Impact of Daily Operations of Cascade Hydropower Stations on Reservoir Flow Fluctuation Characteristics

Jia Zhu, Hao Fan, Yun Deng, Min Chen, Jingying LuWater 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the combined daily operations of upstream and downstream hydropower stations (joint daily operation) impact water level fluctuations (WLFs) in a cascade reservoir system. Using a 1D hydrodynamic model, the research reveals that joint operations lead to more complex wave interactions and energy dissipation, ultimately reducing WLF amplitudes but potentially expanding areas prone to slope instability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Hydropower stations, especially when integrated with solar power (hydro-PV complementarity), are crucial for clean energy. However, their daily operation, driven by electricity demand and grid stability needs, creates periodic water level fluctuations (WLFs) in reservoirs. These WLFs can propagate as waves, affecting reservoir hydrodynamics, navigation, and even bank slope stability. While previous research often focused on individual stations, this paper addresses a critical gap: understanding the cumulative impact of joint daily operations of cascade hydropower stations on reservoir flow characteristics. This is particularly relevant as China aims to balance energy needs with environmental concerns, making optimized cascade operation essential.

Methods

The researchers employed a one-dimensional (1D) unsteady flow hydrodynamic model to simulate water level and discharge fluctuations within the Wudongde Reservoir. This model is based on the Navier-Stokes equations, adapted for open-channel flow. To analyze the wave propagation and energy dissipation, they utilized:

  • Power Spectral Density (PSD) analysis: To understand the frequency distribution of WLFs and identify wave energy characteristics.
  • Cross-correlation analysis: To determine wave propagation times between different sections of the reservoir, allowing for the calculation of wave velocities.
  • Attenuation Rate Calculation: Fitting trend lines to PSD-distance graphs to quantify how wave energy decays along the river channel, distinguishing between exponential and linear decay.

The model was calibrated and validated using measured data from the Wudongde Reservoir.

Datasets

The study utilized measured data from the Wudongde Reservoir on the Jinsha River for model calibration and validation. Specifically, data from November 11-13, 2020, were used. The upstream boundary conditions were derived from the Sanduizi hydrological station, and downstream boundary conditions from the Wudongde dam site. The paper also defines 11 distinct scenarios to simulate various operational conditions, including natural outflow, daily scheduling, constant inflow/outflow, and combinations thereof, across wet and dry seasons, and at different reservoir water levels (RWLs).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Wave Interactions are Key: The core idea is that the interaction between waves propagating from upstream and downstream operations is a significant factor in energy dissipation and WLF reduction. This goes beyond simply summing individual station impacts.
  • Spatial Variation in Decay: Wave energy doesn't decay uniformly. It exhibits exponential decay in the reservoir tail and linear decay in the main reservoir area, suggesting that different parts of the reservoir respond differently to operational changes.
  • Wave Type Transition: The nature of the waves changes with water depth. In shallower areas (reservoir tail), they behave more like kinematic waves, while in deeper areas (main reservoir), they become dynamic waves, leading to faster propagation.
  • Slope Stability Implications: While joint operations can reduce the rate of water level decline, they can also expand the spatial extent of areas vulnerable to slope instability, particularly at the reservoir tail and near the dam. This highlights a trade-off between mitigating rapid fluctuations and managing long-term bank stability.

Key Results

  • Accelerated Wave Propagation: Reservoir impoundment significantly increases wave velocity. During normal storage, wave velocity is approximately six times higher in the wet season and nine times higher in the dry season compared to natural conditions.
  • Reduced WLF Amplitude: Joint daily operations (JDOCPS) lead to a more pronounced reduction in WLF amplitudes compared to individual upstream (DOUPS) or downstream (DODPS) operations, especially in the main reservoir area. Minimum amplitudes were observed around 150 km from the dam.
  • Energy Dissipation: Wave energy dissipates faster under JDOCPS. Exponential decay was observed in the reservoir tail, and linear decay in the main reservoir.
  • Slope Instability Risk: The maximum rate of water level decline, a critical factor for slope stability, was analyzed. JDOCPS can lead to the largest potential instability ranges, particularly at the reservoir tail and pre-dam sections, compared to DOUPS or DODPS.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Limited Validation Period: Model validation was constrained to a 3-day period during the dry season due to data availability. Future work should expand validation to include multiple seasons and dispatch scenarios to enhance robustness.
  • Operational Range: The study focused on typical low and normal storage levels (952m and 975m RWL). Future simulations should explore a broader spectrum of RWLs and cross-sectional geometries to improve generalizability.
  • 1D Model Limitations: The 1D model cannot resolve lateral and vertical flow structures. Future research should consider 2D or 3D modeling for localized zones (e.g., confluences, bays) to capture complex flow patterns. Coupling with ecological response modules is also suggested.
  • System Specificity: The proposed modeling framework is particularly suited for steeply incised cascade reservoirs. Adapting it for low-gradient systems with complex lateral exchanges and floodplain inundation will require higher-dimensional approaches.

Future work should also focus on real-time data acquisition, improving computational efficiency, and enhancing coordination among management agencies for practical application.

Summary updated

Abstract

The daily operation of cascade hydropower stations induces periodic water level fluctuations (WLFs) that propagate as gravity waves, significantly affecting the hydrodynamics of reservoirs. Previous studies have mainly focused on the effects of individual stations, with little attention paid to the combined impacts of upstream and downstream operations. Taking the Wudongde Reservoir on the Jinsha River as a case study, we used a one-dimensional hydrodynamic model and cross-correlation analysis to simulate flow fluctuation patterns under joint daily operations. The results show that fluctuations from upstream stations attenuate rapidly in the reservoir, with greater attenuation during the dry season. Under joint operations, wave energy decayed exponentially near the reservoir tail and linearly in the main reservoir area, leading to a further reduction in the WLF amplitudes. The interactions between upstream- and downstream-propagating waves enhance energy dissipation. The wave type transitioned from kinematic to dynamic as the water depth increased. During the wet and dry seasons, the average wave velocities were approximately six and nine times higher, respectively, than those under natural conditions. Joint operations expand the range of potential slope instability but reduce the WLF rate compared to natural flows. These findings provide a scientific reference for optimising the daily operations of cascade hydropower stations and mitigating their ecological impacts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2025impact,
  author = {Jia Zhu and Hao Fan and Yun Deng and Min Chen and Jingying Lu},
  title = {{Impact of Daily Operations of Cascade Hydropower Stations on Reservoir Flow Fluctuation Characteristics}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/w17111608},
}
Figure