Abstract
Outward foreign direct investment (OFDI) has grown rapidly in China over the past decade, influencing home country employment through both substitute and supplemental effects. This paper analyzes the mechanisms by which OFDI alters domestic employment, examining the relationship between China's OFDI and both employment quality (wages) and quantity. Empirical results indicate a robust positive relationship between OFDI and the domestic labor market in China. In contrast, a comparative analysis of the Euro area suggests no significant impact of OFDI on home country employment. As an emerging economy undergoing structural reform, China’s employment landscape benefits significantly from outward internationalization.
Introduction
Economists have long debated the "hollowing out" effect: the fear that domestic companies investing heavily abroad leads to job losses at home. This phenomenon is typically explained by two competing forces. The Substitute Effect suggests that companies offshoring production to lower-cost regions creates structural unemployment in the home country. Conversely, the Supplementary Effect posits that overseas expansion necessitates increased high-level management, legal, and financial support at headquarters, while also opening new markets for domestic intermediate goods.
This study investigates which effect dominates by comparing China’s rapid investment expansion following its 2002 "Going Out" strategy with the established economies of the Euro area.
Methodology
The research utilizes an empirical approach based on Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) regression. Variables were log-transformed to linearize relationships and allow coefficients to be interpreted as elasticities—measuring the percentage change in employment for every percentage change in investment.
Three primary models were constructed:
- Employment Quantity (China): Total employed staff regressed against OFDI flows and net exports.
- Employment Quality (China): Average wage levels regressed against OFDI flows and net exports.
- Comparative Model (Euro Area): A similar regression applied to the Euro area to identify differences between emerging and developed economies.
Data was sourced from the National Bureau of Statistics of China, the IMF, and UNCTAD, covering the period from 1999 to 2013.
Empirical Analysis and Results
The Chinese Context
Analysis of the Chinese data reveals a strong positive correlation between outward investment and domestic labor metrics. Both the quantity and quality models for China showed high goodness of fit ($R^2$ values of 0.948 and 0.972, respectively). The OFDI variable passed t-tests at a 99% confidence interval, confirming its role as a driver of domestic employment growth.
The regression equations derived for China are:
- Quantity: $\ln(Employment) \approx 11.007 + 0.021 \ln(OFDI)$
- Quality: $\ln(Wage) \approx 4.378 + 0.489 \ln(OFDI)$
These positive coefficients (0.021 and 0.489) demonstrate that for China, the supplementary effect outweighs the substitute effect. OFDI is often market-seeking or resource-driven, which improves the supply side of the home economy and creates high-value "parent company" roles.
Comparative Analysis: The Euro Area
In contrast to the Chinese results, the Euro area model showed that OFDI did not have a statistically significant impact on employment levels. Instead, exports remained the primary driver of employment in these developed economies.
Discussion and Conclusion
The findings suggest that the impact of OFDI is not universal but depends on a country's developmental stage. For an emerging economy like China, internationalization acts as a catalyst for domestic growth and structural reform. While developed economies in the Euro area show neutrality toward OFDI's employment effects, China’s unique position allows it to leverage global investment to enhance both the number of jobs and the level of wages.
Limitations
This macro-level study does not account for industry-specific shifts, where manufacturing might decline while services grow. Additionally, the decade-long window may not capture long-term "hollowing out" effects that manifest over generations. Future research should incorporate sector-level analysis and control for variables such as technological automation and domestic policy shifts.
Summary updated