IMPACT OF WEEKNIGHT AND WEEKEND CURFEWS USING MOBILITY DATA: A CASE STUDY OF BENGALURU URBAN

Aniruddha Adiga, Siva Athreya, Madhav Marathe, Jagadish Midthala, Nihesh Rathod, Rajesh Sundaresan, Srinivasan Venkataramanan, Sarath YasodharanmedRxiv 2022 · DOI

Abstract

In response to the Omicron variant of SARS-CoV-2, Karnataka implemented weeknight and weekend curfews to mitigate viral spread. This study assesses the impact of these restrictions using Google community mobility reports and a simulation-based SEIR model. Findings suggest that while curfews slightly delay and slow the spread, they do not significantly reduce the total population affected. Furthermore, healthcare capacity in Bengaluru Urban may be sufficient if hospitalization rates remain low (2%), but could be overwhelmed if rates mirror more severe scenarios (6.9%), regardless of mobility restrictions.

Introduction

During the 2022 Omicron surge, "intermittent curfews"—restricting movement at night and on weekends while maintaining weekday activity—became a common policy tool to balance public health with economic stability. This paper evaluates the effectiveness of this strategy in Bengaluru Urban, focusing on whether these granular restrictions actually reduced mobility and how they influenced the epidemic's trajectory.

Mobility Analysis

To quantify the impact of the curfews, researchers analyzed Google Community Mobility Reports against a December 2021 baseline. The data revealed a distinct pattern: while weekend mobility in sectors like Retail & Recreation and Transit dropped significantly (to as low as 55% of baseline on Saturdays), weekday activity remained robust, often hovering near 90-100% of baseline levels.

Mobility levels in January 2022 across different categories and days of the week.

This intermittent reduction resulted in an average weekly mobility factor of approximately 80-90%. The high level of weekday activity suggests a "catch-up" effect where social and economic interactions were merely shifted rather than eliminated.

Epidemiological Modeling

The study employed a mean-field SEIR model adapted for Omicron's higher transmissibility. Given the uncertainty regarding prior immunity, the team simulated three susceptibility scenarios: 30%, 60%, and 100% of the population.

Projected daily cases for Bengaluru-Urban across different susceptibility scenarios.

As illustrated in the projections, the susceptibility of the population drastically alters the height and timing of the peak. Initial case data from early January 2022 appeared to track most closely with the 30% susceptibility model.

Key Findings

The "Catch-up" Phenomenon

A critical insight from the simulations is that mobility restrictions primarily "flattened" the curve rather than reducing the total area under it. By the end of March 2022, the cumulative caseload in an "80% mobility" scenario was nearly identical to a "no restriction" scenario. The virus eventually reached the same percentage of the population; the curfews merely delayed the peak by 3 to 5 days.

Healthcare Capacity Paradox

The study highlights a stark divide in healthcare outcomes based on variant severity:

  • Mild Scenario (2% Hospitalization): Peak bed requirements (~7,328) remain just within Bengaluru's capacity (~7,917 beds), even without restrictions.
  • Severe Scenario (6.9% Hospitalization): Peak requirements exceed 50,000 beds, far surpassing available resources. In this case, the 10-20% reduction in peak cases provided by curfews is insufficient to prevent the healthcare system from being overwhelmed.

Conclusion

Intermittent curfews in Bengaluru Urban served to slow the initial surge but had a negligible impact on the total number of infections by the wave's end. The effectiveness of such measures in protecting healthcare infrastructure is highly dependent on the intrinsic severity of the variant. For highly transmissible variants like Omicron, more substantial or sustained mobility reductions would be required to significantly alter the total epidemic burden.

Summary updated

Abstract

Summary Karnataka imposed weeknight and weekend curfews to mitigate the spread of the Omicron variant of SARS-CoV-2. We attempt to assess the impact of curfew using community mobility reports published by Google. Then, we quantify the impact of such restrictions via a simulation study. The pattern of weeknight and weekend curfew, followed by relaxations during the weekdays, seems, at best, to slow and delay the Omicron spread. The simulation outcomes suggest that Omicron eventually spreads and affects nearly as much of the population as it would have without the restrictions. Further, if Karnataka cases trajectory follows the South African Omicron wave trend and the hospitalisation is similar to that observed in well-vaccinated countries (2% of the confirmed cases), then the healthcare requirement is likely within the capacity of Bengaluru Urban when the caseload peaks, with or without the mobility restrictions. On the other hand, if Karnataka cases trajectory follows both the South African Omicron wave trend and the hospitalisation requirement observed there (6.9%), then the healthcare capacity may be exceeded at peak, with or without the mobility restrictions.
BibTeX
@misc{adiga2022impact,
  author = {Aniruddha Adiga and Siva Athreya and Madhav Marathe and Jagadish Midthala and Nihesh Rathod and Rajesh Sundaresan and Srinivasan Venkataramanan and Sarath Yasodharan},
  title = {{IMPACT OF WEEKNIGHT AND WEEKEND CURFEWS USING MOBILITY DATA: A CASE STUDY OF BENGALURU URBAN}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.01.26.22269903},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure