Impacts from Land Use Pattern on Spatial Distribution of Cultivated Soil Heavy Metal Pollution in Typical Rural-Urban Fringe of Northeast China

Wenbo Li, Dongyan Wang, Qing Wang, Shuhan Liu, Yuanli Zhu, Wenjun WuInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how land use patterns in the rural-urban fringe of Northeast China influence the spatial distribution of heavy metal pollution in cultivated soils. Using spatial lag regression, the research identifies long-standing residential areas and surface water bodies as significant contributors to heavy metal accumulation, highlighting the threat of urban sprawl to food security in black soil regions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rapid urbanization in Northeast China is leading to significant land-use changes, particularly the conversion of valuable black soil farmlands. This not only impacts agricultural land availability but also poses a serious threat to soil quality and food security. While previous studies have examined heavy metal pollution sources, there's a need for a more nuanced understanding of how the spatial arrangement of different land uses in peri-urban areas specifically drives the distribution of heavy metal contamination in cultivated soils. This paper aims to fill this gap by exploring the spatial relationships between land use patterns and heavy metal pollution in the black soil region, providing insights for better land management and soil protection policies.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Soil Sampling and Chemical Analysis: 137 topsoil samples (0-20 cm) were collected from cultivated lands in the Kuancheng District of Changchun City. Concentrations of eight heavy metals (As, Hg, Cd, Pb, Cr, Ni, Cu, and Zn) were analyzed using various techniques, including X-ray fluorescence (XRF), inductively-coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS), and atomic fluorescence spectrometry (AFS).
  • Pollution Load Index (PLI) Calculation: A PLI was calculated for each sample to represent the combined heavy metal pollution status, using background values specific to the soil type to account for natural variations.
  • Spatial Interpolation: Ordinary Kriging interpolation was used to map the spatial distribution of individual heavy metal concentrations and the overall PLI.
  • Land Use Classification: High-resolution remote sensing imagery was used to classify land use types into seven categories. Notably, industrial and residential lands were further divided into "developed before 2009" and "developed after 2009" to capture the temporal aspect of urban expansion.
  • Spatial Regression Analysis: To quantify the relationship between land use patterns and heavy metal pollution, a spatial lag regression model was applied. This model is preferred over ordinary least squares (OLS) regression because it accounts for spatial autocorrelation, meaning that values in nearby locations are more similar than those farther apart. The study compared OLS with spatial lag and spatial error models to determine the best fit.

Datasets

  • Soil Samples: 137 cultivated soil samples collected from the Kuancheng District, Changchun City, Northeast China.
  • Heavy Metal Concentration Data: Measured concentrations of As, Hg, Cd, Pb, Cr, Ni, Cu, and Zn in the collected soil samples.
  • Land Use Data: Classified land use maps derived from high-resolution remote sensing imagery (IKONOS) for 2014, supplemented by field surveys.
  • Background Values of Soil Elements: Provided by the "Study on Background Values of Soil Elements in Jilin Province" for different soil types.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spatial Hotspots Identified: The Yitong River catchment and the Lanjia County residential community emerged as significant hotspots for heavy metal pollution, indicating localized sources of contamination.
  • Ecological Land as a Buffer: Beihu Wetland Park, characterized by extensive ecological land, showed low heavy metal concentrations, suggesting the protective role of green spaces.
  • Land Use Drives Spatial Patterns: The distribution of heavy metals is directly linked to the types of surrounding land use and industrial activities, reinforcing the importance of considering land use planning.
  • Temporal Aspect of Urbanization Matters: Differentiating between older and newer residential/industrial developments revealed that long-standing residential areas pose a greater immediate threat, likely due to longer accumulation periods of pollutants.
  • Spatial Lag Model Superiority: The spatial lag regression model provided a better fit for explaining PLI than traditional OLS, underscoring the necessity of accounting for spatial dependencies in such analyses.

Key Results

  • Similar Distribution Patterns: Pb, Cu, and Zn showed similar spatial distribution patterns, as did Cr and Ni, and Hg and Cd.
  • Significant Influencing Factors: Spatial lag regression identified distance from long-standing residential land (RL_DB09) and distance from surface water (SW_D) as significant negative predictors of heavy metal pollution (PLI). This means that as you get closer to these features, heavy metal pollution tends to increase.
  • Inverse Relationship: The regression coefficients indicate an inverse relationship between heavy metal pollution and the distance to these influencing factors.
  • Spatial Lag Model Performance: The spatial lag model achieved a higher R² and log-likelihood compared to OLS, demonstrating its effectiveness in capturing the spatial relationships.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Cultivated Land: The study specifically focused on cultivated land, and its findings may not directly translate to other land use types.
  • Single Study Area: The research was conducted in a specific peri-urban area of Northeast China. Further studies in different geographical and socio-economic contexts would be beneficial for broader generalization.
  • Future Work Suggestions: The authors suggest that future research could explore the specific mechanisms of heavy metal input from different land uses and investigate remediation strategies. The study also implies that continued urban land expansion and longer accumulation periods will exacerbate heavy metal pollution in suburban black soil regions, particularly in areas irrigated by urban river water. This points to the need for proactive land management and pollution control measures.

Summary updated

Abstract

Under rapid urban sprawl in Northeast China, land conversions are not only encroaching on the quantity of cultivated lands, but also posing a great threat to black soil conservation and food security. This study's aim is to explore the spatial relationship between comprehensive cultivated soil heavy metal pollution and peri-urban land use patterns in the black soil region. We applied spatial lag regression to analyze the relationship between PLI (pollution load index) and influencing factors of land use by taking suburban cultivated land of Changchun Kuancheng District as an empirical case. The results indicate the following: (1) Similar spatial distribution characteristics are detected between Pb, Cu, and Zn, between Cr and Ni, and between Hg and Cd. The Yitong River catchment in the central region, and the residential community of Lanjia County in the west, are the main hotspots for eight heavy metals and PLI. Beihu Wetland Park, with a larger-area distribution of ecological land in the southeast, has low level for both heavy metal concentrations and PLI values. Spatial distribution characteristics of cultivated heavy metals are related to types of surrounding land use and industry; (2) Spatial lag regression has a better fit for PLI than the ordinary least squares regression. The regression results indicate the inverse relationship between heavy metal pollution degree and distance from long-standing residential land and surface water. Following rapid urban land expansion and a longer accumulation period, residential land sprawl is going to threaten cultivated land with heavy metal pollution in the suburban black soil region, and cultivated land irrigated with urban river water in the suburbs will have a higher tendency for heavy metal pollution.
BibTeX
@article{li2017impacts,
  author = {Wenbo Li and Dongyan Wang and Qing Wang and Shuhan Liu and Yuanli Zhu and Wenjun Wu},
  title = {{Impacts from Land Use Pattern on Spatial Distribution of Cultivated Soil Heavy Metal Pollution in Typical Rural-Urban Fringe of Northeast China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph14030336},
}
Figure