Impacts of land reclamation projects on hydrodynamics and morphodynamics in the highly altered North Branch of the Changjiang Estuary

Qi Zhang, Daidu Fan, Tao Feng, Junbiao Tu, Xingjie GuoAnthropocene 2022 · DOI

Introduction

Estuaries are highly dynamic environments, sensitive to both natural forcing and human intervention. The North Branch of the Changjiang (Yangtze) Estuary has undergone a profound transformation over the last few decades, shifting from a river-dominated system to one dominated by tides. This shift has been largely driven by extensive land reclamation projects aimed at creating usable land from the sea. This paper examines the "chain reaction" of hydrodynamic and morphodynamic responses to these engineering works between 1997 and 2017.

Study Area and Methodology

The research focuses on the North Branch, a narrow channel separated from the South Branch by Chongming Island. To understand the long-term changes, researchers utilized a dual-track approach:

  1. Digital Elevation Model (DEM) Comparison: Bathymetric data from 1997, 2007, and 2017 were compared to quantify sediment accretion and erosion.
  2. Numerical Simulation: The Finite Volume Community Ocean Model (FVCOM) was employed to simulate water movement. This model's unstructured grid is ideal for the complex geometry of the North Branch.
Map of the study area in the North Branch of the Changjiang Estuary, showing bathymetry and measurement stations.

The model was validated using field data from tide gauges and acoustic doppler velocimeters, ensuring that simulated tidal levels and flow velocities accurately reflected real-world conditions.

Stage 1 (1997–2007): Tidal Amplification and Siltation

The first decade of the study period was characterized by aggressive land reclamation in the upper and middle segments of the North Branch. These projects significantly narrowed the channel; for instance, the cross-sectional area at the "Chong-Tou" profile was reduced by a staggering 86% by 2007.

This narrowing created a "funnel effect," leading to tidal amplification. The average high tide level rose by approximately 0.12 meters. More importantly, it strengthened "flood" tides (inward-moving) relative to "ebb" tides (outward-moving). This flood dominance acted as a pump, bringing offshore sediment into the estuary and causing massive siltation. During this period, the channel volume below the 0m mark was effectively cut in half, dropping from $1434 \times 10^8 m^3$ to $734 \times 10^8 m^3$.

Stage 2 (2007–2017): Reaching a Managed Equilibrium

In the second decade, the nature of engineering projects shifted. Management efforts included narrowing the lower segment and implementing waterway improvement projects, such as dredging in the middle and upper segments.

These later projects helped "relax" the tidal amplification observed in the previous decade. The dominance of flood flows over ebb flows weakened, leading to a more balanced sediment regime. By the 2007–2017 period, contemporary erosion volume was almost balanced by accretion volume, suggesting that the North Branch had reached a new, human-influenced steady state.

The Role of Bed Shear Stress

A key finding of the study is the predictive power of bed shear stress—the frictional force water exerts on the channel floor. The numerical simulations revealed that spatiotemporal variations in erosion and accretion patterns were vividly mirrored by changes in bed shear stress. Areas where simulated shear stress increased underwent severe erosion, while areas with decreased stress saw significant accretion. This confirms that bed shear stress is a primary driver of morphological change in tide-dominated estuaries.

Conclusion and Implications

The 20-year evolution of the North Branch highlights the extreme sensitivity of estuaries to human engineering. While recent management has brought the system into a precarious balance, it remains a "managed equilibrium" that requires constant monitoring.

The study underscores the importance of using advanced simulation tools like FVCOM before implementing large-scale projects. Understanding the feedback loops between channel geometry, tidal dynamics, and sediment transport is crucial for the sustainable management of highly altered estuarine systems, particularly regarding risks like saltwater intrusion and wetland loss.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The estuary is highly dynamic and sensitive to external and internal forcing. We examine a chain reaction of hydrodynamic and morphodynamic responses to a series of land reclamation projects during the period 1997 to 2017 in the North Branch of the Changjiang Estuary through the Digital Elevation Model (DEM) comparison and the numerical simulation by the Finite Volume Community Ocean Model (FVCOM). The results show that tidal amplification was further strengthened by the artificially reduced channel volume in the middle and upper segments of the North Branch due to the implementation of several large-scale land-reclamation projects in the first stage (1997–2007), and the channel siltation in the middle and upper segments was in turn further promoted by the increased tidal flows with flood dominance. In the second stage (2007–2017), tidal amplification was relaxed by the channel narrowing project at the lower segment and the waterway improvement project through channel dredging works at the middle and upper segments. Contemporary erosion volume was almost balanced by the accretion volume in the North Branch because of the weakening dominance of flood over ebb flows. Spatiotemporal variation in channel accretion and erosion patterns in response to estuarine engineering projects was vividly mirrored by the change of simulated bed shear stress in that the areas with increased (decreased) bed shear stress underwent severe erosion (accretion). These findings highlight again the dynamic feature of tide-dominated estuaries and the importance of simulation tools to the estuarine management.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022impacts,
  author = {Qi Zhang and Daidu Fan and Tao Feng and Junbiao Tu and Xingjie Guo},
  title = {{Impacts of land reclamation projects on hydrodynamics and morphodynamics in the highly altered North Branch of the Changjiang Estuary}},
  booktitle = {Anthropocene},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s44218-022-00006-2},
}
Figure