Impacts of Low User and Project Management Risk on IT Project of Public Sector: The Moderating Effect of User Knowledge

Sooin Lee, Sanghyun KimJournal of Digital Convergence 2020 · DOI

Introduction

Public sector IT projects are characterized by rigid budgetary cycles, inflexible deadlines, and a complex web of stakeholders. These constraints often lead to high failure rates or suboptimal performance. While traditional risk management focuses on mitigating technical and organizational hurdles, this research investigates the human element—specifically, how the technical literacy and process knowledge of end-users can amplify the benefits of risk reduction.

Conceptual Framework

The study proposes a model where project performance is driven by the reduction of two primary risk categories: user-related risks (e.g., requirement volatility) and project management risks (e.g., poor planning). Crucially, it introduces User Knowledge—defined as the user's understanding of the system development lifecycle—as a moderator that strengthens these relationships.

Figure 1: Research model illustrating the hypothesized relationships between risk factors, user knowledge, and project performance.

Methodology

The researchers utilized Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) to analyze data from 132 valid survey responses collected in early 2020. The sample included project managers (56.1%) and developers (43.9%) involved in South Korean public sector IT contracts. The model's reliability and validity were confirmed through standard metrics, including Cronbach’s Alpha and Average Variance Extracted (AVE), followed by 500 bootstrap iterations to test the hypotheses.

Results and Analysis

The empirical results strongly support the proposed model, with all four primary hypotheses achieving statistical significance ($p < 0.01$).

Figure 2: Structural model results showing path coefficients and the explanatory power (R²) of the model.

Direct Impacts

Reducing risks has a direct, positive effect on performance. Low user-related risk ($\beta = 0.386$) and low project management risk ($\beta = 0.421$) were both significant predictors of success.

The Moderating Role of User Knowledge

The most critical finding is the significant moderating effect of User Knowledge. High user knowledge was found to enhance the positive impact of reducing user-related risk ($\beta = 0.319$) and project management risk ($\beta = 0.287$). This suggests that when users understand the development process, they are better equipped to provide stable requirements and collaborate effectively, making risk mitigation efforts more successful.

The final model explains 57.2% of the variance in IT project performance ($R^2 = 0.572$), indicating high explanatory power for public sector contexts.

Conclusion

This study highlights that "smart users" are a vital asset for public sector IT success. Beyond simply reducing risks, organizations should invest in educating users about the development process. While the study is limited by its reliance on self-reported data and a specific geographic context (South Korea), it provides a robust framework for understanding how knowledge-based factors can overcome the inherent rigidities of government IT projects.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{lee2020impacts,
  author = {Sooin Lee and Sanghyun Kim},
  title = {{Impacts of Low User and Project Management Risk on IT Project of Public Sector: The Moderating Effect of User Knowledge}},
  journal = {Journal of Digital Convergence},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.14400/jdc.2020.18.6.187},
}
Figure