Impact of the digital trade on lowering carbon emissions in 46 countries

Xiuxiang Li, Yan Hu, Liang Ding, Qiyu Huang, Yi JiangScientific 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Digital trade, as one of the vanguards of the global technological revolution and industrial transformation, empowers low-carbon economic cooperation on a global scale. This study, based on panel data from 2007 to 2021 of 46 countries with varied development levels, constructed a multi-dimensional indicator system from six aspects: trade potential, digital infrastructure, digital innovation, digital skills and security, scale of digital trade, and digital trade environment. The research aims to measure the development level of digital trade and explore its impact on carbon emissions, followed by a heterogeneity analysis. The results indicate significant differences in digital trade development among countries based on economic strength. While digital trade generally exhibits a pronounced low-carbon effect, this impact follows a non-linear trajectory that varies significantly between developed and developing regions.

Introduction

As global trade volumes approach $32 trillion, the environmental footprint of international commerce has come under intense scrutiny. Traditional trade is often associated with high carbon costs due to bunker fuel consumption and paper-intensive administrative processes. Digital trade—defined as the electronic ordering or delivery of goods and services—offers a potential "green" alternative through increased efficiency and automation. However, the environmental impact of this transition is complex, involving trade-offs between logistical optimization and the energy demands of digital infrastructure. This paper investigates whether digital trade truly facilitates a low-carbon economy across 46 diverse nations.

Methodology and Measurement Framework

To quantify digital trade development, the study moves beyond simple proxies to a comprehensive multi-dimensional indicator system. This framework evaluates 27 specific indicators across six primary pillars: Trade Potential, Digital Infrastructure, Digital Innovation, Digital Skills and Security, Digital Trade Scale, and the Digital Trade Environment.

Table 1: The multi-dimensional indicator system used to measure digital trade development levels across four hierarchical layers.

The study employs a hybrid weighting approach. The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) provides a structured, expert-based hierarchy, while the Entropy Method introduces objective, data-driven weights to minimize human bias. This dual approach ensures that the resulting Digital Trade Development Index is both theoretically sound and empirically grounded.

Data and Indicator Analysis

The research utilizes a panel dataset spanning 2007 to 2021, covering 46 countries that represent over 86% of global GDP. Data is aggregated from major international repositories, including the World Bank (WDI), UNCTAD, ITU, WIPO, and the UNESCO Institute for Statistics (UIS), alongside carbon emission metrics from the IEA.

A critical component of the analysis is the determination of indicator weights. The weighting results highlight the disproportionate importance of human capital and physical foundations in the digital economy.

Table 2: Weights assigned to first, second, and third-level indicators, highlighting the significance of Digital Skills and Security.

According to the analysis, Digital Skills and Security (33.1%) and Digital Infrastructure (22.7%) are the most critical factors in determining a country's digital trade maturity. This suggests that technical proficiency and robust network facilities are the primary prerequisites for a country to leverage digital trade for environmental benefits.

The "Inverted U" and the Tipping Point

The most significant finding of this research is the non-linear relationship between digital trade and carbon emissions. The study identifies an "Inverted U-shape" trajectory, suggesting that the environmental impact of digital trade changes as a nation develops.

Using Hansen’s panel threshold model, the researchers identified a specific development threshold at an index value of 0.142:

  • Below the Threshold (0.142): Digital trade growth is positively correlated with carbon emissions (coefficient of 0.535). In these early stages, the carbon footprint of building out servers, networks, and increasing production outweighs the efficiency gains.
  • Above the Threshold (0.142): The relationship flips, and digital trade begins to exert a significant "low-carbon effect" (coefficient of -0.051). At this stage, technological spillovers and industrial upgrades—such as the shift from heavy manufacturing to digital services—drive a net reduction in CO2.

Conclusion and Policy Implications

The study confirms that while digital trade is a powerful tool for decarbonization, its benefits are not immediate. There is a clear "digital divide": developed nations like the United States, Germany, and Singapore have largely crossed the threshold into the low-carbon phase, while many developing nations remain on the upward slope of the carbon curve.

Policy efforts should focus on helping developing countries leapfrog the carbon-intensive infrastructure phase. International cooperation in digital skills training and the deployment of energy-efficient digital infrastructure is essential to ensure that the global transition to digital trade supports, rather than hinders, climate goals.

Summary updated

Abstract

Digital trade, as one of the vanguards of the global technological revolution and industrial transformation, empowers low-carbon economic cooperation on a global scale. This study based on panel data from 2007 to 2021 of 46 countries with varied development levels, constructed a multi-dimensional indicator system from six aspects: trade potential, digital infrastructure, digital innovation, digital skills and security, scale of digital trade, and digital trade environment, aim to measure the development level of digital trade and explore its impact on carbon emissions, followed by a heterogeneity analysis. The research results indicate that there are significant differences in the development levels of digital trade among countries with different economic strengths. Countries with stronger economic power and larger trade scales have a higher level of digital trade development, while less developed regions lag in digital trade. As the level of digital trade development increases, the impact of digital trade on carbon emissions will also change. Overall, digital trade exhibits a pronounced low-carbon effect, while its impact varies among countries with different development levels.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2024impact,
  author = {Xiuxiang Li and Yan Hu and Liang Ding and Qiyu Huang and Yi Jiang},
  title = {{Impact of the digital trade on lowering carbon emissions in 46 countries}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-76586-5},
}
Figure