Impact of Intubator’s Training Level on First-Pass Success of Endotracheal Intubation in Acute Care Settings: A Four-Center Retrospective Study

Jung Heon Kim, Jae-Yun Jung, Joong-Wan Park, Se-Uk Lee, Meong Hi Son, Jeong‐Yong LeeChildren 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated factors influencing first-pass success (FPS) in pediatric endotracheal intubations, finding that experienced intubators and older children (≥12 months) significantly increase the likelihood of success. The findings underscore the critical role of clinical expertise in improving intubation outcomes, especially for vulnerable infants.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Endotracheal intubation in children, particularly in emergency settings, is notoriously challenging and carries a higher risk of complications compared to adults. A key metric for success is "first-pass success" (FPS), meaning the procedure is successful on the initial attempt. Low FPS rates can lead to prolonged procedures, increased risk of desaturation (a dangerous drop in blood oxygen levels), and potentially worse patient outcomes, especially in infants who are more susceptible to hypoxia. While factors like patient age and medical condition are known to influence FPS, the specific impact of the intubator's training level, especially in diverse acute care settings, needed further clarification. This paper aims to identify factors associated with FPS in children under 10 years old in Korean emergency departments, with a particular focus on the intubator's experience.

Methods

This was a retrospective study analyzing data from four Korean academic hospitals between 2016 and 2019. The researchers collected data on children under 10 years old who underwent endotracheal intubation within 24 hours of arrival. They defined "experienced intubator" as a senior resident (PGY 4-5) or a specialist, irrespective of their specific medical specialty. They then compared variables between children who achieved FPS and those who did not. A logistic regression model was employed to quantify the association of various factors with FPS, adjusting for potential confounders.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 280 children who underwent endotracheal intubation across four Korean academic hospitals between January 2016 and December 2019. This dataset was a secondary analysis of a larger study on the factors influencing the use of rapid sequence intubation (RSI). No new benchmarks were introduced; the focus was on analyzing existing clinical data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Experience Trumps Specialty (to an extent): While previous studies have hinted at the importance of specific specialties (like Emergency Medicine or Pediatrics), this study found that being an "experienced intubator" (senior resident or specialist) was a significant predictor of FPS, even when controlling for other factors. This suggests that the depth of training and practice, rather than just the initial specialty, is crucial.
  • Infants are a High-Risk Group: The study reinforces that intubating infants (<12 months) is significantly more challenging, with a lower FPS rate. This is likely due to their smaller airways and higher susceptibility to desaturation.
  • Clinical Competence is Key: The findings strongly suggest that investing in the development and deployment of clinically competent intubators is paramount for improving pediatric intubation outcomes. This implies a need for robust training programs and potentially ensuring experienced personnel are available for critical procedures.

Key Results

  • Out of 280 children studied, 169 (60.4%) achieved first-pass success (FPS).
  • Children with FPS were significantly older (median age 23.0 vs. 11.0 months) and less likely to be infants (36.1% vs. 50.5%).
  • Children with FPS were also less likely to have respiratory compromise (41.4% vs. 55.0%).
  • Experienced intubators were associated with a nearly twofold increase in the odds of FPS (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] 1.93; 95% CI, 1.01–3.67; p = 0.047).
  • Children aged 12 months or older also had significantly higher odds of FPS (aOR 1.84; 95% CI, 1.13–3.02; p = 0.015).
  • Desaturation was significantly rarer in children with FPS (10.1%) compared to those without FPS (53.2%).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Setting Specificity: The study was conducted in Korean academic hospitals, which might have more resources than austere settings, potentially limiting the generalizability of findings.
  • Underestimation of Outcomes: The procedural outcomes of experienced intubators might be underestimated because they are often called upon for more complex or difficult cases.
  • Unmeasured Variables: Factors like the use of video laryngoscopy (which can improve visualization) and detailed information on individual skill levels were not assessed.
  • ED-Success Time: The time taken for intubation in the ED might overestimate delays for children who were initially stable but deteriorated later in the ICU.
  • Underreporting of Adverse Events: Some peri-intubation adverse events might have been underreported.

Future work could focus on:

  • High-Fidelity Simulation: The authors suggest that high-fidelity simulation can enhance novices' intubating skills, especially given the infrequent nature of pediatric intubations. They recommend regular simulation sessions (every 3-8 months).
  • Deploying Experienced Intubators: In the short term, deploying experienced intubators to EDs and ICUs could improve outcomes.
  • Developing Clinical Competence: Long-term strategies should focus on developing clinical competence through ongoing simulation.

Summary updated

Abstract

(1) Background: First-pass success (FPS) of endotracheal intubation is more challenging in children than in adults. We aimed to identify factors associated with FPS of intubation in acute care settings. (2) Methods: We analyzed data of children aged <10 years who underwent intubation within ≤24 h of arrival at four Korean emergency departments (2016−2019). Variables were compared according to FPS. A logistic regression was performed to quantify the association of factors with FPS. An experienced intubator was defined as a senior resident or a specialist. (3) Results: Of 280 children, 169 (60.4%) had FPS. The children with FPS were older (median age, 23.0 vs. 11.0 months; p = 0.018), were less frequently in their infancy (36.1% vs. 50.5%; p = 0.017), and were less likely to have respiratory compromise (41.4% vs. 55.0%; p = 0.030). The children with FPS tended to be more often intubated by experienced intubators than those without FPS (87.0% vs. 78.4%; p = 0.057). Desaturation was rarer in those with FPS. Factors associated with FPS were experienced intubators (aOR, 1.93; 95% CI, 1.01−3.67) and children’s age ≥12 months (1.84; 1.13−3.02). (4) Conclusion: FPS of intubation can be facilitated by deploying or developing clinically competent intubators, particularly for infants, in acute care settings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kim2022impact,
  author = {Jung Heon Kim and Jae-Yun Jung and Joong-Wan Park and Se-Uk Lee and Meong Hi Son and Jeong‐Yong Lee},
  title = {{Impact of Intubator’s Training Level on First-Pass Success of Endotracheal Intubation in Acute Care Settings: A Four-Center Retrospective Study}},
  booktitle = {Children},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/children9070960},
}
Figure