Impacts of Job Demands on Turnover Intention Among Registered Nurses in Hong Kong Public Hospitals: Exploring the Mediating Role of Burnout and Moderating Effect of Pay Level Satisfaction

Ka Po Wong, Bohan Zhang, Yao Jie Xie, Frances Kam Yuet Wong, Claudia K. Y. Lai, Shu‐Cheng Chen, Jing QinJournal of Nursing Management 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates why registered nurses in Hong Kong public hospitals consider leaving their jobs. It found that job demands lead to burnout, which in turn increases turnover intention. Surprisingly, satisfaction with pay level did not mitigate this effect, suggesting that financial compensation alone isn't enough to retain nurses facing high demands and burnout.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The healthcare sector, particularly nursing, globally faces a critical challenge: high turnover rates and burnout among its workforce. This is especially true in Hong Kong's public hospitals, where an aging population and increasing healthcare demands exacerbate these issues. High turnover not only impacts patient care continuity and increases costs but also places immense pressure on remaining staff. While the link between job demands, burnout, and turnover intention is established, this research specifically examines this dynamic within Hong Kong's public hospital nurses, exploring whether pay level satisfaction can act as a buffer against these negative outcomes.

Methods

The study employed a cross-sectional online survey design. Data were collected from 502 registered nurses working in Hong Kong public hospitals. The researchers utilized a robust statistical approach, including:

  • Bivariate Pearson Correlation Analysis: To examine the initial relationships between various study variables.
  • Mediated Moderation Analysis using the PROCESS macro in SPSS 28.0: This is a key analytical technique used to test the mediating role of burnout and the moderating role of pay level satisfaction. It allows researchers to understand how one variable (mediator) explains the relationship between two other variables (independent and dependent), and how a third variable (moderator) influences the strength or direction of that mediated relationship.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Burnout as the Central Mediator: The study strongly confirms that burnout is a significant mediator. It acts as the bridge through which job demands (like work overload, job stress, and conflicts) translate into nurses' intentions to leave their jobs or the profession.
  • The Unexpected Non-Effect of Pay Satisfaction: A major finding is that pay level satisfaction did not moderate the relationship between job demands and turnover intention via burnout. This challenges the common assumption that higher pay satisfaction would buffer the negative impacts of job stress and burnout.
  • Conflict with Colleagues is a Major Driver: Among the job demands, conflict with other nurses emerged as a particularly strong predictor of both organizational and professional turnover intentions.
  • Family-Work Conflict Nuances: Interestingly, family-work conflict showed a negative impact on turnover intention, while work-family conflict did not have a significant association. This might be linked to the specific demographic profile of the nurses in the study (younger, potentially less burdened by immediate family caregiving responsibilities).

Key Results

  • Burnout Mediates All Relationships: Burnout significantly mediated the relationship between all five job demands (work overload, job stress, work-family conflict, family-work conflict, and conflict with nurses) and both organizational and professional turnover intentions.
  • No Moderating Effect of Pay Satisfaction: Despite negative correlations between pay level satisfaction and turnover intention, the statistical analysis (mediated moderation analysis) revealed that pay level satisfaction did not significantly moderate the indirect effect of job demands on turnover intention through burnout. The index of mediated moderation was not significant across the board.
  • Specific Job Demands' Impact: Work overload, job stress, and conflict with other nurses showed significant direct effects on organizational turnover intention. Work overload and conflict with other nurses also significantly impacted professional turnover intention.
  • Quantitative Impact: For instance, the study found that for every unit increase in work overload, burnout increased by 0.590 (SE=0.425), and this pathway ultimately contributed to turnover intention.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cross-Sectional Design: This design limits the ability to establish definitive causal relationships. Future research should employ longitudinal designs to better understand temporal dynamics.
  • Generalizability: The study focused on public hospital nurses in Hong Kong. Findings may not directly apply to private hospitals or healthcare systems in other countries. Future studies should include diverse settings and populations.
  • Omitted Variables: Variables such as organizational culture, social support, and job autonomy were not included but could influence the examined relationships. Future research should incorporate these factors for a more comprehensive understanding.

The authors suggest future research should:

  • Utilize qualitative methods (interviews, focus groups) to gain deeper insights into nurses' experiences.
  • Explore a wider range of variables to identify additional factors influencing burnout and turnover.
  • Conduct international comparative studies to enhance generalizability.
  • Investigate the specific reasons for the lack of moderation by pay level satisfaction, potentially exploring perceived fairness of pay systems, nonfinancial factors, and cultural norms.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> High turnover rates and burnout are prevalent issues among registered nurses in public hospitals in Hong Kong. Pay level satisfaction is one of the crucial factors influencing organisational and professional turnover intention. Understanding whether pay level satisfaction can mitigate the negative impact of burnout on turnover intention can provide insights into the role of financial rewards in employee retention. <b>Objective:</b> This study aims to evaluate the relationship between job demands and turnover intention among registered nurses in Hong Kong public hospitals. Additionally, it seeks to examine the mediating role of burnout and explore the potential moderating effect of pay level satisfaction on the relationship between burnout and turnover intention. <b>Methods:</b> The study was a cross-sectional online survey of public hospital staff in Hong Kong. A total of 502 registered nurses who had worked at their employing facility for at least 6 months participated in this cross-sectional survey. Study variables included work overload, job stress, work-family conflict, family-work conflict, conflict with other nurses, burnout, pay level satisfaction and turnover intention. The collected data were analysed using bivariate Pearson correlation analysis and mediated moderation analysis with the PROCESS macro in SPSS 28.0. <b>Results:</b> Burnout mediated the relationship between job demands, including work overload, job stress, work-family conflict, family-work conflict and conflicts with nurses, and organisational and professional turnover intention. Pay level satisfaction did not exert a moderating influence on the relationship between job demands and turnover intention through burnout mediating this relationship. <b>Conclusions:</b> The importance of addressing job stress and burnout to mitigate turnover intention and promote nurse retention is underscored. Contrary to expectations, pay level satisfaction did not buffer the negative impact of job demands on turnover intentions via burnout. This suggests that compensation alone may not be sufficient to offset the detrimental effects of high job demands and burnout on nurses' intention to leave their jobs or the profession. Further research is warranted to explore potential moderators that may influence the relationship between job demands and turnover intention.
BibTeX
@article{wong2024impacts,
  author = {Ka Po Wong and Bohan Zhang and Yao Jie Xie and Frances Kam Yuet Wong and Claudia K. Y. Lai and Shu‐Cheng Chen and Jing Qin},
  title = {{Impacts of Job Demands on Turnover Intention Among Registered Nurses in Hong Kong Public Hospitals: Exploring the Mediating Role of Burnout and Moderating Effect of Pay Level Satisfaction}},
  journal = {Journal of Nursing Management},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1155/2024/3534750},
}
Figure