Impact of symmetry-breaking of non-fullerene acceptors for efficient and stable organic solar cells

Peddaboodi Gopikrishna, Huijeong Choi, Do Hui Kim, Jun Ho Hwang, Youngwan Lee, Hyeonwoo Jung, Gyeonghwa Yu, Telugu Bhim Raju, Eunji Lee, Youngu Lee, Shinuk Cho, BongSoo KimChemical 2021 · DOI

Introduction

Organic solar cells (OSCs) offer a lightweight, flexible, and low-cost alternative to traditional silicon photovoltaics. However, widespread adoption is hindered by two primary challenges: the efficiency trade-off and morphological instability. In OSC design, improving light absorption often leads to a decrease in open-circuit voltage ($V_{OC}$), and vice versa. Furthermore, the active layer—a blend of donor and acceptor molecules—tends to degrade as molecules rearrange or as metal atoms from electrodes diffuse into the device. This study explores how "symmetry-breaking"—the use of two different end-groups on a single non-fullerene acceptor (NFA) molecule—can simultaneously address these performance and stability hurdles.

Methodology

Researchers synthesized a novel asymmetric NFA, IPC-BEH-IC2F, featuring a central electron-donating core (BEH) flanked by two distinct electron-accepting units: a tricyclic fused IPC group and a fluorinated IC2F group. For comparison, symmetric NFAs (IPC-BEH-IPC and IC2F-BEH-IC2F) were also characterized.

The team employed a comprehensive suite of analytical tools:

  • Density Functional Theory (DFT): To model molecular geometry and calculate dipole moments.
  • Spectroscopy & Voltammetry: UV-Vis and Cyclic Voltammetry (CV) were used to measure light absorption and electronic energy levels.
  • Morphological Analysis: GIWAXS and AFM visualized molecular packing in thin films.
  • Diffusion Tracking: Cross-sectional TEM and EDS tracked the migration of silver (Ag) atoms from the electrode into the active layer over a 2,000-hour period.

Key Insights

The asymmetric design of IPC-BEH-IC2F provides several strategic advantages:

  • The Dipole Advantage: Breaking molecular symmetry creates a permanent dipole moment (13.30 D), which facilitates exciton separation and promotes more ordered molecular packing compared to symmetric versions.
  • Optimized Energy Levels: The asymmetric molecule’s HOMO and LUMO levels are positioned between those of the two symmetric counterparts. This allows for broader light absorption than the IPC-only version while maintaining a higher voltage than the IC2F-only version.
  • Enhanced Crystallinity: The IPC unit, with its tricyclic fused system, promotes superior molecular stacking. This increases the overall crystallinity of the blend, leading to more efficient charge transport.
  • Physical Barrier to Degradation: The dense, crystalline packing of the IPC-containing blend acts as a physical shield, effectively resisting the diffusion of silver atoms from the top electrode—a common cause of device failure.

Results

The performance of the asymmetric NFA was benchmarked using PBDB-T and PM6 as p-type polymer donors:

  • Efficiency: The PBDB-T:IPC-BEH-IC2F device achieved a Power Conversion Efficiency (PCE) of 12.70%, significantly higher than the symmetric IPC (7.26%) or IC2F (11.05%) versions.
  • Voltage Improvement: The asymmetric design raised the $V_{OC}$ to 0.85 V, compared to 0.70 V for standard symmetric IC2F-based devices.
  • Long-term Stability: In unencapsulated air-stability tests, the asymmetric device retained over 77% of its initial PCE after 1,000 hours. By comparison, common high-performance pairings like PM6:IC2F-BEH-IC2F suffered severe failure.
  • Ag Diffusion Resistance: TEM/EDS analysis confirmed that the asymmetric blend significantly slowed silver atom penetration, preserving the integrity of the active layer.

Conclusion

The results demonstrate that asymmetric structural modification of NFAs is a highly effective strategy for improving both the photovoltaic performance and the long-term stability of OSCs. While the current efficiency of 12.7% is notable, future research will focus on applying this asymmetry strategy to higher-performing "Y6-series" derivatives to push efficiencies toward 20%. Additionally, investigating more robust electrode materials could further enhance the commercial viability of these stable, high-efficiency organic solar cells.

Summary updated

Abstract

The concurrent enhancement of short-circuit current (<i>J</i> <sub>SC</sub>) and open-circuit voltage (<i>V</i> <sub>OC</sub>) is a key problem in the preparation of efficient organic solar cells (OSCs). In this paper, we report efficient and stable OSCs based on an asymmetric non-fullerene acceptor (NFA) IPC-BEH-IC2F. The NFA consists of a weak electron-donor core dithienothiophen[3,2-<i>b</i>]-pyrrolobenzothiadiazole (BEH) and two kinds of strong electron-acceptor (A) units [9<i>H</i>-indeno[1,2-<i>b</i>]pyrazine-2,3-dicarbonitrile (IPC) with a tricyclic fused system and 2-(5,6-difluoro-3-oxo-2,3-dihydro-1<i>H</i>-inden-1-ylidene)malononitrile (IC2F)]. For comparison, the symmetric NFAs IPC-BEH-IPC and IC2F-BEH-IC2F were characterised. The kind of flanking A unit significantly affects the light absorption features and electronic structures of the NFAs. The asymmetric IPC-BEH-IC2F has the highest extinction coefficient among the three NFAs owing to its strong dipole moment and highly crystalline feature. Its highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) and lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) levels lie between those of the IPC-BEH-IPC and IC2F-BEH-IC2F molecules. The IPC group also promotes molecular packing through the tricyclic π-conjugated system and achieves increased crystallinity compared to that of the IC2F group. Inverted-type photovoltaic devices based on p-type polymer:NFA blends with PBDB-T and PM6 polymers as p-type polymers were fabricated. Among all these devices, the PBDB-T:IPC-BEH-IC2F blend device displayed the best photovoltaic properties because the IPC unit provides balanced electronic and morphological characteristics. More importantly, the PBDB-T:IPC-BEH-IC2F-based device exhibited the best long-term stability owing to the strongly interacting IPC moiety and the densely packed PBDB-T:IPC-BEH-IC2F film. These results demonstrate that asymmetric structural modifications of NFAs are an effective way for simultaneously improving the photovoltaic performance and stability of OSCs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gopikrishna2021impact,
  author = {Peddaboodi Gopikrishna and Huijeong Choi and Do Hui Kim and Jun Ho Hwang and Youngwan Lee and Hyeonwoo Jung and Gyeonghwa Yu and Telugu Bhim Raju and Eunji Lee and Youngu Lee and Shinuk Cho and BongSoo Kim},
  title = {{Impact of symmetry-breaking of non-fullerene acceptors for efficient and stable organic solar cells}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1039/d1sc04153c},
}
Figure