Impact of the Tier system on SARS-CoV-2 transmission in the UK between the first and second national lockdowns

Daniel J. Laydon, Swapnil Mishra, Wes Hinsley, Pantelis Samartsidis, Seth Flaxman, Axel Gandy, Neil M. Ferguson, Samir BhattmedRxiv 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Objective: To measure the effects of the regional Tier system on the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK between the first and second national lockdowns, prior to the emergence of the B.1.1.7 variant.

Design: A modelling study combining estimates of the real-time reproduction number $R_t$ (derived from UK case, death, and serological data) with publicly available data on regional non-pharmaceutical interventions. We utilized a Bayesian hierarchical model with latent factors to account for national trends alongside subnational Tier effects.

Results: Nationally, transmission increased between July and late September. Immediately prior to the Tier system, $R_t$ averaged 1.3, declining to 1.1 two weeks later. Tier 1 had negligible effects, while Tiers 2 and 3 reduced transmission by 6% and 23%, respectively. If every LTLA had entered Tier 3, 93% would have suppressed their epidemics, compared to 29% in reality.

Conclusions: Interventions at least as stringent as Tier 3 are required to suppress transmission, particularly in the face of more transmissible variants.

Introduction

Following the first national lockdown in 2020, the UK government transitioned to a localized "Tier" system in October 2020. This strategy aimed to apply restrictions to Lower Tier Local Authorities (LTLAs) based on local transmission intensity. Evaluating these policies is complex because transmission rates are influenced by broad "secular trends"—national behavioral shifts and mandates like the "rule of six"—that occur independently of local Tiers. This study aims to disentangle these national trends from the specific impacts of Tiers 1, 2, and 3.

Methodology

The researchers employed a two-stage Bayesian hierarchical model to analyze data from 310 LTLAs between July 1st and November 5th, 2020. First, $R_t$ was estimated by back-calculating from observed deaths, cases, and antibody surveys to account for infection-to-outcome lags. Second, a latent factor regression was applied to these $R_t$ values.

The Bayesian hierarchical model equations used for latent factor regression to isolate Tier effects.

As shown in the model specification above, latent factors were used to represent shared national changes in transmission. By factorizing the secular trend into basis functions, the model could "soak up" broad national noise, leaving a cleaner signal to measure the specific multiplicative effect of the Tiers.

Key Results

The model revealed that transmission began to plateau in late September, before the Tier system was officially introduced. This highlights the importance of accounting for secular trends to avoid overestimating policy effectiveness. The specific impacts of the Tiers were found to be:

  • Tier 1: Showed a negligible effect (Coefficient = 1.0), likely because its core components were already practiced nationally.
  • Tier 2: Provided a modest ~6% reduction in $R_t$ (Coefficient = 0.94).
  • Tier 3: Provided a substantial ~23% reduction in $R_t$ (Coefficient = 0.77).

A counterfactual analysis indicated a significant gap in suppression: while only 29% of LTLAs achieved $R_t < 1$ under the mixed-tier approach, an estimated 93% would have seen their epidemics shrinking if Tier 3 had been applied universally.

Discussion and Limitations

The relatively small effect sizes for Tiers 1 and 2 suggest they were insufficient to suppress transmission. Only Tier 3 demonstrated the "punch" necessary to bring $R_t$ below 1.0. These results are associative; because interventions were bundled into Tiers, the model cannot isolate the impact of specific rules, such as closing hospitality versus banning indoor mixing.

Furthermore, this study concluded just before the Alpha (B.1.1.7) variant became dominant. Given that newer variants are more transmissible, the interventions evaluated here would likely be even less effective today. The findings underscore that high-intensity interventions are essential for epidemic control until widespread population immunity is achieved.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Objective Measure the effects of the Tier system on the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK between the first and second national lockdowns, before the emergence of the B.1.1.7 variant of concern. Design Modelling study combining estimates of the real-time reproduction number R t (derived from UK case, death and serological survey data) with publicly available data on regional non-pharmaceutical interventions. We fit a Bayesian hierarchical model with latent factors using these quantities, to account for broader national trends in addition to subnational effects from Tiers. Setting The UK at Lower Tier Local Authority (LTLA) level. Primary and secondary outcome measures Reduction in real-time reproduction number R t . Results Nationally, transmission increased between July and late September, regional differences notwithstanding. Immediately prior to the introduction of the tier system, R t averaged 1.3 (0.9 – 1.6) across LTLAs, but declined to an average of 1.1 (0.86 – 1.42) two weeks later. Decline in transmission was not solely attributable to Tiers. Tier 1 had negligible effects. Tiers 2 and 3 respectively reduced transmission by 6% (5%-7%) and 23% (21%-25%). 93% of LTLAs would have begun to suppress their epidemics if every LTLA had gone into Tier 3 by the second national lockdown, whereas only 29% did so in reality. Conclusions The relatively small effect sizes found in this analysis demonstrate that interventions at least as stringent as Tier 3 are required to suppress transmission, especially considering more transmissible variants, at least until effective vaccination is widespread or much greater population immunity has amassed. Strengths and limitations of this study First study to measure effects of UK Tier system for SARS-CoV-2 control at national and regional level. Model makes minimal assumptions and is primarily data driven. Insufficient statistical power to estimate effects of individual interventions that comprise Tiers, or their interaction. Estimates show that Tiers 1 and 2 are insufficient to suppress transmission, at least until widespread population immunity has amassed. Emergence of more transmissible variants of concern unfortunately supports this conclusion.
BibTeX
@misc{laydon2021impact,
  author = {Daniel J. Laydon and Swapnil Mishra and Wes Hinsley and Pantelis Samartsidis and Seth Flaxman and Axel Gandy and Neil M. Ferguson and Samir Bhatt},
  title = {{Impact of the Tier system on SARS-CoV-2 transmission in the UK between the first and second national lockdowns}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.02.23.21252277},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure