utilizes:

  • Simulated Phase Noise Data: Generated using a standard phase noise model from the MATLAB Communications toolbox, with parameters adjusted to represent typical phase noise characteristics.
  • Measured Phase Noise Data: Obtained from three different types of down-conversion blocks (Type A, B, and C), measured using a spectrum analyzer.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Phase Noise is a Significant Performance Bottleneck: Contrary to the assumption that phase noise might be a minor issue, this paper demonstrates it has a substantial and predictable negative impact on the PI algorithm's anti-jamming capabilities.
  • Logarithmic Degradation: The ICR (a measure of anti-jamming performance) decreases logarithmically with the phase noise variance. This means a tenfold increase in phase noise variance leads to a 10 dB drop in ICR, highlighting the sensitivity of the system to phase noise.
  • Diminishing Returns with More Antennas: While increasing the number of auxiliary antennas generally improves the ICR, this improvement is upper-bounded. The paper shows that the increment in ICR saturates, offering at most a 3 dB improvement, suggesting that beyond a certain point (around 10 auxiliary antennas), adding more does not significantly enhance performance if phase noise is the limiting factor.
  • Model Underestimation: The derived theoretical model consistently underestimates the ICR by approximately 1 dB compared to simulation results. This is attributed to approximations made during the mathematical derivation, but the consistency across different scenarios makes the model valuable for practical design.

Key Results

  • ICR vs. Phase Noise Variance: The study found that the ICR decreases logarithmically linearly with phase noise variance. For instance, a 10x increase in phase noise variance leads to a ~10 dB decrease in ICR.
  • ICR vs. Number of Auxiliary Antennas: The ICR increases with the number of auxiliary antennas, but this increase is capped at approximately 3 dB. The performance saturates around N=10 auxiliary antennas.
  • Validation: Theoretical predictions were validated against simulation results and measurements from real hardware, showing good agreement, with minor underestimations by the theoretical model.
  • Hardware Comparison: Among the tested down-conversion blocks, Type C (a customized module) offered the best performance due to its lower phase noise, resulting in an improvement of around 3 dB in ICR compared to other types.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Approximations in Model: The theoretical model relies on certain approximations, leading to a slight underestimation of the ICR. The paper notes that for Type B, the underestimation was slightly larger (around 2 dB), potentially due to spurious signals that deviate from the assumed phase noise model.
  • Focus on Specific Architecture: The analysis is primarily focused on systems employing a common reference clock-based down-conversion circuit. While this is a common architecture, other configurations might exhibit different sensitivities to phase noise.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their mathematical model can be used to directly calculate the required phase noise variance for a target ICR. This is valuable for circuit designers who can now precisely validate their designs against specific performance requirements. They also highlight that if phase noise is the bottleneck, increasing the number of auxiliary antennas beyond a certain point offers limited benefits. This implies that efforts to improve anti-jamming performance should also focus on mitigating phase noise in the down-conversion circuitry.

Summary updated

Abstract

Power inversion (PI) is a known adaptive beamforming algorithm that is widely used in wireless communication systems for anti-jamming purposes. The PI algorithm is typically implemented in a digital domain, which requires the radio-frequency signals to be down-converted into base-band signals, and then sampled by ADCs. In practice, the down-conversion circuit will introduce phase noises into the base-band signals, which may degrade the performance of the algorithm. At present, the impacts of phase noise on the PI algorithm have not been studied, according to the open literature, which is, however, important for practical design. Therefore, in this paper, we present a theoretical analysis on the impacts, provide a new mathematical model of the PI algorithm, and offer a closed-form formula of the interference cancellation ratio (ICR) to quantify the relations between the algorithm performance and the phase noise level, as well as the number of auxiliary antennas. We find that the ICR in decibel decreases logarithmically linearly with the phase noise variance. In addition, the ICR improves with an increasing number of auxiliary antennas, but the increment is upper-bounded. The above findings are verified with both simulated and measured phase noise data.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2022impacts,
  author = {Minglei Zhou and Qing Wang and Fangmin He and Jin Meng},
  title = {{Impacts of Phase Noise on the Anti-Jamming Performance of Power Inversion Algorithm}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22062362},
}
Figure