TL;DR
This paper investigates how fairness concerns and non-linear production costs influence investment decisions in blockchain for shipping supply chains. Using a game theory model, it reveals that while fairness can benefit freight forwarders, it often reduces the shipping company's profits, highlighting a complex trade-off for optimizing supply chain operations.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The shipping industry, a cornerstone of global commerce, is increasingly adopting blockchain technology to enhance transparency, traceability, and efficiency. However, the decision to invest in such platforms isn't purely rational. This paper addresses the critical gap in understanding how two key factors—non-linear production costs (economies or diseconomies of scale) and "fairness concern" (a desire for equitable profit distribution)—influence the strategic investment and operational decisions of supply chain participants, specifically a shipping company and a freight forwarder. Traditional models often assume perfect rationality, neglecting these crucial behavioral and cost structure elements that can significantly impact decision-making and overall supply chain performance.
Methods
The authors employ a Stackelberg game model to represent the two-echelon supply chain, where the shipping company acts as the leader and the freight forwarder as the follower. This model is adapted to incorporate:
- Non-linear production costs for the shipping company, modeled as either economies of scale (decreasing marginal cost) or diseconomies of scale (increasing marginal cost).
- Fairness concern for the freight forwarder, modeled using a utility function that considers not only her own profit but also the profit of the shipping company. This captures the idea that a freight forwarder might forgo some profit to achieve a fairer outcome.
- Blockchain investment by the freight forwarder, which incurs a quadratic cost, reflecting diminishing returns on investment.
Four distinct scenarios are analyzed by combining the presence or absence of economies/diseconomies of scale and fairness concern. The study then uses mathematical derivations and numerical simulations to analyze the equilibrium outcomes, including profits, total freight, ocean freight, and blockchain platform value.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on a theoretical model and numerical simulations rather than empirical data from specific datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Fairness as a Double-Edged Sword: While fairness concern generally benefits the freight forwarder by increasing her profit share and utility, it consistently leads to a decrease in the shipping company's profit, regardless of scale economies or diseconomies.
- Economies of Scale are Generally Beneficial: The presence of economies of scale positively impacts the profits and utility of all supply chain members, including the shipping company and the freight forwarder, irrespective of fairness considerations.
- Non-Linearity Matters: The interplay between non-linear production costs and fairness concern significantly alters decision-making. For instance, diseconomies of scale can exacerbate the negative impact of fairness concern on the shipping company's profit.
- Fairness and Profit Aren't Always Aligned: A freight forwarder's profit and utility don't always increase proportionally with their degree of fairness concern. This is particularly true when economies of scale are present or when blockchain investment costs are high.
- Blockchain Investment Costs Influence Strategy: The cost of building and maintaining a blockchain platform plays a crucial role. When costs are high, freight forwarders might adjust total freight strategies to compensate, and the shipping company's ocean freight decisions are also affected.
Key Results
- Freight Forwarder's Profit: Generally higher under fairness concern compared to fairness neutrality, especially when economies of scale are present.
- Shipping Company's Profit: Consistently lower when the freight forwarder exhibits fairness concern, regardless of economies or diseconomies of scale.
- Total Freight: Influenced by the interaction of scale economies/diseconomies and fairness concern, with varying impacts depending on production scales and blockchain costs.
- Blockchain Platform Value: Tends to decrease when fairness concern is present, suggesting that fairness considerations might reduce the incentive for freight forwarders to invest in or fully leverage the platform's potential.
Limitations and Future Work
- Simplified Model: The study considers a two-echelon supply chain with only one shipping company and one freight forwarder. Real-world scenarios often involve multiple players.
- Unilateral Fairness Concern: Only the freight forwarder's fairness concern is modeled. Future research could explore situations where the shipping company or both parties consider fairness.
- Limited Social Preferences: Fairness concern is one of many social preferences. Future work could incorporate other factors like altruism or reciprocal preferences.
- Linear Demand Assumption: The model assumes linear market demand. Non-linear demand models could offer a more realistic representation of market dynamics.
- Additional Economic Factors: Future research could integrate other economic factors like inflation or explore more complex cost structures.
Summary updated