Abstract
Background: As we contend with the massive SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, preventing infections among healthcare workers (HCWs) and patients is critical for delivering care to patients admitted for other purposes, and many standard scheduling practices require reassessment. In most academic hospitals in the United States, inpatient rotations are designed to deliver optimal patient care by staggering rotations of attendings and house-staff, and much emphasis is placed on HCW burnout, yet during a pandemic preventing further infection is the single most important factor.
Methods: Our purpose was to model various inpatient rotation schedules of physicians and nurses to determine patterns associated with optimal workforce preservation and lower nosocomial infections in settings in which personal protective equipment is imperfect or unavailable. We simulated the spread of COVID-19 in hospital wards using Monte Carlo methods. Universal model parameters for COVID-19 included incubation period distribution and latent period distribution. Situation-dependent COVID-19 model parameters included pre-admission infection probability, team member infection probability, physician-to-patient, nurse-to-patient, patient-to-physician, patient-to-nurse, and HCW-to-HCW transmission probabilities, team member absence after symptom onset, daily SARS-CoV-2 exposure probability of team members, length of admission after COVID-19 symptoms, and length of simulation time.
Results: The primary outcome measure was probability of team failure, defined as the likelihood that at some point there are insufficient attendings, house-staff or nurses to staff a fully functioning floor. In all of our simulations, physician and nurse rotation lengths of 1-3 days led to higher team failure rates. Nursing shifts of 12 versus 8 hours and avoiding staggering of physician rotations also decreased the chance of team failure.
Conclusions: Simple changes in staff scheduling, such as lengthening nursing shifts or avoiding rotations that are either staggered or last fewer than three days, can result in improved workforce preservation. These workforce scheduling changes are easy to implement.
Introduction
In standard academic hospital settings, rotations for doctors and nurses are often "staggered." For example, an attending physician might start their rotation mid-week while residents start on Monday to ensure continuity of care. While beneficial for medical education and patient handoffs, this creates a complex web of overlapping interactions. During the COVID-19 pandemic, healthcare workers (HCWs) became highly vulnerable. This study argues that in a crisis where workforce preservation is the top priority, traditional staggered schedules may inadvertently accelerate viral spread. The goal was to identify scheduling patterns that minimize nosocomial infections and prevent "team failure"—a state where a ward lacks enough healthy staff to function.
Methods
The researchers developed a stochastic simulator using Monte Carlo methods to model the spread of SARS-CoV-2 within a hospital ward over 180 days. The model simulates daily interactions between physicians, nurses, and patients, incorporating viral dynamics such as incubation periods (median 5.1 days) and latent periods.
The simulation tested several variables:
- Shift Duration: 8-hour vs. 12-hour nursing shifts.
- Synchronization: Staggered vs. un-staggered rotations.
- Continuity: Consecutive vs. alternating work days.
The primary metric, Team Failure, occurs if the pool of healthy, available staff drops below the minimum required to run the floor or if nurses exceed a 48-hour work week due to staffing shortages. The model relies on epidemiological parameters derived from early 2020 COVID-19 literature.
Key Insights: Temporal Distancing
The most effective schedules act as a form of "social distancing in time." By having staff work longer blocks of consecutive days followed by longer blocks off, the number of unique HCWs exposed to a single infectious individual is reduced.
- The Danger of Short Rotations: Rotations of 1–3 days were consistently the worst performers. Frequent cycling increases the "surface area" for the virus to jump from asymptomatic carriers to fresh groups of susceptible workers.
- Un-staggering as a Shield: Synchronizing the start and end dates for the whole team creates "clean" breaks that can break the chain of transmission.
- 12-Hour Shifts: Moving from 8-hour to 12-hour shifts reduces the number of shift changes and the total number of nurses required on-site, lowering the overall infection rate.
Results
The simulation results clearly demonstrate the impact of scheduling on workforce preservation.
- Rotation Length: In all simulations, physician and nurse rotation lengths of 1–3 days led to significantly higher team failure rates. The probability of team failure was notably lower when all HCWs worked at least 3–4 consecutive days.
- Shift Duration and Synchronization: 12-hour nursing shifts were superior to 8-hour shifts, and avoiding the staggering of rotations (un-staggering) further decreased the chance of team failure.
Limitations and Conclusion
While 12-hour shifts and long blocks of work preserve the number of healthy workers, they may increase physical and mental exhaustion—factors not quantified in this model. Additionally, the benefits of un-staggering rotations depend on the latent period of the virus; if the latent period is significantly shorter than 4 days, these benefits may decrease.
In conclusion, simple, easy-to-implement changes in staff scheduling—such as lengthening nursing shifts to 12 hours and avoiding staggered rotations of fewer than three days—can significantly improve workforce preservation during a pandemic. These strategies provide a vital tool for hospital administrators to protect their staff and maintain care capacity.
Summary updated