Impact of Labor Migration on Chemical Fertilizer Application of Citrus Growers: Empirical Evidence from China

Ruixin Zhang, Lei Luo, Yuying Liu, Xinhong FuSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how rural-to-urban labor migration in China impacts citrus farmers' chemical fertilizer use. It finds that migration, surprisingly, leads to a reduction in fertilizer application, primarily by increasing farmers' access to green production knowledge and off-farm income. This effect is more pronounced among younger farmers and those with higher agricultural incomes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China, like many developing nations, is experiencing significant rural-to-urban migration. This shift in labor allocation has profound implications for agricultural practices. While migration is known to boost household income, its effect on agricultural input decisions, particularly chemical fertilizer use, is complex and debated. Overuse of chemical fertilizers is a major environmental concern, impacting soil health and water quality. This paper aims to clarify the relationship between labor migration and chemical fertilizer application among citrus growers, a crucial cash crop in China, to inform sustainable agricultural practices.

Methods

The researchers employed a Propensity Score Matching (PSM) method to address the self-selection bias inherent in labor migration decisions. This approach creates a counterfactual scenario by matching migrant households with similar non-migrant households based on observable characteristics. This allows for a more robust estimation of the causal effect of labor migration.

Additionally, a mediating effect test (stepwise test) was used to explore the pathways through which labor migration influences fertilizer application. This involved examining the roles of increased off-farm income and improved access to green production information and technology.

Datasets

The study utilized survey data from 814 citrus growers in Sichuan Province, China, collected in July and August 2020. The questionnaire covered various aspects, including citrus production inputs and costs, household characteristics, and labor migration status.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Migration as a Green Catalyst: Counterintuitively, labor migration doesn't lead to increased fertilizer use as some theories might suggest (e.g., labor substitution). Instead, it appears to foster more sustainable practices.
  • Knowledge Transfer is Key: A significant finding is that migrant farmers gain access to better information and technology related to green agricultural production, which directly influences their decision to reduce chemical fertilizer use.
  • Off-Farm Income as an Enabler: Increased off-farm income from migration provides financial resources that can be reinvested in more sustainable, albeit potentially more expensive, farming methods.
  • Demographic and Economic Nuances: The impact of migration isn't uniform. Younger farmers and those with higher agricultural incomes are more likely to reduce fertilizer use when they migrate, suggesting that human capital and existing farm investment play a role.

Key Results

  • Overall Reduction in Fertilizer Use: The average chemical fertilizer application per acre decreased by 3.06% (from 6.95 to 6.74) after farmers engaged in labor migration.
  • Mediating Effects:
    • Off-farm income from migration had a partly mediating influence on reducing fertilizer application.
  • Improved access to green production information and technology also played a partly mediating role.
  • Heterogeneity:
    • Younger farmers showed a more significant reduction in fertilizer application due to labor migration compared to older farmers.
  • Farmers with high agricultural income also exhibited a greater reduction in fertilizer use when migrating.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study is based on survey data from a specific region (Sichuan Province), which may limit the generalizability of the findings to other regions or crop types. While PSM helps control for observable differences, unobservable factors influencing migration decisions could still introduce bias.

Future research could explore:

  • The long-term impacts of labor migration on agricultural sustainability.
  • The specific types of green production knowledge and technologies that are most influential.
  • The role of government policies in guiding migration and promoting green agriculture.
  • Comparative studies across different agricultural sectors and geographical regions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Due to the growing trend of rural labor migration, farmers’ labor allocation under the condition of constant time endowment has gradually become a key factor in the transformation of green agricultural production methods. Using the propensity score matching method, this paper verified the influence of labor migration on citrus growers’ fertilizer application using 814 survey data from Sichuan Province, China. The study found that the boosting effect of capacity accumulation brought on by farmers’ labor migration was greater than the weakening effect of labor constraints and that the average chemical fertilizer application per acre decreased from 6.95 to 6.74 after farmers’ labor migration, a 3.06 percent decrease. Second, labor migration reduces chemical fertilizer application by allowing farmers to acquire knowledge and technology for green agricultural production and to increase off-farm income. Third, the choice of labor migration by farmers with higher agricultural incomes and younger ages promotes a reduction in their chemical fertilizer application. Therefore, this paper makes the following suggestions: the government should appropriately guide farmers in their labor migration decisions, increase public awareness of green agricultural knowledge and technology, and encourage farmers to to invest their off-farm income in green production. Farmers with higher agricultural income and younger ages, in particular, should be encouraged to choose labor migration and train to become new agricultural business entities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022impact,
  author = {Ruixin Zhang and Lei Luo and Yuying Liu and Xinhong Fu},
  title = {{Impact of Labor Migration on Chemical Fertilizer Application of Citrus Growers: Empirical Evidence from China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14137526},
}
Figure