Impact of Traditional Chinese Medicine Constitution on Breast Cancer Incidence: A Case-Control and Cross-Sectional Study

Youzhi Sun, Qianjun Chen, Pei Liu, Yi Zhao, Yanhua He, Xiao Jing Zheng, Wei Mao, Lei Jia, Kumar Ganesan, Feizhi Mo, Jianping ChenInterdisciplinary 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the link between Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) constitutions and breast cancer (BC) incidence in Hong Kong. It found that specific "imbalanced" TCM constitutions, particularly "qi-depressed," are significant risk factors for BC, especially when combined with other constitutional types like "wetness-heat" or "blood-stasis." This suggests TCM constitutional analysis could offer a novel approach to identifying individuals at higher risk for BC.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Breast cancer (BC) remains a leading cause of cancer-related death worldwide, and despite advances in Western medicine, a significant percentage of patients experience recurrence or metastasis. Identifying risk factors and preventative strategies is crucial, but many known factors (like age and family history) are unmodifiable, and others (like diet and smoking) have controversial links or unclear mechanisms. Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) offers a different framework for understanding health and disease through the concept of "TCM Constitution" (TCMC), which describes an individual's inherent physical and psychological characteristics. Imbalances in these constitutions are believed to predispose individuals to illness. This paper aims to explore whether specific imbalanced TCMC types are associated with an increased incidence of BC, thereby potentially uncovering new avenues for risk assessment and prevention.

Methods

The researchers employed a cross-sectional, retrospective, case-control study design. They recruited 305 breast cancer patients and 305 healthy women in Hong Kong. Data was collected through face-to-face consultations using questionnaires that gathered sociodemographic information, known BC risk factors, and assessed TCM constitutions using a modified TCM Physical Constitution Scale. This scale, validated by previous research, comprises 60 items scored on a five-point scale, measuring nine subscales representing different TCMC types (e.g., blood-stasis, qi-deficiency, qi-depressed, wetness-heat). Statistical analysis involved descriptive methods, chi-square tests, and independent t-tests to identify associations between TCMC types, risk factors, and BC. Stepwise logistic regression was used to determine the independent risk factors and the combined effects of different TCMC types.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 305 breast cancer patients and 305 healthy women residing in Hong Kong. The data included sociodemographic information, known BC risk factors, and assessments of TCM constitutions. No new benchmarks were introduced; the study focused on analyzing existing data within the context of TCMC.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • TCM Constitutions as a Novel Risk Factor: The study strongly suggests that imbalanced TCM constitutions are not just descriptive but can be active contributors to BC risk, offering a new perspective beyond conventional risk factors.
  • The Prominence of "Qi-Depressed": The "qi-depressed" constitution emerged as a significant independent risk factor for BC, highlighting the potential role of emotional and energetic imbalances in cancer development from a TCM perspective.
  • Synergistic Effects of Constitutions: The research revealed that combinations of imbalanced TCM constitutions can amplify BC risk. Specifically, "qi-depressed" combined with "wetness-heat" or "blood-stasis" showed a notably higher association with BC than individual types alone.
  • TCM as a Predictive Tool: The findings propose that TCM constitutional analysis could be a valuable tool for identifying populations vulnerable to BC, potentially enabling earlier interventions.

Key Results

  • Compared to healthy individuals, breast cancer patients exhibited a significantly higher percentage of imbalanced TCM constitutions, including qi-depressed, Yin-deficiency, blood stasis, qi-deficiency, and wetness-heat (P < 0.05).
  • The "qi-depressed" constitution was found to be an independent risk factor for BC, with an odds ratio (OR) of 3.21 (95% CI = 1.49-6.92).
  • When combined with "wetness-heat," the "qi-depressed" constitution showed a significantly increased risk (OR = 4.82, 95% CI = 1.83-12.71).
  • The combination of "qi-depressed" and "blood-stasis" also increased BC risk (OR = 3.27, 95% CI = 1.31-8.16).
  • The combination of "wetness-heat" and "blood-stasis" was also associated with BC (OR = 2.88, 95% CI = 1.02-8.17).
  • While "blood-stasis" and "wetness-heat" alone did not significantly increase BC risk, their combination with "qi-depressed" amplified the threat.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Potential for Bias in TCMC Assessment: The study relied on participants recalling their symptoms from the previous year, which could introduce recollection bias, especially for BC patients who may have undergone treatment and experienced side effects.
  • Broad Inclusion Criteria: The admission criteria were considered not very challenging or sensible, potentially leading to confounding results.
  • Small Sample Size and Stage Distribution: The study population size was relatively small, and there was a lack of substantial changes in TCMC distribution across different disease stages.
  • Limited Impact of Common Risk Factors: Common risk factors like family history and reproductive status did not show significant impact in this study, possibly due to the limitations mentioned above.

For future work, the researchers suggest using more logical inclusion criteria and a larger sample size to mitigate bias. They also propose further investigation into the synergistic effects of various TCMC types and their role in other severe conditions like hypertension and other cancers, aiming to develop more effective prevention and treatment strategies within TCM.

Summary updated

Abstract

The term “Constitution of Traditional Chinese Medicine” refers to the physical and psychological characteristics of the body remaining constant. Unbalanced TCMCs make people more susceptible to illness. To evaluate the effectiveness of TCMCs, this study examined how Chinese healthy women and breast cancer patients were disseminated in Hong Kong. To analyze the physical constitution scale in TCM and identify the TCMC categories, 305 healthy women and 305 BC women were recruited for the study. Que
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2021impact,
  author = {Youzhi Sun and Qianjun Chen and Pei Liu and Yi Zhao and Yanhua He and Xiao Jing Zheng and Wei Mao and Lei Jia and Kumar Ganesan and Feizhi Mo and Jianping Chen},
  title = {{Impact of Traditional Chinese Medicine Constitution on Breast Cancer Incidence: A Case-Control and Cross-Sectional Study}},
  booktitle = {Interdisciplinary},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.51847/su6xyb9pqn},
}
Figure